Correction
The probable-loss test does not authorize a company to record a probable gain. An expected favorable outcome can remain uncertain even when the company can estimate the amount.
An expected award remains disputed
A company seeking damages may expect to win its lawsuit. The other party may still dispute whether it owes anything. Recording the expected award would report an asset and income before that uncertainty is resolved.
Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 450-30-25-1 generally prevents recognizing a contingent gain before realization. In this setting, the gain remains contingent while the company's entitlement to the award is unresolved. A completed settlement with unconditional payment differs from a prediction that the company will win.
The company discloses the possible gain without implying that receipt is more likely than the facts support. The disclosure requirement appears in ASC 450-30-50-1. Disclosure does not itself establish an asset or income.
Check your reasoning
A lawyer calls a favorable outcome probable and can estimate the award, but the lawsuit remains disputed. May the company use the probable-and-estimable loss test to record the gain?
Compare your answer.
No. That test addresses losses already incurred. The company still needs to distinguish its expectation of an award from a gain whose uncertainty has been resolved.
When this mistake may appear
- Management expects a favorable litigation award.
Your work may contain this mistake if:
- An expected gain is accrued because receipt is called probable.