Case study · CASE:inventory-ownership-cost-flow-and-measurement/cedar-trail-inventory-close

Close Cedar Trail's inventory without pricing the wrong goods

Go beyond ACC 300: combine inventory calculations with professional research and disclosure review. Some questions deliberately require evidence not supplied on this page.

Updated Aug 8, 2026 Review due Nov 8, 2026
On this page
  1. Go beyond this course
  2. Case context
  3. Exhibit A — physical count and rights exceptions
  4. Exhibit B — sales cutoff and consignee activity
  5. Exhibit C — cost-pool exceptions
  6. Exhibit D — stipulated unit stream and method schedules
  7. Exhibit E — LIFO bridge and possible liquidation
  8. Exhibit F — measurement populations
  9. Exhibit G — future purchase contract
  10. Exhibit H — missing-evidence estimates
  11. Exhibit I — draft error and statement effects
  12. Exhibit J — draft note and IFRS request
  13. Assemble the advanced analysis
Decision brief

Your assignment

Role: Inventory accounting senior preparing Cedar Trail Outfitters' December 31 close for controller review

Deliverable: Inventory reconciliations, cost-flow schedules, measurement calculations, proposed entries, statement effects, disclosure analysis, source citations, and a list of missing evidence.

Evidence basis: fictional

Visible standard

Evaluation criteria

  • rights cutoff and cost population (25%): Identifies owned goods using the supplied contract and movement evidence. Treats transit and consignment correctly and includes only qualifying costs.
  • records cost flow and reconciliation (25%): Prepares periodic and perpetual records and compares specific identification, FIFO, average cost, and LIFO. Shows the cost layers and reconciles units and costs.
  • measurement estimates and errors (25%): Selects the appropriate measurement rule and explains write-downs and commitment losses. States the assumptions behind estimates and traces errors across accounts and periods.
  • disclosure authority and release (25%): Supports the inventory note with records and applicable guidance. Distinguishes US GAAP from IFRS and explains which missing facts prevent a final reporting conclusion.

Go beyond this course

This optional case extends beyond ACC 300's inventory calculations and error analysis into professional research, disclosure, and review of a reporting package. The numerical exhibits below can be worked from their stated assumptions. Other exhibits deliberately omit contract terms or supporting records. For those, identify the missing evidence and explain how it could change the accounting. You cannot complete a company-wide reporting conclusion from this page alone.

For Chapter 17 practice with complete facts, use the measurement question and inventory-error question.

Case context

Cedar Trail Outfitters, Inc. is a US retailer and light assembler with a December 31 year-end. Management states that its general-purpose financial statements follow US GAAP. You are the inventory accounting senior. The controller stopped the close when a 70-unit physical count was copied directly into a FIFO worksheet even though contracts, carrier records, and consignment reports were unresolved.

Use inventory units and US dollars. A fact marked stipulated for schedule work is an exercise input, not proof of the underlying accounting judgment. Cite the specific accounting guidance supporting each conclusion. Separate a calculation using supplied inputs from a judgment that needs additional evidence.

Exhibit A — physical count and rights exceptions

The main warehouse count lists 70 TrailCam units. The count team included 15 demonstration units supplied by North Ridge Components. Under their agreement, North Ridge retains ownership until Cedar Trail sells the goods to a customer. Cedar Trail shipped 12 of its own TrailCams to an independent retailer on consignment; the retailer reports that none sold by December 31. Eight more units are with a carrier.

For the 8 in transit, the purchase agreement, carrier acceptance, delivery requirement, insurance responsibility, redirection rights, and loss event are not assembled in one file. The invoice is dated December 29, the carrier scan December 30, receiving report January 3, and payable posting January 4.

List the goods by location and identify their owner. Reconcile the main count to owned inventory, leaving the 8 units unresolved until the contract terms establish when ownership transfers. Explain the corresponding payable treatment. Do not select December or January from the invoice or receipt date alone.

Exhibit B — sales cutoff and consignee activity

A customer order for 10 units was picked December 31, invoiced December 31, accepted by the carrier January 2, and delivered January 4. The executed terms and customer acceptance evidence are missing. Revenue was recorded December 31 and 10 units were removed from the perpetual record.

The consignee's January 5 report shows the 12 Cedar Trail units, no customer sale before year-end, one damaged box, and a proposed commission. Reconcile units, revenue, cost transfer, receivable, commission, damage evidence, and settlement. Delivery to the consignee is not itself a customer sale.

Exhibit C — cost-pool exceptions

The draft unit-cost pool includes:

  • ordinary supplier invoice price and inbound freight;
  • routine receiving and assembly labor supported by time records;
  • emergency air freight caused by Cedar Trail's scheduling mistake;
  • abnormal spoilage after a machine-control failure;
  • fixed overhead allocated using actual low output rather than documented normal capacity;
  • storage after finished goods were ready for sale; and
  • sales commissions.

Classify each amount as qualifying inventory cost, current-period charge, or unresolved research. Explain whether each cost brings the goods to their present location and condition. For allocated costs, identify the allocation base and why it is appropriate. Rebuild unit cost from the amounts that qualify for capitalization.

Exhibit D — stipulated unit stream and method schedules

After ownership and cost issues are separated, use this independent controlled stream for method calculation:

Event Units Unit cost
Opening layer 100 $10
Purchase 1 60 12
Sale 1 (120) —
Purchase 2 80 14
Sale 2 (50) —

Recompute periodic and perpetual FIFO and LIFO, periodic weighted average, and perpetual moving average. Explain why FIFO agrees here, why average and LIFO differ, and why none of those methods proves physical movement. Add one serial-numbered specific-identification row and state what makes its trace supportable.

The schedule should reproduce $2,840 goods available, 170 units sold, 70 units ending, and the six method results in the checked worked example. Every row must satisfy cost of goods sold plus ending inventory equals $2,840.

Exhibit E — LIFO bridge and possible liquidation

Cedar Trail's LIFO population has a same-date periodic FIFO comparison. Under the stipulated stream, FIFO ending inventory is $980 and LIFO ending inventory is $700. Prepare the $280 bounded reserve and explain which reserve amount bridges the balance sheet and which reserve change bridges period cost.

A separate pool fell by 20 units and released a layer carried at $8 per unit while current unit cost was $14. Quantify the $120 cost difference for review—20 × ($14 − $8)—but do not label it an operating gain without price, volume, mix, replacement, tax, and disclosure evidence. Relative to assigning current $14 cost, the old layer lowers cost of goods sold and raises pretax income by $120; that comparison is not a separate cash gain.

Exhibit F — measurement populations

Two independent items are stipulated for schedule work:

  1. An ordinary non-LIFO, non-retail-method item has $980 cost and $900 supported NRV.
  2. A LIFO item has $1,000 cost, $940 NRV, $880 replacement cost, and $100 approximately normal profit.

Reperform the $80 LCNRV write-down and the LIFO item's $940 ceiling, $840 floor, $880 designated market, and $120 write-down. Then explain what evidence would support the selling price, remaining costs, replacement cost, and normal profit allowance. Identify the comparison level and reporting date. Explain how changed estimates could affect the write-down; do not assume supplied exercise inputs establish conditions in company records.

Exhibit G — future purchase contract

Cedar Trail signed an order to buy 1,000 units next quarter for $12 each. Current spot price is $10.50. The file does not establish enforceability, cancellation, seller performance, indexed adjustments, expected use, hedging, related parties, or the current recognition and disclosure paragraph.

Keep the future contract separate from owned inventory. Explain when the agreement would require a loss, disclosure, or no entry. Identify which missing contract facts prevent a final conclusion. Do not record $1,500 merely by multiplying the spot-price difference.

Exhibit H — missing-evidence estimates

A fire destroyed one store's count evidence. For a bounded gross-profit estimate, use $20,000 beginning inventory, $80,000 net purchases, $120,000 net sales, and a stipulated 30 percent historical gross margin. Reproduce $16,000 estimated ending inventory and challenge the rate for mix, markdowns, returns, inflation, theft, damage, and purpose.

A different store's average-cost retail pool has $90,000 goods available at cost, $150,000 at retail, and $110,000 net sales. Reproduce the 60 percent ratio and $24,000 estimate. Identify missing markup, markdown, return, discount, transfer, shrinkage, and department-pool evidence. Do not silently convert the average-cost illustration into the conventional retail method.

Exhibit I — draft error and statement effects

The draft includes $5,000 of supplier-owned goods in ending inventory and incorrectly records their purchase and payable. The goods remain unsold. Cedar Trail neither owns them nor owes the supplier. Beginning inventory and all other transactions are correct. Use periodic accounting and ignore income taxes.

Trace the combined effects on Purchases, Inventory, Accounts Payable, Cost of Goods Sold, and income. Explain why unchanged income does not make the balance sheet correct. Describe the correction before closing and immediately after closing, before any later transactions. Identify which issued statements would need correction if the error were material.

Do not assume an opposite income error next year. Explain which later transactions or corrections you would need to know before tracing that period.

Exhibit J — draft note and IFRS request

The draft note says:

Inventory is stated at the lower of cost or market using FIFO. Management's estimates are reasonable, and all purchase commitments are recorded.

Cedar Trail uses FIFO, LIFO, and the average-cost retail method for different goods. It also has the two supplied write-downs, a LIFO reserve, and a possible liquidation. The fire-loss estimate and unresolved purchase commitment need separate consideration. Reconcile policy and amount language to the ledgers and workpapers. Identify the applicable US GAAP disclosure requirements and the facts needed to satisfy each requirement.

Management also asks for “the IFRS number.” Create a separate IAS 2 comparison column. State the FIFO/weighted-average/LIFO and lower-of-cost-and-NRV boundaries, but do not produce a conversion until the current Standard, application level, reversals, tax, transition, and opening-policy facts are researched.

Assemble the advanced analysis

Assemble in lesson order:

Packet cluster Primary support
Locations, rights, transit, consignment, and cutoff Lesson 00
Qualifying cost and periodic/perpetual controls Lesson 01
Specific units, layers, FIFO, average, LIFO, reserve, and liquidation Lessons 02–04
NRV, market, write-downs, and purchase commitments Lessons 05–06
Gross-profit and retail estimates Lesson 07
Error, entries, statements, tax, and control remediation Lesson 08
Note, authority, IFRS comparison, open items, and release Lesson 09

Organize your calculations, proposed entries, statement effects, and source citations by issue. For each unresolved question, name the missing document or fact and explain which conclusion depends on it. State what additional review would be needed before issuing financial statements. Reconciled arithmetic alone cannot establish that the records include all owned goods and obligations.