In this chapter
- Select a measurement rule
- Determine net realizable value
- Serving platters at Second Helping
- Choose items or groups
- Apply lower of cost or market
- Three separate LIFO products
- Account for recoveries
- Interpret write-down effects
- Disclosures and purchase commitments
- Losses on purchase commitments
- Estimates versus errors
- How ending-inventory errors affect income
- An ending-inventory error at Second Helping
- Trace errors across periods
- Interpret error effects on performance
- Effects in 2026
- Effects in 2027
- Compare calculation and cutoff errors
- Correct inventory errors
- Correct the accounting records
- Correct financial statements that contain errors
Review and resources
Once a company assigns costs to inventory, those costs generally remain on the balance sheet until the goods are sold. The company expects to recover those costs through future sales, but that expectation can change. Damage, obsolescence, or declining demand may reduce the amount the company can recover from its inventory. If the recoverable amount falls below recorded cost, continuing to report that cost would overstate inventory and delay recognition of the loss.
This chapter examines how companies identify and measure declines in inventory value. It also addresses inventory errors, which affect both the inventory reported on the balance sheet and cost of goods sold on the income statement. Because one period's ending inventory becomes the next period's beginning inventory, an error can distort reported profit in more than one period.
Select a measurement rule
Inventory is initially recorded at its assigned cost, but that amount may no longer be appropriate at a later reporting date. A company might have paid $100 for a product that it now expects to sell for only $80. No further completion or selling costs are expected. The expected proceeds no longer cover the recorded cost, requiring the company to recognize a loss before selling the product.
This reassessment is called subsequent measurement. The company compares recorded cost with the amount required under the applicable measurement rule and recognizes any required reduction as a loss.
Under US GAAP, the required comparison depends on the method used to determine inventory cost.
For inventory measured using first-in, first-out (FIFO), average cost, or specific identification, companies generally apply lower of cost and net realizable value. Net realizable value (NRV) is the estimated selling price less the reasonably predictable costs of completing and selling the goods. If NRV is below recorded cost, the company reduces inventory to NRV and recognizes the difference as a loss.
Inventory measured using last-in, first-out (LIFO) or the retail inventory method follows a different rule: lower of cost or market. For this purpose, market generally starts with current replacement cost, subject to an upper and lower limit based on net realizable value. These limits can produce a different inventory measurement than a direct comparison with NRV.
The retail inventory method is a technique for estimating inventory cost using the relationship between the cost and selling prices of goods available for sale. It does not refer to all inventory held by retailers. A retailer using FIFO or average cost, for example, applies lower of cost and NRV. Chapter 18 explains the retail inventory method in detail.
The applicable comparison also depends on the reporting framework:
| Reporting framework and method | Measurement rule |
|---|---|
| US GAAP: FIFO, average cost, specific identification, and other methods except LIFO and the retail inventory method | Lower of cost and NRV |
| US GAAP: LIFO or the retail inventory method | Lower of cost or market |
| International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS): ordinary inventories within IAS 2 | Lower of cost and NRV; LIFO is prohibited |
Review Chapter 16 for the costs assigned by FIFO, LIFO, and average cost. The new comparison begins with that assigned amount.
A US kitchenware retailer uses weighted-average cost to account for inventory. Which subsequent measurement rule applies, and why doesn't selling goods at retail change that rule?
Compare your answer.
Under US GAAP, inventory measured using weighted-average cost is subject to lower of cost and net realizable value. The exception for lower of cost or market applies to LIFO and the retail inventory method. The retail inventory method is a specific technique for estimating inventory cost, not a rule that applies to every retailer.
Determine net realizable value
An inventory item's expected selling price may exceed its recorded cost without allowing the company to recover that cost. The company may still need to repair or complete the goods, pay for delivery, or incur other costs to make the sale. Those remaining costs reduce the proceeds available to recover the inventory's recorded cost.
The amount remaining after those costs is net realizable value (NRV). Under US GAAP, NRV is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business, less reasonably predictable costs of completion, disposal, and transportation. IFRS similarly deducts estimated completion costs and costs necessary to make the sale.
NRV = Estimated selling price − Estimated completion and selling costs.
The inventory's assigned cost is not deducted when calculating NRV. NRV measures the net amount expected from selling the goods, before considering the cost already recorded in inventory. We then compare NRV with that recorded cost to determine whether the company can recover its investment or must recognize a write-down.
Serving platters at Second Helping
At December 31, 2026, Second Helping holds 130 stoneware serving platters with an assigned FIFO cost of $46 each. The packaging is damaged, so Second Helping must repackage the platters before sale. Management estimates a selling price of $49 per platter, repackaging costs of $3 per platter, and selling and outbound delivery costs of $4 per platter. No other completion or selling costs apply.
Although the expected selling price exceeds the $46 cost, Second Helping must incur another $7 per platter to complete the sale. Those costs reduce the amount available to recover the recorded inventory cost.
| Measurement | Amount per platter |
|---|---|
| Expected selling price | $49 |
| Less repackaging costs | ($3) |
| Less selling and outbound delivery costs | ($4) |
| Net realizable value | $42 |
| Assigned FIFO cost | $46 |
| Lower of cost and NRV | $42 |
Second Helping expects to recover only $42 of each platter's $46 recorded cost. The $4 per-platter shortfall is an inventory write-down, recognized even though the company has not yet sold the platters.
For all 130 platters, the recorded cost is $5,980 ($46 per platter × 130 platters), while NRV is $5,460 ($42 per platter × 130 platters). The company must reduce inventory by $520.
The entry recognizes the $520 loss in current income and reduces inventory to its required carrying amount of $5,460. The company recognizes the loss in the period in which the decline occurs. Waiting until the platters are sold would leave inventory overstated and delay recognition of a loss already evident at the reporting date.
Instead of crediting Inventory directly, the company may credit a separate inventory valuation allowance. The allowance preserves the original Inventory account balance while reducing the net amount reported on the balance sheet. Both approaches recognize the same loss and report the same net inventory.
A product has a recorded cost of $40, an expected selling price of $45, and remaining completion and selling costs of $3. Does the company need to write down the inventory? Explain.
Compare your answer.
No. NRV is $42 ($45 − $3), which exceeds the $40 recorded cost. The company retains the $40 carrying amount because lower of cost and NRV does not permit recognizing the expected $2 profit before sale.
Choose items or groups
Lower of cost and NRV can produce different results depending on whether a company compares amounts for individual products or groups of products. One product's NRV may fall below its cost while another's NRV exceeds cost. Combining them before the comparison can allow expected profits on one product to offset losses on another.
Consider two products:
| Product | Cost | NRV |
|---|---|---|
| A | $100 | $80 |
| B | $100 | $130 |
| Total | $200 | $210 |
Applying lower of cost and NRV separately to each product requires a $20 write-down for Product A. Product B remains at its recorded cost because its NRV exceeds cost. Comparing the total produces no write-down because total NRV exceeds total cost. The choice of comparison level therefore affects the loss recognized and the reported inventory amount.
Under US GAAP, a company may apply the applicable lower-of-cost comparison to individual items, appropriate categories, or total inventory, depending on the character and composition of the goods. The selected basis must clearly reflect periodic income. Management cannot justify grouping unrelated products merely because doing so reduces the write-down.
Under IFRS, a company generally assesses inventory item by item. Grouping may be appropriate for similar or related items, such as goods in the same product line that cannot practicably be evaluated separately. Broad groupings, such as all finished goods, are not sufficient by themselves.
In the calculations that follow, we apply the applicable measurement model separately to each product.
Apply lower of cost or market
Under lower of cost and NRV, the company compares recorded inventory cost directly with the amount expected from selling the goods. Under US GAAP, inventory measured using LIFO or the retail inventory method also requires consideration of current replacement cost. This is what the company would spend now to obtain goods with equivalent usefulness. Replacement cost provides an indication of inventory's remaining usefulness.
Replacement cost does not always provide an appropriate measurement on its own. It may exceed the net amount the company expects to recover from selling the goods. Alternatively, an unusually low replacement cost could produce an excessive inventory write-down, leaving an unusually large profit to be recognized when the goods are eventually sold.
The lower-of-cost-or-market rule addresses both concerns by limiting replacement cost to a range defined by a ceiling and a floor.
- Ceiling: NRV. Market cannot exceed the net amount expected from selling the inventory. A higher replacement cost would not increase the proceeds available from the goods already held.
- Floor: NRV less an allowance for an approximately normal profit margin. Market cannot fall below this amount. The floor limits the write-down from an unusually low replacement cost. A larger reduction would leave more than a normal profit to be recognized on the later sale.
In this course, the normal profit allowance is supplied. Use it to calculate the floor; you do not need to estimate it.
Replacement cost adjusted for these limits is called designated market (or constrained market). In this US GAAP measurement rule, market means replacement cost constrained by the ceiling and floor. It does not simply mean the current selling price or an unrestricted replacement cost.
profit allowance
Three separate LIFO products
At its annual reporting date, Second Helping holds three products accounted for using LIFO. Management has estimated each product's replacement cost, expected selling price, remaining completion and selling costs, and normal profit allowance. The company applies lower of cost or market separately to each product.
The loss is the assigned LIFO cost less the required carrying amount, which is the lower of cost or designated market. Multiply that loss per unit by the quantity held to calculate the total write-down.
All amounts except quantities and total write-downs are per unit.
| Per-unit measurement | Casserole dish | Roasting pan | Serving set |
|---|---|---|---|
| Assigned LIFO cost | $74 | $59 | $54 |
| Calculate the bounds | |||
| Expected selling price | $72 | $66 | $60 |
| Less completion costs | ($2) | ($3) | ($2) |
| Less selling and delivery costs | ($5) | ($4) | ($3) |
| NRV: ceiling | $65 | $59 | $55 |
| Less normal profit allowance | ($12) | ($12) | ($11) |
| NRV less normal profit: floor | $53 | $47 | $44 |
| Determine market | |||
| Current replacement cost | $78 | $52 | $39 |
| Designated market | $65 | $52 | $44 |
| Determine the write-down | |||
| Lower of cost or market | $65 | $52 | $44 |
| Loss per unit: cost − carrying amount | $74 − $65 = $9 per dish |
$59 − $52 = $7 per pan |
$54 − $44 = $10 per set |
| Quantity held | 24 dishes | 31 pans | 43 sets |
| Total write-down: loss per unit × quantity | $9 per dish × 24 dishes = $216 |
$7 per pan × 31 pans = $217 |
$10 per set × 43 sets = $430 |
Each product illustrates a different way the limits affect designated market.
Casserole dishes: use the ceiling. Replacement cost is $78, above the $65 NRV ceiling. The company cannot use a market amount greater than the net proceeds expected from selling the dishes, so designated market is $65.
Roasting pans: use replacement cost. Replacement cost is $52, between the $47 floor and $59 ceiling. Neither limit applies, so designated market remains $52.
Serving sets: use the floor. Expected net sale proceeds are $55 per set. Subtracting the $11 normal profit allowance per set gives a floor of $44 per set. Replacement cost is $39 per set, below that floor, so designated market is $44 per set. Writing inventory down to $39 per set would leave an expected profit of $16 per set, exceeding the $11 normal profit allowance per set.
After determining designated market for each product, Second Helping compares it with assigned LIFO cost. Market is lower than cost for all three products, requiring write-downs of $216, $217, and $430.
The combined write-down is $863. Second Helping records the following entry:
The entry recognizes the decline in current income and reduces the inventory carrying amount before the goods are sold. As with lower of cost and NRV, the write-down recognizes a loss that has become evident rather than waiting until the eventual sale.
Applying lower of cost or market also requires judgment about whether a loss has occurred. A lower replacement cost alone does not establish a loss. Under US GAAP, no loss is recognized when the evidence indicates that recorded cost will be recovered with an approximately normal profit. Firm sales contracts at fixed prices may provide that evidence.
Replacement cost falls below the floor. Which amount becomes designated market, and why does the floor matter?
Compare your answer.
The floor becomes designated market, which the company then compares with recorded cost. The floor can limit the write-down and prevent an unusually large profit when the goods are later sold. If recorded cost is already below designated market, no write-down is needed.
Account for recoveries
An inventory write-down reflects a decline in the amount the company expects to recover from its goods. If expected recovery improves before the goods are sold, can the company reverse the earlier loss?
Return to Second Helping's 130 FIFO serving platters. Their original cost was $46 each, but the December 31, 2026 write-down reduced their carrying amount to $42 each. The platters remain unsold, and at December 31, 2027, revised estimates support an NRV of $45 per platter.
The estimated shortfall has fallen from $4 to $1 per platter. Whether Second Helping can reverse the earlier loss depends on the reporting framework.
Under US GAAP, a year-end inventory write-down establishes a new cost basis. The reduced $42 amount becomes the cost used for subsequent accounting, even though the original purchase cost was $46. A later increase in NRV does not restore the previous basis. Assuming no further decline or other changes, inventory remains at $5,460 (130 platters × $42 per platter). Separate guidance applies to inventory losses and recoveries in interim financial statements.
Under IFRS, the company must reassess NRV in subsequent periods and reverse a previous write-down when the conditions support recovery. The revised carrying amount is the lower of original cost and current NRV. For Second Helping, the $45 NRV is below the original $46 cost, so inventory increases to $5,850 (130 platters × $45 per platter). The $390 increase reverses part of the loss recognized in 2026.
The same change in expected recovery therefore produces different accounting results:
| Measurement | US GAAP | IFRS |
|---|---|---|
| Original inventory cost | $5,980 | $5,980 |
| Carrying amount after 2026 write-down | $5,460 | $5,460 |
| Revised NRV at December 31, 2027 | $5,850 | $5,850 |
| Reversal recognized in 2027 | $0 | $390 |
| 2027 ending inventory | $5,460 | $5,850 |
Under IFRS, Second Helping records the recovery as follows:
The credit reduces inventory expense for 2027. It does not represent revenue from a sale; the platters are still held in inventory.
A reversal cannot increase inventory above its original cost. Suppose NRV instead rises to $52 per platter. Under IFRS, the carrying amount would be limited to the original $46 cost, or $5,980 for all 130 platters. The maximum reversal would be the original $520 write-down.
When the goods are eventually sold, their carrying amount becomes cost of goods sold. Under US GAAP, the earlier write-down leaves less cost to recognize upon sale. Under IFRS, any reversal increases the cost that remains to be recognized. A higher margin in the sale period may therefore reflect losses recognized in earlier periods rather than an improvement in the underlying sale.
Inventory originally cost $100 and was written down to $80 at the end of 2026. At the end of 2027, its NRV is $110, and the goods remain unsold. What inventory amount should the company report under US GAAP and under IFRS?
Compare your answer.
Under US GAAP, inventory remains at $80 because the year-end write-down established a new cost basis.
Under IFRS, the company reverses the $20 write-down and reports inventory at $100, the lower of original cost and current NRV.
Interpret write-down effects
Inventory write-downs affect more than the amount reported on the balance sheet. Recognizing a loss reduces current income, while the lower inventory carrying amount affects the expense recognized when the goods are eventually sold. These effects can complicate comparisons of profitability across periods.
Chapter 16 introduced inventory turnover as a measure of how quickly a company sells its inventory. Because the ratio uses cost of goods sold and average inventory, a write-down can change it without changing the movement of goods.
A write-down reduces ending inventory regardless of where the loss is reported on the income statement. If the company includes the loss in Cost of Goods Sold, it also increases the numerator of the turnover ratio. A separately presented loss reduces inventory without increasing reported cost of goods sold.
Consider a separate annual illustration for Second Helping:
| Given information | Amount |
|---|---|
| Balances before the adjustment | |
| Beginning inventory | $22,000 |
| Ending inventory | $26,000 |
| Cost of goods sold | $144,000 |
| Sales revenue | $216,000 |
| Adjustment to record | |
| Inventory write-down | $4,800 |
Purchases, sales quantities, and selling prices remain unchanged.
The adjustment changes the following annual amounts:
| Annual measure | Before recognizing write-down | After recognizing write-down |
|---|---|---|
| Ending inventory | $26,000 | $21,200 |
| Cost of goods sold | $144,000 | $148,800 |
| Gross profit | $72,000 | $67,200 |
| Average inventory | $24,000 | $21,600 |
To calculate days in inventory, divide 365 days by annual inventory turnover. Results use unrounded turnover.
The entry does not change the goods held or how long they have been held. The write-down changes the accounting amounts used in the ratios, not the company's inventory activity. Likewise, gross profit declines because the company recognizes the loss in Cost of Goods Sold, not because it sold fewer goods or charged lower prices.
The effects can also extend into later periods. A write-down reduces the inventory cost remaining to be recognized when the goods are sold. A subsequent increase in gross profit rate may therefore partly reflect an earlier loss rather than improved operations.
When interpreting performance, consider the timing and presentation of inventory write-downs alongside sales quantities, selling prices, and inventory age.
Inventory days fall after a write-down, with the same physical sales and purchases. Does that prove that the company sold goods faster?
Compare your answer.
No. The accounting reduction changes the ratio inputs without changing the physical sales. Investigate inventory quantities, age, sales patterns, and the measurement loss before drawing an operating conclusion.
Disclosures and purchase commitments
Companies can report different inventory amounts for similar goods because they use different cost methods or recognize different measurement losses. Before comparing their profitability or inventory turnover, examine the accompanying notes to understand how those amounts were determined.
Under US GAAP, the company discloses its inventory accounting basis, significant changes in that basis, and substantial and unusual losses from inventory measurement. Under IFRS, required disclosures include inventory expense, write-downs, reversals, and the circumstances that led to reversals. These disclosures help readers distinguish changes in operating performance from changes in inventory measurement.
Losses on purchase commitments
A company can also face an inventory-related loss before it controls the goods. An inventory purchase commitment is an agreement to purchase goods in the future. If the company has committed to a fixed purchase price and the goods decline in value before delivery, it may expect to pay more than it can recover from them.
For example, a company has a firm, noncancelable, unhedged commitment to purchase goods for $100. It does not yet control the goods. The amount under the applicable inventory measurement rule has fallen to $80. No firm sales contract or other circumstances protect the company against the resulting $20 loss.
Under US GAAP, the company recognizes the $20 loss before receiving the goods. It cannot avoid the purchase obligation and does not expect to recover the full committed price.
This treatment differs from an inventory write-down. The company does not yet control the goods, so it does not reduce an existing inventory asset. Instead, it recognizes an expected loss arising from its purchase obligation. An ordinary purchase order does not automatically create either inventory or a loss; the terms of the commitment and expected economic outcome matter.
Detailed accounting for purchase commitment settlements and hedging arrangements is beyond the scope of this chapter.
Estimates versus errors
The preceding examples changed inventory measurements because expectations about recovering inventory costs had changed. An incorrect inventory balance can also result from a mistake in recording or calculating costs.
An inventory error occurs when a company incorrectly measures or reports inventory. Examples include miscounting goods, omitting purchases, or assigning incorrect costs to inventory. Correcting an error requires determining what the accounting should have been based on the information available when the original amount was reported.
A change in estimate generally reflects new information or changed circumstances. An error results from incorrect accounting, mathematical mistakes, or misuse or oversight of information available when the statements were prepared. A company must identify which occurred before determining how to report the adjustment, particularly when an earlier reporting period may have been misstated.
How ending-inventory errors affect income
When beginning inventory and purchases are correct, an ending-inventory error changes how much cost the company reports as an asset and how much it reports as an expense.
Cost of unsold goods
If ending inventory is overstated, too much cost remains on the balance sheet and too little is recognized as cost of goods sold. Income is therefore overstated. If ending inventory is understated, the opposite occurs: cost of goods sold is too high and income is too low.
These effects follow directly from the cost allocation. An error in ending inventory changes how much cost is assigned to the asset and how much is deducted from revenue.
An ending-inventory error at Second Helping
Consider a separate 2026 scenario for Second Helping. Correct beginning inventory is $15,400, purchases total $84,300, and correct ending inventory is $18,500. Sales are $146,000, and other expenses are $27,400.
While calculating ending inventory, an employee incorrectly multiplies counted quantities by their assigned unit costs, overstating inventory by $650. The quantities are correct, all goods belong to Second Helping, and all purchases and sales are recorded in the proper period. Ignore income taxes and dividends.
Calculate cost of goods sold
| 2026 cost calculation | Correct | With the error |
|---|---|---|
| Beginning inventory | $15,400 | $15,400 |
| Add purchases | $84,300 | $84,300 |
| Cost of goods available for sale | $99,700 | $99,700 |
| Less ending inventory | $18,500 | $19,150 |
| Cost of goods sold | $81,200 | $80,550 |
Calculate income
| 2026 income calculation | Correct | With the error |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | $146,000 | $146,000 |
| Less cost of goods sold | $81,200 | $80,550 |
| Gross profit | $64,800 | $65,450 |
| Less other expenses | $27,400 | $27,400 |
| Income before income taxes | $37,400 | $38,050 |
The calculation error leaves an extra $650 in ending inventory. Because cost of goods sold equals goods available for sale less ending inventory, the same error understates cost of goods sold by $650.
Sales and other expenses are unchanged, so income is overstated by $650. When income is closed to retained earnings, the error also overstates ending retained earnings by $650.
If the calculation error instead understated ending inventory, which way would cost of goods sold and income move?
Compare your answer.
Cost of goods sold would be overstated and income understated. Assigning too little cost to the goods still held leaves too much cost assigned to the goods sold. The company then deducts too much expense from the same sales revenue.
Trace errors across periods
Ending inventory becomes beginning inventory in the following year. For an isolated ending-inventory error, with purchases and other transactions correct, the error carries into the next period's cost of goods available for sale. If the following year's ending inventory is correct, the error affects that year's cost of goods sold in the opposite direction.
This explains why an inventory error can overstate income in one year and understate it in the next. The two income effects offset, but neither year's income is correct.
Return to Second Helping's $650 overstatement of 2026 ending inventory. In 2027, the company purchases $91,700 of goods, earns sales revenue of $159,500, and incurs other expenses of $30,200. Ending inventory is correctly measured at $20,200. Assume the company does not correct the earlier error, and there are no other errors, income taxes, or dividends.
| 2027 amount | Correct | With the opening error |
|---|---|---|
| Beginning inventory | $18,500 | $19,150 |
| Purchases | $91,700 | $91,700 |
| Ending inventory | $20,200 | $20,200 |
| Cost of goods sold | $90,000 | $90,650 |
| Income before income taxes | $39,300 | $38,650 |
The $650 overstatement of beginning inventory increases 2027 cost of goods sold by $650. Because the 2027 ending inventory is correct, none of that excess cost remains in the ending asset. The cost omitted from expense in 2026 is instead recognized in 2027.
An inventory error that produces offsetting income effects across periods is called a counterbalancing error. The effects on Second Helping's income are:
| Income comparison | Correct | Reported without correction |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 income | $37,400 | $38,050 |
| 2027 income | $39,300 | $38,650 |
| Combined income | $76,700 | $76,700 |
The error shifts $650 of expense from 2026 to 2027 without changing the total expense recognized across the two years.
The same pattern affects retained earnings. Second Helping begins 2026 with retained earnings of $41,000 and has no dividends or other equity changes. Correct retained earnings at December 31, 2026 are $78,400, but the error causes the company to report $79,050. At December 31, 2027, both the correct and uncorrected calculations produce retained earnings of $117,700.
The error has counterbalanced, but the annual income statements remain incorrect. A lender or investor comparing the two years would see overstated income in 2026 followed by understated income in 2027. Total income and ending retained earnings agree despite those annual errors.
The offset depends on the 2027 ending inventory being correct and no other errors affecting the calculation. If the company repeats the error or omits another transaction, the effects must be traced separately rather than assumed to cancel.
A company overstates 2026 ending inventory by $900. Its 2027 ending inventory is correct, and no other errors occur. If the company makes no correction, how does the error affect income in each year and retained earnings at the end of 2027? Ignore income taxes.
Compare your answer.
2026 income is overstated by $900 because cost of goods sold is understated. In 2027, the overstated beginning inventory increases cost of goods sold, understating income by $900. The income effects offset, so ending 2027 retained earnings are correct, although neither year's income is correct.
Interpret error effects on performance
The inventory error also distorts measures used to assess profitability and operating efficiency. Gross profit rate depends on cost of goods sold, while inventory turnover depends on both cost of goods sold and average inventory. An error can therefore affect the ratios differently in each period.
Using Second Helping's amounts, calculate the following measures with average beginning and ending inventory and a 365-day year. Use unrounded values before rounding the results.
Effects in 2026
Shaded amounts are misstated by the inventory error.
| Amounts used | Correct | With the error |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | $146,000 | $146,000 |
| Cost of goods sold | $81,200 | $80,550 |
| Amounts used | Correct | With the error |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of goods sold | $81,200 | $80,550 |
| Beginning inventory | $15,400 | $15,400 |
| Ending inventory | $18,500 | $19,150 |
Results use unrounded turnover.
| Amounts used | Correct | With the error |
|---|---|---|
| Annual inventory turnover | 4.79 times | 4.66 times |
| Days in year | 365 days | 365 days |
In 2026, understated cost of goods sold inflates gross profit and its rate. Turnover is understated because the numerator is understated while average inventory, the denominator, is overstated. Calculated days in inventory are consequently overstated.
The company appears to earn a higher gross profit rate while holding inventory longer, even though the error changes neither sales nor the physical movement of goods.
Effects in 2027
Shaded amounts are misstated by the inventory error.
| Amounts used | Correct | With the opening error |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | $159,500 | $159,500 |
| Cost of goods sold | $90,000 | $90,650 |
| Amounts used | Correct | With the opening error |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of goods sold | $90,000 | $90,650 |
| Beginning inventory | $18,500 | $19,150 |
| Ending inventory | $20,200 | $20,200 |
Results use unrounded turnover.
| Amounts used | Correct | With the opening error |
|---|---|---|
| Annual inventory turnover | 4.65 times | 4.61 times |
| Days in year | 365 days | 365 days |
In 2027, the error increases cost of goods sold, reducing gross profit and its rate. Average inventory also remains overstated because it includes the incorrect beginning balance, even though ending inventory is correct.
Both the numerator and denominator of inventory turnover are overstated. The direction of the ratio cannot be determined from those facts alone; we must calculate their combined effect. In this example, turnover remains understated and days in inventory remain overstated.
Although the income errors offset across the two years, the turnover errors do not. Correcting the annual income amounts and inventory balances is necessary before interpreting changes in profitability or inventory efficiency.
Suppose a separate calculation error understates ending inventory, while beginning inventory, purchases, and sales are correct. How would the error affect gross profit rate, inventory turnover, and days in inventory that year?
Compare your answer.
Cost of goods sold is overstated, so gross profit rate is understated. Average inventory is understated. The higher numerator and lower denominator both overstate turnover, which understates days in inventory. The company could appear to sell goods faster even though the error changed no sales.
Compare calculation and cutoff errors
The earlier example held purchases constant. When an error affects both purchases and ending inventory, the income effect can differ.
Use Second Helping's correct 2026 amounts, but replace the earlier calculation error with an omitted purchase. Beginning inventory is $15,400, purchases are $84,300, and ending inventory is $18,500. These correct amounts include $1,260 of goods purchased on credit that remain unsold at year-end.
Suppose Second Helping fails to record that purchase and excludes the goods from ending inventory. Beginning inventory remains correct. Purchases and ending inventory are each understated by $1,260.
Both calculations assign $81,200 to Cost of Goods Sold. The omitted purchase reduces the cost available for sale, but the omitted ending inventory reduces the cost retained as an asset by the same amount.
The original error therefore understates Inventory and Accounts Payable by $1,260 each but does not affect income under these facts.
The outcome would differ if Second Helping had recorded the purchase but omitted the goods from ending inventory. Purchases would already be correct, while ending inventory would be understated. Cost of goods sold would then be overstated by $1,260, reducing income by the same amount.
Before determining how an inventory error affects income, identify which transactions and account balances are incorrect. The effect depends on the complete set of omissions or misstatements, not merely on whether ending inventory is too high or too low.
A company using periodic inventory accounting receives goods on credit before year-end. It owns the goods, which remain unsold, but omits both the purchase and the goods from ending inventory. Beginning inventory and all other transactions are correct. How does the error affect Inventory, Accounts Payable, and Cost of Goods Sold? Explain.
Compare your answer.
Inventory and Accounts Payable are understated by the cost of the omitted goods. Cost of Goods Sold is unchanged. Omitting the purchase understates the cost available for sale; omitting the same goods from ending inventory understates the cost retained as an asset by an equal amount. The effects on Cost of Goods Sold offset because all the omitted goods remain unsold.
Correct inventory errors
The company must correct the affected accounts and determine whether financial statements previously provided to users also require correction. Closing the accounts and issuing financial statements are separate events.
Correct the accounting records
The correcting entry depends on which accounts contain the error when it is discovered. Return to Second Helping's $650 overstatement of ending inventory in 2026.
Before closing the 2026 accounts, Inventory is overstated and Cost of Goods Sold is understated. The company corrects both amounts:
The entry transfers $650 from the overstated asset to the expense that should have been recognized in 2026. Closing the corrected income accounts then produces the proper retained earnings balance.
After the 2026 income accounts have been closed, the overstated income has already been included in retained earnings. Assume the error is discovered before any 2027 transactions. The balances can then be corrected by debiting Retained Earnings and crediting Inventory:
This entry reduces the overstated inventory and retained earnings balances without charging the correction to 2027 operating expense. If the 2026 statements have not yet been issued or made available to be issued, the company must ensure they reflect the corrected 2026 amounts.
For an inventory understatement, the relevant correcting entries reverse direction. If the error also involves an omitted purchase, the company must correct the purchase and payable as well as the inventory balance.
Correct financial statements that contain errors
Correcting the accounting records does not automatically correct financial statements already issued to users. Under US GAAP, a material error in prior-period statements generally requires restatement after those statements have been issued or are available to be issued, as applicable.
The company corrects the amounts reported for each period presented. Any cumulative effect arising before the earliest period presented is reflected in opening assets, liabilities, and retained earnings as appropriate.
The correction belongs to the period in which the error occurred, not automatically to the period in which the company discovered it. The company must also disclose the nature of the error and the effects of the restatement on the financial statements.
Suppose Second Helping discovers the $650 error after closing 2027. If the error is material, the company must correct the affected financial statements:
- 2026: increase cost of goods sold by $650 and decrease income by $650. Decrease ending inventory and ending retained earnings by $650.
- 2027: decrease beginning inventory and cost of goods sold by $650, increasing income by $650.
These corrections put the expense in the proper year. They do not change December 31, 2027 inventory or retained earnings, because those ending balances are already correct. The company corrects the amounts reported for each affected period without reducing those ending balances again.