Why this is mistaken
Choose the measurement rule from the inventory cost method before calculating a loss. Under US GAAP, first-in, first-out (FIFO), average cost, and specific identification use lower of cost and net realizable value (NRV). Last-in, first-out (LIFO) and the retail inventory method use lower of cost or market.
Why the same shortcut gives different answers
NRV is expected selling price less remaining completion and selling costs. For FIFO inventory, the company compares that amount directly with recorded cost. Replacement cost does not enter that comparison.
For LIFO inventory, NRV is the ceiling for designated market. The company also calculates a floor by subtracting the normal profit allowance from NRV. It limits replacement cost to those bounds, then compares the result with recorded cost. Using replacement cost without the limits can overstate a loss or leave inventory above its expected net recovery.
The retail inventory method is a cost-estimation technique. A retailer using FIFO still applies lower of cost and NRV; selling goods at retail does not place it under the market rule.
Check your reasoning: a retailer uses average cost. Does it need replacement cost to apply its subsequent measurement rule?
No. Under US GAAP, it compares recorded cost directly with NRV. The company's cost method, not its retail customers, determines that rule.
See the measurement comparison for worked calculations under both rules. ASC 330-10-35-1A through 35-1C establish the distinction in FASB's Inventory topic. Access may require registration.
When this mistake may appear
- Use MIN(cost, NRV) for every SKU.
- Market always means replacement cost.
- List price is NRV.
Your work may contain this mistake if:
- Skips the cost-method route, omits NRV deductions, or uses replacement cost without the ceiling and floor.