Misconception · MIS:minimum-of-range-is-always-conservative

Mistaken idea “The minimum of a range is always the conservative accrual”

Mistaken reasoning: The minimum applies only when accrual is required and no amount within the reasonable range is a better estimate.

Updated Oct 5, 2026 Review due Nov 8, 2026
On this page
  1. Correction
  2. An estimate before a calculation
  3. Sources
  4. Check your reasoning

Correction

When a loss must be accrued, the company records the best estimate within a reasonable range. Under US generally accepted accounting principles (US GAAP), it uses the minimum only when no amount is a better estimate.

An estimate before a calculation

A range describes possible loss amounts. It does not establish that every amount is equally well supported or that a liability should be recorded.

The company first determines whether the incurred loss is probable and reasonably estimable. Probable means likely to occur. If accrual is required, the company then examines whether available information supports an amount better than the others.

Suppose a lawyer identifies a reasonable range and supports an amount above its minimum as the best estimate. Recording the minimum would understate that supported estimate. Calling the lower amount conservative does not justify ignoring the lawyer's assessment.

When no amount is better supported, the company records the minimum under US GAAP. It separately evaluates disclosure of possible loss above the accrual.

Sources

Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 450-20-25-2 establishes whether a loss qualifies for accrual. Paragraph 30-1 governs selection within a range. Paragraphs 50-3 and 50-4 address disclosure, including additional possible loss.

Check your reasoning

A company has a probable loss and a reasonable range, but no amount is a better estimate. Should it automatically record the midpoint?

Compare your answer.

No. Under US GAAP, it records the minimum in these circumstances. The midpoint calculation does not establish that the midpoint is a better estimate.

Where to watch

When this mistake may appear

  • A probable loss has a $180,000 to $420,000 range and a supported $300,000 better estimate.
Check your work

Your work may contain this mistake if:

  • This mistake records $180,000 solely because it is lowest.