Correction
Hold cost, residual value, useful life, and readiness date constant. Compare how each method assigns the same depreciable amount across periods. Then choose a method that fits the asset's expected use. Consider activity, the passage of time, and any greater early productivity or rising maintenance costs.
ASC 360-10-35-4 requires a systematic and rational allocation. Under ASC 360-10-35-7, declining balance can fit an asset that is more productive in its early years. Neither paragraph permits choosing a method to reach a target income.
How to avoid the mistake
Check both the calculation and the reason for the method. Even when several schedules reach the same ending amount, they assign different expense to each period. Management needs a reason based on expected use for that timing.
When this mistake may appear
- Several depreciation schedules reconcile to the same total depreciable amount.
- Management prefers the method with the desired current-year income.
Your work may contain this mistake if:
- Selects straight-line only because it is simple.
- Selects an accelerated method only because it lowers current income.
- Treats equal lifetime depreciation as proof that method choice does not matter.