In this chapter
- Assign the cost of an identified item
- Assign costs to interchangeable goods
- Purchases before the only sale
- First-in, first-out
- Last-in, first-out
- Average cost
- Selling before the next purchase
- Periodic: assign costs at month-end
- Perpetual: assign costs at each sale
- Compare periodic and perpetual costs for the November 6 sale
- Perpetual: record the November 10 purchase
- Perpetual moving average: calculate the next sale cost
- Compare periodic weighted average with perpetual moving average
- Perpetual LIFO: assign costs at each sale
- Periodic LIFO: assign costs at month-end
- FIFO: compare perpetual and periodic costs
- Compare all methods and systems for November
- Interpret the reported profit
- Read the cost policy before comparing companies
- Calculate inventory turnover and days
- Compare annual amounts under periodic methods
- Use total inventory for a manufacturer-wide comparison
- Distinguish reported profit from taxable income
- Qualifying to use LIFO for taxes
- Use a LIFO reserve for a comparable basis
- See the reserve in the remaining cost layers
- Use the disclosed annual reserve
- Adjust the measures to compare with companies using FIFO
- Identify a LIFO liquidation effect
- Dollar-value LIFO: compare inventory at the same prices
- Put beginning and ending inventory on the same price basis
- Identify the increase in the pool
- Assign a cost to the new layer
Review and resources
A retailer can buy the same product at different prices during a month. When it sells part of that inventory, it must assign some of the available cost to the sale. The rest remains in inventory. The quantity sold does not, by itself, establish which costs become expense.
In Chapter 15, Second Helping's inventory examples used a uniform unit cost. We could multiply the quantity by that cost. Here, we keep the distinction between goods sold and goods remaining, but introduce different acquisition costs. You will calculate how the company assigns those costs and interpret the resulting profit and inventory measures.
Amounts are in US dollars. Each new case states its period and assumptions; no balance carries forward from Chapter 15 unless expressly identified.
Review periodic and perpetual entries in Chapter 15 for how each system records inventory transactions.
Assign the cost of an identified item
Specific identification assigns the actual recorded cost of a particular item to its sale. The company retains records connecting that item to its acquisition cost. The method is useful when the items are individually distinct, such as diamonds with different characteristics and grading reports.
Consider a separate company, Facet Jewelers. Its December 2026 inventory contains these individually documented stones. Each letter identifies a particular stone and its attached grading report, not a category of diamonds.
| Stone | Identifying description | Acquisition cost |
|---|---|---|
| A | Round diamond with its own grading report | $2,400 |
| B | Emerald-cut diamond with its own grading report | $3,700 |
| C | Pear-shaped diamond with its own grading report | $5,100 |
Facet sells stones A and C. Their costs become cost of goods sold:
$2,400 + $5,100 = $7,500.
Facet started with diamonds costing $11,200. It sold stones A and C, so their $7,500 cost became cost of goods sold. Unsold stone B remains an inventory asset at its $3,700 cost.
Facet uses the costs of the stones actually sold. It cannot choose different stones' costs merely to report a preferred profit.
Facet sells stone B instead. Which cost becomes expense?
Compare your answer.
The cost of stone B, $3,700, becomes expense. The company does not average the stones' costs or select the oldest invoice. It identifies the stone sold and follows its recorded acquisition cost.
Assign costs to interchangeable goods
Second Helping sells interchangeable casserole dishes. A customer buying the same model receives the same product regardless of the retailer's purchase date. The company nevertheless may have paid different prices for those dishes.
A cost-flow assumption specifies which acquisition costs become expense and which remain in inventory. It does not prescribe which physical dish a warehouse employee selects. Under Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 330-10-30-9 through 30-11, accepted assumptions include first-in, first-out (FIFO), average cost, and last-in, first-out (LIFO).
The company uses FIFO, LIFO, or average cost to assign costs to goods sold and goods remaining. Under perpetual records, it assigns costs at each sale. Under periodic records, it assigns costs through a period-end calculation. Under both systems, the company recognizes sales revenue when control of the goods transfers to the customer.
These methods also apply to a manufacturer's finished goods. A retailer's inventory cost comes from purchasing merchandise; a manufacturer's finished-goods cost comes from materials, labor, and manufacturing overhead. Once production is complete, the manufacturer uses FIFO, LIFO, or average cost to assign those costs between goods sold and goods remaining.
- Mistaken idea: A label or FIFO result proves which unit moved
Mistaken reasoning: This mistake treats a product label as a supported specific unit cost trace or treats FIFO cost assignment as evidence of physical movement.
Read the full explanation
Purchases before the only sale
Use a separate November 2026 product example with no beginning inventory. The stated unit costs include all acquisition costs. There are no returns, shortages, freight adjustments, or write-downs.
| Date | Transaction | Acquisition cost |
|---|---|---|
| November 2 | Buy 12 dishes at $20 per dish. | $240 |
| November 10 | Buy 8 dishes at $30 per dish. | $240 |
| November 15 | Sell 6 dishes. | Assigned below. |
Available inventory is 20 dishes costing $480. After the sale, 14 dishes remain. We must assign the available cost between the sold and remaining dishes.
Second Helping makes both purchases before selling any dishes. Periodic and perpetual calculations therefore produce the same result for each method. That agreement depends on these transaction dates. We will change the sale date after comparing the cost methods.
First-in, first-out
First-in, first-out (FIFO) assigns the earliest available costs to goods sold. A cost layer is a quantity of units carried at a particular unit cost. Here, the earliest layer contains 12 dishes at $20 per dish.
The sale uses only part of that layer:
6 dishes × $20 per dish = $120 cost of goods sold.
The remaining inventory contains 6 dishes at $20 per dish and 8 dishes at $30 per dish. Its cost is $360. The oldest costs entered expense, so the more recent costs remain in inventory.
8 dishes × $30 = $240
6 dishes × $20 = $120
6 dishes × $20 = $120
6 dishes × $20 per dish
= $120.
If Second Helping sells another dish before buying more, what cost does FIFO assign to that sale?
Compare your answer.
FIFO assigns $20 to the next dish sold. After the first sale, 6 dishes remain in the November 2 cost layer. The company uses those costs before assigning any November 10 costs to a sale.
Last-in, first-out
Last-in, first-out (LIFO) assigns the latest available costs to goods sold. For this sale, the latest layer contains 8 dishes at $30 per dish. Both purchases have already occurred.
6 dishes × $30 per dish = $180 cost of goods sold.
Ending inventory costs $300. Second Helping sold the same quantity as under FIFO. It reports a different expense because it assigns the later, higher acquisition costs to the sale.
6 dishes × $30 = $180
12 dishes × $20 = $240
6 dishes × $30 per dish
= $180.
Would selecting the oldest physical dishes prevent the company from using LIFO?
Compare your answer.
No. LIFO is a cost assignment. A company can physically sell older goods while assigning more recent acquisition costs to expense. Inventory records must still account for the actual quantities sold and remaining.
Average cost
Weighted-average cost divides available cost by available units. Each unit contributes to the calculation, so a larger purchase receives more weight than a smaller purchase.
6 dishes × $24 per dish = $144 cost of goods sold.
Ending inventory costs $336.
6 dishes × $24 per dish
= $144.
Under every method, cost of goods sold plus ending inventory equals the original $480 cost:
| Method | Cost of goods sold | Ending inventory |
|---|---|---|
| FIFO | $120 | $360 |
| LIFO | $180 | $300 |
| Average cost | $144 | $336 |
For unchanged sales revenue, the higher expense under LIFO means lower gross profit. No method changed the quantity purchased, the quantity sold, or the amount paid to suppliers in this example.
Why is the weighted average below the simple midpoint of the purchase prices?
Compare your answer.
Second Helping purchased more dishes at the lower price. Dividing total cost by total units gives that larger purchase more weight. Averaging the invoice prices alone would treat the purchase quantities as equal.
Selling before the next purchase
Now change only the first sale date, from November 15 to November 6. The purchases, unit costs, and quantity sold remain unchanged. The retailer now sells the dishes before making its second purchase.
Buy 12 dishes
at $20 per dish
Sell 6 dishes
Buy 8 dishes
at $30 per dish
- Mistaken idea: The recordkeeping system selects cost flow or proves the count
Mistaken reasoning: This mistake treats periodic or perpetual record timing as a FIFO, average, or LIFO choice, or treats a running record as proof of physical quantity and ownership.
Read the full explanation
Periodic: assign costs at month-end
Under periodic accounting, Second Helping calculates cost of goods sold at the November close. It purchased 20 dishes costing $480, sold 6, and has 14 remaining. Those quantities and costs are unchanged even though the sale now occurs on November 6.
| Periodic method | Cost of goods sold | Ending inventory |
|---|---|---|
| FIFO | 6 dishes × $20 = $120 | $480 − $120 = $360 |
| LIFO | 6 dishes × $30 = $180 | $480 − $180 = $300 |
| Weighted average | 6 dishes × $24 = $144 | $480 − $144 = $336 |
The periodic weighted average remains:
Periodic LIFO uses the November 10 purchase costs because the company assigns costs at month-end using all purchases made during November.
At November close
8 dishes × $30 = $240
6 dishes × $20 = $120
6 dishes × $20 = $120
6 dishes × $20 per dish
= $120.
At November close
6 dishes × $30 = $180
12 dishes × $20 = $240
6 dishes × $30 per dish
= $180.
Perpetual: assign costs at each sale
Under perpetual accounting, the company assigns costs when it records the November 6 sale. At that date, only the first purchase is available. Each method assigns $20 per dish, making the sale's cost $120. On November 6, Second Helping has purchased only the $20 dishes, so each dish sold adds $20 to cost of goods sold.
6 dishes sold
6 dishes × $20 = $120
6 dishes × $20 per dish
= $120.
Compare periodic and perpetual costs for the November 6 sale
| Method | Periodic cost of goods sold | Perpetual cost of goods sold |
|---|---|---|
| FIFO | $120 | $120 |
| LIFO | $180 | $120 |
| Average cost | $144 | $120 |
Under perpetual LIFO, latest means the latest available costs at the time of that sale. Under periodic LIFO, the assignment uses the period's available costs. That difference explains the LIFO results above without changing the meaning of the cost method.
Can perpetual LIFO use the November 10 purchase cost for the November 6 sale?
Compare your answer.
No. The purchase had not occurred when the company recorded the sale. The periodic calculation can assign those later costs at the November close, but the perpetual calculation uses costs available at each sale.
Perpetual: record the November 10 purchase
8 dishes × $30 = $240
6 dishes × $20 = $120
After the November 10 purchase, inventory contains two purchase costs. At the next sale, FIFO, LIFO, and moving average can assign different costs.
Perpetual moving average: calculate the next sale cost
Continue the revised timeline. On November 18, Second Helping sells another 5 dishes. No further transactions occur during November. This adds a transaction to the revised case; it does not replace the first sale.
Under perpetual average cost, called moving average, the company recalculates the average after each purchase. A sale removes units and cost at the average then in effect. The sale itself does not change that unit average.
After each purchase, calculate the new average using the inventory still on hand and the goods just purchased:
Use the remaining inventory cost, after subtracting the costs of earlier sales. Then multiply the units in the next sale by this new average to calculate cost of goods sold.
The November 2 purchase cost $240. The November 6 sale removed $120 of that cost:
The sale also reduced the quantity from 12 dishes to 6.
6 dishes sold
6 dishes × $20 = $120
6 dishes × $20 per dish
= $120.
On November 10, Second Helping buys 8 more dishes for $240. Calculate the new average from the remaining inventory and this purchase:
November 10 purchase
8 dishes × $30 = $240
6 dishes × $20 = $120
= about $25.714286 per dish.
On November 18, Second Helping sells 5 dishes. Multiply that quantity by the new average to calculate cost of goods sold:
Subtract the sale's cost from the $360 available after the November 10 purchase:
November 18 sale
5 dishes sold
≈ $231.43
5 dishes × $25.714286 per dish
= $128.57, rounded to cents.
| Transaction | Cost assigned to the sale | Inventory cost after transaction |
|---|---|---|
| November 6 sale | $120 | $120 |
| November 10 purchase | No sale occurs. | $360 |
| November 18 sale | $128.57 | $231.43 |
Does the November 18 sale require another moving-average calculation?
Compare your answer.
No. Apply the average established after the November 10 purchase. Both quantity and cost leave inventory at that average. Recalculate when another purchase changes the available quantity and cost.
Compare periodic weighted average with perpetual moving average
Calculate the periodic weighted-average cost per unit using beginning inventory and all purchases during the period:
Second Helping has no beginning inventory. At the November close, its goods available for sale consist of the two purchases:
Apply that average to all 11 dishes sold during November:
| Inventory system and method | November cost of goods sold |
|---|---|
| Periodic weighted average | 11 dishes × $24 = $264 |
The November 10 purchase raises the periodic average applied to all November sales.
Under perpetual moving average, Second Helping uses the average available at each sale. The November 6 sale occurs before the higher-cost purchase, so its cost remains $120. Add the costs recorded for the two sales:
| Inventory system and method | November cost of goods sold |
|---|---|
| Perpetual moving average | $120 + $128.57 = $248.57 |
Perpetual LIFO: assign costs at each sale
Use the same revised timeline, including the November 18 sale. Under perpetual LIFO, the November 6 sale already cost $120.
6 dishes sold
6 dishes × $20 = $120
6 dishes × $20 per dish
= $120.
After the November 10 purchase, inventory contains 6 dishes at $20 and 8 dishes at $30 per dish.
November 10 purchase
8 dishes × $30 = $240
6 dishes × $20 = $120
The November 18 sale uses 5 dishes from the latest available layer:
5 dishes × $30 per dish = $150.
Total perpetual LIFO cost of goods sold is $270. The remaining layers contain 6 dishes at $20 and 3 dishes at $30 per dish, totaling $210.
November 18 sale
5 dishes sold
3 × $30 = $90
6 × $20 = $120
5 dishes × $30 per dish
= $150.
Periodic LIFO: assign costs at month-end
Under periodic LIFO, assign costs to all 11 dishes sold at month-end. Use the entire latest purchase first, then enough of the earlier purchase to complete the sold quantity. This produces cost of goods sold of $300 and ending inventory of $180.
FIFO: compare perpetual and periodic costs
Perpetual FIFO
Under perpetual FIFO, both sales use the earliest remaining costs. The second sale still fits within the first purchase layer, so it costs $100. Total expense is $220. The remaining inventory costs $260.
Periodic FIFO
Periodic FIFO assigns the same earliest costs to the period's sold quantity. For these ordinary purchases and sales, FIFO produces the same ending amounts under either system. Average cost and LIFO can differ when purchases and sales are interspersed.
Compare all methods and systems for November
The completed November case has 11 dishes sold and 9 remaining. Every row below reconciles to the same $480 available cost.
| Method and system | Cost of goods sold | Ending inventory |
|---|---|---|
| FIFO, either system | $220 | $260 |
| Periodic weighted average | $264 | $216 |
| Perpetual moving average | $248.57 | $231.43 |
| Periodic LIFO | $300 | $180 |
| Perpetual LIFO | $270 | $210 |
The physical count is identical under every method. Why do the reported inventory amounts differ?
Compare your answer.
The company assigns different costs to the same remaining quantity. A count establishes units, subject to the ownership checks from Chapter 15. The cost method and system establish which costs remain assigned to those units.
Interpret the reported profit
Gross profit equals sales revenue less cost of goods sold. Suppose Second Helping sells every dish in the completed November case for $48. Revenue is $528 under every method.
| Method and system | Sales revenue | Less: cost of goods sold | Gross profit |
|---|---|---|---|
| FIFO, either system | $528 | $220 | $308 |
| Periodic weighted average | $528 | $264 | $264 |
| Perpetual moving average | $528 | $248.57 | $279.43 |
| Periodic LIFO | $528 | $300 | $228 |
| Perpetual LIFO | $528 | $270 | $258 |
FIFO produces higher profit here because purchase prices rose and FIFO assigned the earlier, lower costs to expense. The company did not sell more dishes or charge more under FIFO. A comparison of profit must distinguish a change in cost assignment from a change in selling prices, sales volume, or purchase costs.
What if purchase prices fell instead? Imagine Second Helping buys 12 dishes at $30 each, then 8 dishes at $20 each. It sells 6 dishes after both purchases, at the same selling price under either method. Which method would now produce the higher gross profit?
FIFO assigns the earlier $30 cost to each dish sold, making cost of goods sold $180. LIFO assigns the later $20 cost, making cost of goods sold $120. LIFO assigns the most recent purchase costs to the sale. Because those costs are lower here, cost of goods sold is lower and gross profit is higher.
Under FIFO, ending inventory retains the most recent purchase costs. LIFO can retain much older costs, although perpetual LIFO may also leave newer costs from later purchases. Both methods use acquisition costs, which may differ from what the company would pay to replace the inventory today.
Read the cost policy before comparing companies
Under US generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), ASC 330-10-30-9 permits FIFO, average cost, and LIFO. ASC 330-10-50-1 requires consistent application and disclosure of the inventory basis. A company does not freely switch methods each year to obtain a preferred profit.
Read the inventory composition as well as the method. A retailer's merchandise and a manufacturer's total inventory contain different stages of goods.
International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) differ. International Accounting Standard (IAS) 2, paragraphs 23 and 25, uses specific identification for specified noninterchangeable items and FIFO or weighted average for other inventory. LIFO is not permitted. An IFRS company's inventory therefore cannot be assumed comparable to a US company's LIFO inventory without adjustment. See the IFRS Foundation's IAS 2 page.
Review inventory and cost of goods sold in Chapter 15 for how inventory costs move through the operating cycle.
Calculate inventory turnover and days
A company commits money to inventory before it sells the goods. Managers need enough inventory to fill orders, but holding goods adds storage costs and the risk of damage or obsolescence. Inventory turnover and days in inventory help managers assess how quickly goods sell relative to the inventory the company holds.
Inventory turnover estimates how many times a company sells an amount of inventory equal to its average stock during a period. Higher turnover can reflect faster sales relative to stock held; lower turnover can indicate slower sales or a buildup of stock. Accounting adjustments can also change the ratio without changing the movement of goods.
In some business contexts, turnover means sales revenue. Inventory turnover measures something different: how many times the company sold an amount equal to its average inventory. Because inventory is recorded at cost, we also measure the goods sold at cost. Using sales revenue would count the selling markup as though it were additional inventory sold.
Here, we estimate average inventory using the beginning and ending balances. We add those 2 balances and divide by 2:
A company may build inventory before a busy season and sell most of it before year-end. Beginning and ending balances can miss the higher inventory held during that season. More frequent observations, such as monthly balances, can better reflect inventory held throughout the period. For balances taken at regular intervals, add the balances and divide by the number of inventory balances included in the calculation:
The denominator counts balances, not periods. For example, averaging 12 month-end balances means dividing by 12. State which balances you use.
Days in inventory estimates how long the company holds goods before selling them, on average. The calculated days depend on the recorded costs used in turnover, rather than the actual purchase and sale dates of each item. Use the number of days in the reporting period and the unrounded turnover result:
Compare annual amounts under periodic methods
On January 1, 2027, Second Helping has inventory costing $20,000. All beginning inventory units have the same unit cost, so the beginning balance is the same under every method. During 2027, Second Helping purchases $70,000 of merchandise and earns $120,000 in sales revenue.
The supplied year-end cost assignments below describe the same physical goods and sales under alternative periodic methods. There are no shortages or write-downs. Use beginning and ending inventory to calculate the average, and use 365 days for the year.
| Amount | FIFO | Weighted average | LIFO |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beginning inventory | $20,000 | $20,000 | $20,000 |
| Ending inventory | $22,000 | $19,000 | $16,000 |
| Measure | FIFO | Weighted average | LIFO |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost of goods sold = Beginning inventory cost ($) + Purchases ($) − Ending inventory cost ($) | |||
| Calculation | $20,000 + $70,000 − $22,000 | $20,000 + $70,000 − $19,000 | $20,000 + $70,000 − $16,000 |
| Result | $68,000 | $71,000 | $74,000 |
| Average inventory cost = Beginning inventory cost ($) + Ending inventory cost ($)2 | |||
| Calculation | $20,000 + $22,0002 | $20,000 + $19,0002 | $20,000 + $16,0002 |
| Result | $21,000 | $19,500 | $18,000 |
| Inventory turnover = Cost of goods sold ($)Average inventory cost ($) | |||
| Calculation | $68,000$21,000 | $71,000$19,500 | $74,000$18,000 |
| Result | ≈ 3.24 times | ≈ 3.64 times | ≈ 4.11 times |
| Days in inventory = Days in the period × Average inventory cost ($)Cost of goods sold ($) | |||
| Calculation | 365 × $21,000$68,000 | 365 × $19,500$71,000 | 365 × $18,000$74,000 |
| Result | ≈ 112.7 days | ≈ 100.2 days | ≈ 88.8 days |
The days calculation uses inventory cost and cost of goods sold directly to avoid rounding turnover first. It is equivalent to dividing days in the period by inventory turnover.
Under FIFO, Second Helping's turnover of 3.24 means it sold about 3.24 times the amount it typically held in inventory, measured at cost. The 112.7-day estimate suggests that goods remain in inventory for roughly that long before sale. Managers can compare these measures with prior years and similar retailers to investigate changes in purchasing or sales.
LIFO produces higher turnover and fewer days in inventory than FIFO or weighted average in this example. Its cost of goods sold is higher, while its average inventory cost is lower. Physical sales and inventory quantities are unchanged, so these differences do not establish faster selling or better inventory management.
Higher turnover and fewer days in inventory can indicate that a company is selling goods faster while holding less inventory. But holding less inventory helps only if the company can still fill customer orders. If inventory falls because the company cannot obtain enough goods, turnover may rise even as it loses sales. To judge whether the increase is an improvement, consider why inventory fell and whether the company can meet customer demand.
Can you combine LIFO cost of goods sold with FIFO average inventory to improve comparability?
Compare your answer.
No. The numerator and denominator would use different cost bases. Adjust cost of goods sold and both inventory balances to the same basis before calculating the comparison. Adjusting only ending inventory also leaves an inconsistent average.
Use total inventory for a manufacturer-wide comparison
You can calculate inventory turnover for any span of time, such as a week, 6 weeks, a month, or a year. Use cost of goods sold and average inventory for that same span. Compare turnover over periods of equal length, while considering seasonal differences. To calculate days in inventory, use the actual number of days in the chosen period.
Homefield Advantage Athletics manufactures baseball gloves and uses FIFO. Its December 2027 cost of goods sold is $1,960. For its inventory turnover, include raw materials, work in process, and finished goods:
| Inventory | December 1 | December 31 |
|---|---|---|
| Raw materials | $410 | $530 |
| Work in process | $620 | $740 |
| Finished goods | $770 | $630 |
| Total inventory | $1,800 | $1,900 |
Average total inventory is $1,850. Dividing December cost of goods sold of $1,960 by that average gives 1.06 times during December. This is a monthly measure, not annual turnover.
Using only finished goods gives an average of $700 and turnover of 2.80 for the same month. Finished-goods turnover excludes raw materials and work in process from average inventory. Its smaller denominator produces a higher turnover ratio than total-inventory turnover for the same company. Comparing one manufacturer's finished-goods turnover with another's total-inventory turnover could therefore suggest a difference in selling speed that comes from which inventory accounts were included.
Why would using only Homefield's finished goods produce a higher turnover ratio?
Compare your answer.
The cost of goods sold stays the same, but average inventory is smaller when raw materials and work in process are excluded. The higher ratio does not mean Homefield sold more gloves.
Distinguish reported profit from taxable income
The annual comparison uses financial-reporting amounts. A difference in reported cost of goods sold does not, by itself, establish a difference in taxable income. The company must calculate taxable income under tax rules before estimating a tax effect.
Suppose a separate tax calculation establishes that Second Helping's taxable income would be $6,000 lower under LIFO than under FIFO. If that income would otherwise be taxed at 25%, with no other tax effects, the reduction in current income tax owed would be:
$6,000 reduction in taxable income × 25% = $1,500 reduction in current tax owed.
This calculation uses an assumed difference in taxable income, not the difference in financial-statement expense alone. It does not calculate total income tax expense for the financial statements, which can also include deferred taxes.
Qualifying to use LIFO for taxes
To use LIFO for US federal income taxes, a company generally must also use LIFO when reporting annual income to owners and lenders. This is the LIFO conformity requirement under Internal Revenue Code section 472(c) and Treasury Regulation section 1.472-2(e).
When rising costs make LIFO income lower than FIFO income, the company cannot use LIFO for taxes while presenting FIFO income as its primary annual income figure to owners or lenders. It can provide a FIFO comparison as supplemental information if it follows the regulation's disclosure requirements. The Internal Revenue Service's LIFO conformity guidance describes the permitted supplemental reporting.
Use a LIFO reserve for a comparable basis
A LIFO reserve is a disclosed difference between the LIFO carrying amount and another stated inventory basis. Read the company's definition before assuming the comparison basis is FIFO. For companies subject to Regulation S-X (including publicly traded companies and companies registering a public securities offering), Rule 5-02(6)(c) addresses disclosure of material replacement or current cost in excess of stated LIFO value.
See the reserve in the remaining cost layers
In Second Helping's first example, both purchases occur before the November 15 sale. After that sale, 14 dishes remain under either method. FIFO assigns those dishes $360 of cost; LIFO assigns them $300.
6 dishes × $30 = $180
6 dishes × $20 = $120
6 dishes × $20 = $120
6 dishes × $20 = $120
6 dishes × ($30 − $20) = $60
The other portions have the same assigned costs under both methods. The $60 reserve is the cost difference for the outlined 6 dishes. It does not represent additional goods.
Use the disclosed annual reserve
A company reports the following inventory amounts in its 2027 financial statements. Its inventory note defines the reserve as FIFO inventory minus LIFO inventory. All inventory is included in that comparison, and there are no other reconciling items.
| Amount | January 1, 2027 | December 31, 2027 |
|---|---|---|
| Reported LIFO inventory | $40,000 | $48,000 |
| FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve | $6,000 | $9,000 |
| Inventory on a FIFO basis | $46,000 | $57,000 |
Add each reserve to the LIFO inventory balance at the same date. To see how these balances affect cost of goods sold, compare the inventory accounts. The company reports LIFO cost of goods sold of $156,000. We can calculate purchases from its reported LIFO balances:
Both accounts include those same purchases. Beginning inventory and purchases are debits; the cost of goods sold leaves inventory as a credit.
To convert reported LIFO cost of goods sold to FIFO, adjust both inventory balances. The COGS calculation adds beginning inventory and subtracts ending inventory:
| Adjustment from LIFO to FIFO | Effect on COGS |
|---|---|
| Higher beginning inventory | Add $6,000. |
| Higher ending inventory | Subtract $9,000. |
We can express the same adjustments using the change in the LIFO reserve. Adding the beginning reserve and subtracting the ending reserve is equivalent to subtracting the increase in the reserve:
Calculate the change as ending reserve minus beginning reserve. If the reserve decreases, subtracting the negative change adds the decrease to LIFO cost of goods sold.
- Mistaken idea: The ending LIFO reserve is the period effect
Mistaken reasoning: This mistake uses an ending reserve instead of its change or treats liquidation income as evidence of better operations.
Read the full explanation
Adjust the measures to compare with companies using FIFO
Suppose you want to compare this company with a similar business that reports inventory under FIFO. Use the FIFO-adjusted cost of goods sold and inventory balances to calculate this company's measures on the same inventory cost basis.
The company has annual sales revenue of $260,000. Use the same beginning-and-ending average convention and 365 days.
| Measure | Reported LIFO basis | Adjusted FIFO basis |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of goods sold = Beginning inventory cost ($) + Purchases ($) − Ending inventory cost ($) | ||
| Calculation | $40,000 + $164,000 − $48,000 | $46,000 + $164,000 − $57,000 |
| Result | $156,000 | $153,000 |
| Average inventory cost = Beginning inventory cost ($) + Ending inventory cost ($)2 | ||
| Calculation | $40,000 + $48,0002 | $46,000 + $57,0002 |
| Result | $44,000 | $51,500 |
| Gross profit = Sales revenue ($) − COGS ($) | ||
| Calculation | $260,000 − $156,000 | $260,000 − $153,000 |
| Result | $104,000 | $107,000 |
| Gross profit rate = Gross profit ($)Sales revenue ($) × 100% | ||
| Calculation | $104,000$260,000 × 100% | $107,000$260,000 × 100% |
| Result | 40.00% | 41.15% |
| Inventory turnover = COGS ($)Average inventory cost ($) | ||
| Calculation | $156,000$44,000 | $153,000$51,500 |
| Result | ≈ 3.55 times | ≈ 2.97 times |
| Days in inventory = Days in the period × Average inventory cost ($)COGS ($) | ||
| Calculation | 365 × $44,000$156,000 | 365 × $51,500$153,000 |
| Result | ≈ 102.9 days | ≈ 122.9 days |
You can now compare the adjusted FIFO measures with those of the business using FIFO without mixing inventory cost methods. Differences in product mix, seasonality, purchasing, and customer demand can still affect that comparison. These calculations do not change the company's accounting records; it continues to report under LIFO.
Why not subtract the ending reserve from this year's cost of goods sold?
Compare your answer.
The ending reserve includes differences accumulated before this year. The current year's expense adjustment uses only the change between beginning and ending reserves. Both reserve balances are needed to explain that change.
Identify a LIFO liquidation effect
LIFO liquidation occurs when a reduction in inventory draws on older LIFO cost layers. The expense includes those historical costs. If they are below current costs, reported gross profit can rise even though the company has not improved its selling prices or current purchase costs.
Consider a separate Second Helping periodic LIFO case for 2028. Beginning inventory contains 40 dishes at $18 per dish. The company buys 70 dishes at $27 per dish and sells 85 dishes at $45 each. No other transactions occur.
Current purchases do not cover all units sold. The sale uses 15 units from the older layer.
| Cost assigned | Calculation | Expense |
|---|---|---|
| Current purchases | 70 dishes × $27 per dish | $1,890 |
| Older layer | 15 dishes × $18 per dish | $270 |
| Total cost of goods sold | Current costs plus older costs | $2,160 |
The 25 unsold dishes make up ending inventory, with a total cost of $450.
To see how the older layer affects cost of goods sold, suppose all 85 dishes sold had cost the current purchase price of $27 each. Compare that amount with the reported LIFO cost of goods sold:
| Cost of goods sold for the same 85 dishes | Calculation | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Using the current purchase price for every dish | 85 × $27 | $2,295 |
| Reported under LIFO | $1,890 + $270 | $2,160 |
| Reduction from using older costs | $2,295 − $2,160 | $135 |
Sales revenue is $3,825. Reported gross profit is $1,665, compared with $1,530 using the stated current-cost benchmark. The $135 difference arises because the 15 dishes from the older layer cost $18 each, below the current purchase price of $27. Those lower costs reduce COGS and increase gross profit; sales revenue is unchanged.
The profit effect need not be favorable. If the current-cost benchmark were $14 per dish instead, the same older costs would exceed it. The released older units would reduce gross profit by $60 relative to that lower benchmark.
A decline in a disclosed reserve does not, by itself, prove liquidation. Price changes and the inventory mix can also affect the difference between cost bases. Read the company's explanation and any quantified liquidation effect; do not label the entire reserve change a liquidation gain.
Does every LIFO liquidation increase profit?
Compare your answer.
No. Compare the released historical costs with the stated current-cost benchmark. Older costs below that benchmark raise reported profit relative to it; older costs above the benchmark reduce reported profit relative to it.
Dollar-value LIFO: compare inventory at the same prices
A company may end the year with fewer units of one product and more of another. Counting the units alone does not tell us whether inventory increased, because the products can have different costs. Price beginning and ending inventory at the same prices to compare the changed mix without price increases interfering.
Dollar-value LIFO uses that comparison for a pool, a group of goods whose combined inventory cost the company measures together. An increase in the pool's inventory at those common prices creates a new cost layer.
Put beginning and ending inventory on the same price basis
On January 1, 2027, a company begins using dollar-value LIFO with one inventory pool costing $100,000. The base year is the year the company begins using the method. Its base-year prices are the prices at the start of that year, January 1, 2027 in this example.
By December 31, the quantities and mix of products in the pool have changed. The ending inventory costs $132,000 at year-end prices. We need to find what that ending inventory would cost at January 1 prices before comparing it with the beginning inventory.
A price index compares the cost of the same ending mix at year-end prices and at base-year prices. For this course, the pool's index is supplied. You use it to calculate the inventory layers; you do not need to construct it.
| Information supplied | Amount |
|---|---|
| January 1 inventory at base-year prices | $100,000 |
| December 31 inventory at year-end prices | $132,000 |
| Price index for the ending inventory pool | 1.10 |
The index of 1.10 means the ending inventory costs 10% more at year-end prices than the same goods would cost at base-year prices. Divide by that index to find the base-year amount:
- Mistaken idea: A higher inventory index proves that the pool holds more goods
Mistaken reasoning: This mistake reads price movement as quantity movement and skips the conversion to base year cost.
Read the full explanation
Identify the increase in the pool
We can now compare both inventories at January 1 prices. Beginning inventory costs $100,000 at those prices; ending inventory costs $120,000. The difference is the new layer:
$100,000
$20,000
$100,000
Assign a cost to the new layer
The original layer keeps its $100,000 cost. The new layer was added when prices were higher, so multiply its base-year amount by the index for 2027:
| Layer | Calculation | Dollar-value LIFO cost |
|---|---|---|
| Original inventory | Retain its starting cost. | $100,000 |
| New 2027 layer | $20,000 × 1.10 | $22,000 |
| Ending inventory | $100,000 + $22,000 | $122,000 |
Dividing by the index lets us identify the new layer without counting price increases as additional inventory. Multiplying only that new layer by its index assigns its acquisition-year cost. The original layer is not repriced. Each layer keeps the price index from the year it was added. If the pool later shrinks at base-year prices, the company removes costs from its newest layers first. Treasury Regulation section 1.472-8(a) describes the base-year approach.
Why isn't the new layer $32,000, the difference between the starting cost and the inventory at year-end prices?
Compare your answer.
That difference includes price increases. Compare inventory at the same prices first: $120,000 − $100,000 = $20,000. Then price the new layer using its 1.10 index, giving $22,000.