Check your answer
Write your response and explain your reasoning.
Northstar applies US GAAP and measures each of the following inventory items separately at year-end. All figures are amounts for one item.
| Given information | FIFO item | LIFO item |
|---|---|---|
| Recorded cost | $1,120 | $1,010 |
| Expected selling price | $1,200 | |
| Remaining completion costs | $80 | |
| Remaining disposal costs | $35 | |
| Remaining transportation costs | $25 | |
| NRV, already calculated | $1,080 | |
| Normal profit allowance | $140 | |
| Replacement cost | $900 |
Calculate net realizable value (NRV) for the FIFO item. Then calculate the carrying amount and write-down for each item, showing the LIFO ceiling, floor, and designated market. Explain why the LIFO replacement cost cannot be used without adjustment. State whether a later increase in NRV can reverse either fiscal-year-end write-down under US GAAP.
For the applicable requirements, consult ASC 330-10-35-1A through 35-1C and 35-14 in FASB's Inventory topic. Access may require registration.
Compare your reasoning with the worked answer
The FIFO item's NRV is $1,060: $1,200 selling price − $80 completion costs − $35 disposal costs − $25 transportation costs. The carrying amount is $1,060, below the $1,120 recorded cost. The write-down is $60.
For the LIFO item, NRV sets the ceiling at $1,080. The floor is $940: $1,080 NRV − $140 normal profit allowance. Replacement cost of $900 is below that floor, so designated market is $940. Comparing $1,010 recorded cost with $940 market gives a $70 write-down and a $940 carrying amount.
Using $900 would leave more than the supplied normal profit allowance between carrying amount and expected net sale proceeds. The floor limits that reduction. The FIFO item does not use the floor because its cost method requires a direct comparison with NRV.
Under US GAAP, each fiscal-year-end write-down establishes a new cost basis. A later increase in NRV does not reverse either loss. Separate guidance applies to interim reporting within the same fiscal year.