Concept · C:nonmonetary-asset-exchange

Nonmonetary asset exchange

Working definition

A transaction in which a company gives up a noncash asset to obtain another asset, sometimes with an additional cash payment.

Also calledExchange of noncash assets · Asset trade-in

A nonmonetary asset exchange occurs when a company gives up a noncash asset to obtain another asset. Cash may also form part of the transaction. The company must measure the new asset and remove the old asset from its accounts.

Fair-value measurement

ASC 845-10-30-1 generally uses the surrendered asset's fair value unless the received asset's fair value is more clearly evident. For a company paying cash, add that payment to the old asset's fair value to measure the replacement. Compare the old asset's fair value with its carrying amount to determine the gain or loss. Cash paid is additional consideration, not the gain or loss itself.

Remove the old asset's cost and accumulated depreciation. Carrying amount is its remaining recorded cost, which can differ from fair value even when the company calculated depreciation correctly.

Commercial substance and cash consideration

An exchange has commercial substance when it significantly changes expected future cash flows under ASC 845-10-30-4. Consider risk, timing, and amount, or a significant change in value to the company. A different machine model alone does not establish that change.

Cash of 25% or more of the exchange's total fair value makes the exchange monetary under ASC 845-10-25-6. Account for it like a sale and purchase, recognizing the old asset's gain or loss. A lack of commercial substance does not defer the gain in that case.

For an exchange without commercial substance, cash may fall below that threshold. The cash payer then records the replacement at the old carrying amount plus cash under ASC 845-10-30-6. Recognize any indicated loss rather than carrying an impaired amount into the replacement. Rules for a company receiving cash can require partial gain recognition and need separate analysis.

ASC 845-10-30-3 also specifies recorded-amount measurement when neither fair value can be reasonably determined and for certain inventory exchanges that support sales. Identify the transaction's scope before applying an equipment trade-in example.

Learning objectives

Put the concept to work

Learning level

Understand this concept

  • Map an asset exchange through transaction scope, commercial substance, fair-value support, cash boot, acquired-cost measurement, and surrender-asset derecognition.
Learning level

Analyze this concept

  • Analyze supplied exchange evidence, compute only the supported branch, and withhold a fair-value or gain conclusion when reliability or scope facts are absent.

Learning resources

Choose a lesson, try an application, or inspect the sources behind this concept.

Build on these ideas

Lessons

Worked examples and cases

Practice

Common mistaken ideas

Sources

Standard references

Broader topics

Use this idea next

Updated Sep 10, 2026 Review due Nov 8, 2026