Lesson

Record write-downs and keep purchase commitments separate

Explain why a write down reduces inventory, while a loss on a future purchase commitment creates a liability.

Updated Sep 10, 2026 Review due Nov 8, 2026
On this page
  1. Record an inventory write-down
  2. Identify the purchase obligation
  3. Distinguish a price decline from a recognized loss
  4. Practice
  5. Go beyond this course: evaluate contract terms
  6. Accounting sources
About this lesson

Lesson details

Estimated study time
105 min
Learning objectives (4)

A decline in inventory value can create a loss on goods a company already owns. A firm purchase commitment can create a loss before the company receives the goods. Both situations concern expected recovery, but the credit goes to a different account because only the first involves an existing inventory asset.

Record an inventory write-down

Cedar Trail's FIFO item has an $80 loss under lower of cost and NRV. The company recognizes the loss in the period of the decline. Crediting Inventory reduces the asset to its required carrying amount.

Account Debit Credit
Inventory Write-down Loss $80
Inventory $80

A separate inventory valuation allowance can preserve the original Inventory account balance while reducing the net asset reported. Including the loss in Cost of Goods Sold instead changes its income-statement presentation. These choices do not change the loss or the net inventory amount.

A US GAAP fiscal-year-end write-down establishes a new cost basis. A recovery in a later fiscal year does not reverse that loss; separate interim guidance applies within the same fiscal year. Under IFRS, a supported recovery requires a reversal, limited to the earlier write-down and original cost.

Identify the purchase obligation

Signing an ordinary purchase order does not itself establish inventory or a loss. First determine whether the company already controls the goods. If it does not, examine whether the contract exposes it to an unavoidable loss.

Under US GAAP, a net loss on a firm, noncancelable, unhedged inventory purchase commitment is recognized before delivery. The company measures the loss using the applicable inventory measurement rule. Firm sales contracts or other circumstances may protect the company against some or all of the loss.

A loss on that commitment creates a liability. Crediting Inventory would reduce an asset the company has not yet received. The worked commitment example shows the loss entry and subsequent receipt of the goods.

Distinguish a price decline from a recognized loss

Suppose Cedar Trail agrees to purchase 1,000 units at $12 per unit. The current spot price falls to $10.50 per unit. The price difference is $1,500 [1,000 units × ($12 − $10.50) per unit].

If Cedar Trail can cancel without cost and has no other obligation, that price difference does not create an unavoidable loss. If the agreement is firm and noncancelable, the company must assess the expected net loss. The spot price alone does not establish the amount under the applicable inventory measurement rule.

For this contract, the supplied facts do not establish hedging, expected recovery, or protection through firm sales contracts. We therefore cannot conclude that the full price difference is a recognized loss. The worked example supplies those missing facts so you can follow a complete calculation and entry.

Practice

Complete the Northstar write-down and commitment question. Explain why one loss reduces inventory while the other creates a liability. That account choice follows from whether the company already owns the goods.

Go beyond this course: evaluate contract terms

Detailed contract interpretation, hedging, tax effects, and settlement accounting extend beyond this course's conceptual treatment of purchase commitments. An accountant evaluating a real contract must inspect cancellation provisions, fixed or indexed prices, delivery terms, and evidence of expected recovery. Legal advice may be needed to establish whether an obligation is enforceable.

Document which facts support recognition, measurement, and disclosure separately. If a contract term or recovery estimate is missing, explain which conclusion cannot yet be reached and what evidence would resolve it. Do not substitute a spot-price difference for that analysis.

Accounting sources

ASC 330-10-35-1B and 35-1C address inventory losses; 35-14 addresses the annual new cost basis. ASC 330-10-35-17 through 35-18 addresses commitment losses and protection against loss; 50-5 addresses their disclosure. Open FASB's Inventory topic and select those paragraphs. Sign in or register if prompted. IAS 2.33–34 addresses inventory write-down reversals under IFRS.