Practice prompt · Q:financial-reporting-environment-and-framework/memo-analysis-critique-001

Critique quotation-only memo analysis

Identify what a memo needs beyond quotations to support an accounting conclusion.

Updated Sep 6, 2026 Review due Nov 7, 2026
Practice

Check your answer

Choose a response, then check the answer and explanation.

A draft memo quotes three paragraphs, says “therefore the treatment is appropriate,” and lists no facts, alternative, open items, or accounting effects. Which revision most improves the analysis?

Choose the best answer.

Your answer stays on this page. It is not sent or saved.

Show explanationHide explanation

Answer: a

Choice a. A useful memo explains how applicable guidance and evidence support the conclusion. It addresses contrary evidence and missing facts, rather than hiding them behind quotations or a claim that judgment was used.