On this page
Lesson details
- Estimated study time
- 95 min
Learning objectives (2)
Cedar Trail includes $5,000 of supplier-owned goods in ending inventory. It also records a purchase and an Accounts Payable balance for those goods. The goods remain unsold, and Cedar Trail neither owns them nor owes the supplier. Beginning inventory and all other transactions are correct. Ignore income taxes.
Identify all affected accounts
Under periodic accounting, the incorrect purchase increases cost available for sale. Including the same goods in ending inventory keeps that cost out of Cost of Goods Sold. The two errors therefore leave Cost of Goods Sold and income unchanged.
| Reported amount | Effect of the error |
|---|---|
| Purchases | Overstated by $5,000 |
| Ending inventory | Overstated by $5,000 |
| Accounts Payable | Overstated by $5,000 |
| Cost of Goods Sold | Unchanged |
| Income and retained earnings | Unchanged |
The balance sheet still needs correction. Cedar Trail reports an asset it does not own and a liability it does not owe. Before closing the periodic accounts, it reverses the purchase by debiting Accounts Payable and crediting Purchases. It also excludes the supplier-owned goods from ending inventory.
If the closing entries already include the incorrect ending inventory, both Inventory and Accounts Payable remain overstated. Before any later transactions, the company corrects those balances by debiting Accounts Payable and crediting Inventory for $5,000. Neither correction charges the error to income.
Contrast a separate inventory-only error
Now suppose a calculation error overstates ending inventory by $5,000, while beginning inventory, purchases, and all other transactions are correct. Too much cost remains in Inventory, so Cost of Goods Sold is understated. Income and ending retained earnings are overstated by $5,000, ignoring taxes.
If the company leaves that error uncorrected, the incorrect ending inventory becomes the next year's beginning inventory. With a correct next-year ending inventory and no other errors, Cost of Goods Sold is overstated by $5,000. That year's income is understated by the same amount.
Those opposite income effects belong to the separate calculation error. They do not describe the supplier-owned goods case, where both purchases and ending inventory were wrong. For that case, later effects depend on how the company handles the goods, the incorrect payable, and any correction.
Correct the accounts and statements
Identify which accounts are still wrong when the company discovers the error. A correction before closing may affect an expense account. After closing, the same error may already have affected retained earnings. If later transactions have offset part of the error, correct only the remaining account misstatements.
For a material error in previously issued financial statements, correct the affected comparative periods under the applicable restatement requirements. Correct cumulative retained earnings does not establish that each year's income was correct. Fixing today's ledger also does not revise statements already provided to readers.
Use the separate inventory-only example to trace both years. Then complete Northstar practice with an independent understatement and a correction analysis.
Go beyond this course: investigate the consequences
A full error investigation can extend to taxes, earnings per share, debt covenants, compensation, cash-flow reporting, and previously filed reports. That work goes beyond the inventory account effects taught here. It requires facts about the company's contracts, tax treatment, and reporting obligations.
Start by determining how the error arose. A count mistake, ownership error, and omitted purchase can require different corrections and preventive controls. Then trace the effect through each affected report and identify who must review the correction. Correcting the balance does not prevent the same recording mistake from recurring.
Accounting sources
ASC 250-10-45-23 through 45-24 addresses corrections of previously issued financial statements; 50-7 addresses disclosure. Open FASB's Accounting Changes and Error Corrections topic and select those paragraphs. Sign in or register if prompted.