On this page
A counterbalancing error overstates income in one period and understates it in a later period, or the reverse. The effects offset across periods, but the income reported for each period remains incorrect.
Follow ending inventory into the next year
Suppose a company understates ending inventory while correctly recording beginning inventory and purchases. Too little cost remains in the asset, so Cost of Goods Sold is too high and income is too low. Ignore income taxes.
That understated ending inventory becomes understated beginning inventory in the following year. If the next ending inventory is correct and no other errors occur, Cost of Goods Sold is then too low and income is too high.
| Amount | First year | Following year |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of goods sold | Overstated | Understated by the same amount |
| Income | Understated | Overstated by the same amount |
| Ending retained earnings | Understated | Correct after the income effects offset |
The reversal depends on the next ending inventory being correct. A repeated count error or another omitted transaction requires a separate calculation. Do not assume that every inventory problem cancels in the next year.
Correct annual results even after the offset
If the error is material, the company corrects the affected financial statements. In this example, it reduces the first year's Cost of Goods Sold and increases that year's income. It makes the opposite changes to the following year's income statement.
Those corrections assign expense to the proper period. They do not require another reduction of current inventory or retained earnings when those ending balances are already correct.
Trace the worked inventory error and the independent practice question.
Accounting sources
ASC 250-10-45-23 through 45-24 address correction of prior-period financial statements; 50-7 addresses disclosures. Open FASB's Accounting Changes and Error Corrections topic and select those paragraphs. Access may require registration.
Put the concept to work
Understand this concept
- Explain why offsetting annual income errors can leave correct cumulative balances while misstating each affected period.
Apply this concept
- Calculate the annual and cumulative effects of a counterbalancing error and determine the corrections needed when it is found.
Learning resources
Choose a lesson, try an application, or inspect the sources behind this concept.
Build on these ideas
- Counterbalancing error — Understand
To apply this concept: Required. The schedule must preserve both period and cumulative views.
- Error in previously issued financial statements — Understand
To understand this concept: Required. Counterbalancing describes propagation of an error.
Lessons
Worked examples and cases
Practice
Common mistaken ideas
Sources
Standard references
Broader topics
Related concepts
Use this idea next
- Counterbalancing error — Apply
Required level here: understand. Required. The schedule must preserve both period and cumulative views.