On this page
A company may expect to receive money from a lawsuit while its right to that payment remains disputed. The expected award is a gain contingency. A favorable assessment does not mean the company has already earned an amount it can record.
Why the loss rule does not apply to gains
The general loss model permits an accrual when an incurred loss is probable and reasonably estimable. Applying that same test to an expected award could record income before the company's entitlement is resolved. Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 450-30-25-1 therefore generally excludes contingent gains from recognition before realization.
For example, a company's lawyer expects a favorable outcome and can estimate an award. The opposing party continues to dispute the claim. Those facts do not justify recording the award using the probable-and-estimable loss test. Management must consider whether the gain is still contingent under the applicable guidance.
A possible recovery does not erase a loss
Cedar Trail records a $180,000 product-claim loss. It also seeks $150,000 from an insurer, but its right to that recovery has not met the applicable recognition requirements. Cedar Trail records the $180,000 loss without reducing it for the possible recovery.
The obligations concern different parties. Cedar Trail may owe the customer even if the insurer refuses payment. The insurance claim needs its own recognition analysis; expecting reimbursement is not enough to cancel the customer liability.
Disclosure without implying certainty
ASC 450-30-50-1 requires adequate disclosure of a possible gain and cautions against overstating the likelihood of realization. The company describes the nature and status of the uncertainty without presenting the hoped-for receipt as assured.
Insurance recoveries and other reimbursement rights can also fall under specific guidance. Identify the type of claim before deciding when to record an asset or gain. Keeping the possible recovery separate from the loss helps avoid recognizing income before the recovery qualifies.
Put the concept to work
Analyze this concept
- Explain why an expected gain or reimbursement needs its own recognition analysis and cannot automatically reduce a recorded loss.
Learning resources
Choose a lesson, try an application, or inspect the sources behind this concept.
Build on these ideas
- Loss contingency — Understand
To analyze this concept: Helpful. The conditions for recording a contingent loss do not apply in the same way to a contingent gain.
Lessons
Worked examples and cases
Practice
Common mistaken ideas
Sources
Standard references
Related concepts
Used in these readings
These chapters explain or apply this concept. The label states how the chapter uses it.
- ACC 300: Current obligations Use now