Check your answer
Write your response and explain your reasoning.
Northstar's draft note states:
Inventory is $150,000 and is stated at the lower of cost or market using FIFO. Inventory write-downs were $1,800.
The close file lists $96,000 merchandise under FIFO, $24,000 service parts under LIFO, and a $30,000 average-cost retail-method pool. A same-date and same-scope comparison shows $44,000 under FIFO and $36,500 under LIFO. Supported write-down schedules show $1,800 for merchandise and $1,200 for service parts.
Reconcile the class total, LIFO reserve, and write-down total. Treat all three inventory classes as material. Explain why the policy sentence does not describe the methods and measurement rules actually used for the three classes.
Go beyond this course
A complete disclosure review and conversion between reporting frameworks extend beyond this course's inventory-note interpretation. For this optional extension, identify the company facts and US GAAP disclosure requirements you would need to inspect before concluding that the note is complete.
Then explain why replacing the words US GAAP with IFRS cannot establish IFRS compliance. Consider method eligibility, measurement, and recoveries. A numerical conversion would also require information not supplied in this question.
Compare your reasoning with the worked answer
Merchandise of $96,000, service parts of $24,000, and the retail pool of $30,000 total $150,000. The same-scope FIFO comparison of $44,000 less the $36,500 LIFO amount gives a $7,500 reserve. The $1,800 and $1,200 write-downs total $3,000, so the draft's $1,800 statement omits one supplied population.
The policy sentence is unsupported. Northstar uses FIFO for merchandise, LIFO for service parts, and an average-cost retail method for the store pool. The note should identify those methods separately. FIFO merchandise uses lower of cost and NRV; LIFO and retail-method goods use lower of cost or market. The stated policy incorrectly applies one method and measurement rule to all three classes.
For the optional extension, a complete disclosure review also needs facts about significant policy changes, unusual losses, commitments, and other applicable requirements. An IFRS comparison must account for the prohibition on LIFO and the different measurement and reversal requirements. Those facts are not supplied, so the amounts cannot simply be relabeled as IFRS amounts.