Worked example · EX:accounting-changes-error-corrections-and-comparative-reconstruction/granite-harbor-two-view-error-correction

Quantify Granite Harbor's accumulated accrual error two ways

Go beyond ACC 300: compare annual income errors with an accumulated liability error and explain why a current catch up can misstate income.

Updated Aug 8, 2026 Review due Nov 8, 2026
On this page
  1. Go beyond this course
  2. Problem
  3. Trace the layers
  4. Derive the current entry
  5. Interpret the two views
Worked-example setupScope and assumptions
  • Granite Harbor is fictional; the public-company scope, error classification, four annual omissions, and no-reversal fact are supplied.
  • Each year omitted $20,000 of operating expense and liability; tax is omitted only to isolate the two-view computation.
  • The sign convention for income effects is the signed correction needed: negative reduces reported income. Ending balance effects use the signed adjustment to the account under the stated trial-balance convention.
  • Materiality, auditor response, filing response, and control conclusions are not determined by the calculation.
Period
Years 1 through 4; discovery at the end of Year 4 before correction
Units
US dollars
Rounding
Retain full precision; display dollars with commas and parentheses for negatives

Go beyond this course

This optional example introduces two SEC methods for quantifying errors: the current-period income effect and the accumulated balance-sheet effect. That analysis extends beyond ACC 300's inventory-error coverage. You can follow the supplied calculations without deciding whether the error is material.

The rollover approach measures the current-period income effect. The iron-curtain approach measures the accumulated error in the ending balance sheet. Comparing both helps explain why correcting a liability entirely through current expense can misstate the current year's income.

Problem

Granite Harbor omitted a $20,000 operating accrual in each of four years. The obligation did not reverse. At the end of Year 4, management proposes an $80,000 current expense so the liability will be correct. Quantify the error before evaluating that proposal.

Trace the layers

Year Signed correction to pretax income Ending liability increase needed
1 $(20,000) $20,000
2 (20,000) 40,000
3 (20,000) 60,000
4 before correction (20,000) 80,000

The Year 4 rollover amount is a $(20,000) correction to current pretax income. The iron-curtain amount is an $80,000 increase needed in the ending liability. Booking the full $(80,000) through Year 4 income creates a $(60,000) out-of- period component beyond the current origin.

Derive the current entry

Under the supplied no-tax facts and signed trial-balance convention:

Dr operating expense—Year 4                 $20,000
Dr retained earnings—prior years             60,000
    Cr operating liability                             $80,000

The entry balances and produces the corrected ending liability. It does not by itself revise the comparative statements. The company must separately evaluate how the earlier errors affect comparative income, equity, disclosures, and any required filing corrections. Those decisions require materiality and reporting facts not supplied here.

Interpret the two views

Rollover is smaller here because the error accumulates. In a reversing error, iron curtain can be smaller. Neither approach is selected as conservative. For a covered registrant, both quantities enter the separate SAB 99 analysis, along with trends, contracts, compensation, segments, concealment, aggregate errors, and other actual facts.

The calculation proves the two quantities and the balanced entry. It does not decide materiality, whether current catch-up treatment is acceptable, whether previous filings are amended, what the auditor reports, or how a control deficiency is classified.

Reproduce · vary · inspect

Quantitative companions

Choose from 2 ways to work with this calculation.

Verified calculation · accounting change error analysis

The curriculum loader recomputed this example before it entered the site build. Expand any structured input to inspect the stated facts.

current corrected balances
3 fields
Inspect data
{
  "operating_expense": 20000,
  "operating_liability": -80000,
  "retained_earnings": -440000
}
current recorded balances
3 fields
Inspect data
{
  "operating_expense": 0,
  "operating_liability": 0,
  "retained_earnings": -500000
}
misstatement layers
1 field
Inspect data
{
  "omitted_operating_accrual": {
    "current_period_income_effect": -20000,
    "ending_balance_sheet_effect": 80000
  }
}
period effects
4 fields
Inspect data
{
  "year_1": {
    "direct_pretax_adjustment": -20000,
    "reported_amount": 300000,
    "reported_corrected_amount": 280000,
    "tax_rate": 0,
    "weighted_average_common_shares": 400000
  },
  "year_2": {
    "direct_pretax_adjustment": -20000,
    "reported_amount": 330000,
    "reported_corrected_amount": 310000,
    "tax_rate": 0,
    "weighted_average_common_shares": 410000
  },
  "year_3": {
    "direct_pretax_adjustment": -20000,
    "reported_amount": 360000,
    "reported_corrected_amount": 340000,
    "tax_rate": 0,
    "weighted_average_common_shares": 420000
  },
  "year_4": {
    "direct_pretax_adjustment": -20000,
    "reported_amount": 390000,
    "reported_corrected_amount": 370000,
    "tax_rate": 0,
    "weighted_average_common_shares": 430000
  }
}
pre earliest period pretax effect
0
pre earliest period tax rate
0
proposed current income correction
-80,000
reported correction entry balance difference
0
reported iron curtain amount
80,000
reported opening equity effect
0
reported out of period component
-60,000
reported rollover amount
-20,000
route
error correction

Recomputed result

Values recomputed by the curriculum loader
MeasureValue
correction entry balance difference0
correction operating expense20,000
correction operating liability-80,000
correction retained earnings60,000
iron curtain amount80,000
opening equity effect0
opening tax effect0
out of period component-60,000
rollover amount-20,000
year 1 after tax effect-20,000
year 1 corrected amount280,000
year 2 corrected amount310,000
year 3 corrected amount340,000
year 4 corrected amount370,000