Unit 5 · Chapter 16

Inventory cost methods: practice

About 15 minutes to read

Practice questions
  1. 1. Correct the cost assigned to a sale
  2. 2. Recover a missing purchase price
  3. 3. Test which costs are latest
  4. 4. Reconstruct the quantity sold
  5. 5. Correct a moving-average calculation
  6. 6. Evaluate a software-change claim
  7. 7. Find a perpetual LIFO timing error
  8. 8. Reconcile equal sales with different profits
  9. 9. Choose evidence for a replacement-cost estimate
  10. 10. Check the basis of a disclosed difference
  11. 11. Adjust expense when the reserve decreases
  12. 12. Test the effect of seasonal inventory
  13. 13. Correct a manufacturer comparison
  14. 14. Investigate an apparent turnover improvement
  15. 15. Finish an incomplete dollar-value LIFO calculation
  16. 16. Compare equal dollar increases
  17. 17. Test whether liquidation raises profit
  18. 18. Request evidence for a liquidation claim
  19. 19. Resolve conflicting inventory reports
  20. 19a. Identify the method from the first entry
  21. 19b. Explain the conflicting ending balances
  22. 19c. Test the direction of the average-cost difference
  23. 20. Compare two retailers on the same basis
  24. 20a. Test the reported profit ranking
  25. 20b. Make the turnover comparison consistent
  26. 20c. Decide what the comparison establishes

Use the records in each problem to decide which costs belong in inventory and expense. Check calculations in the number fields. For written responses, compare your reasoning with the worked explanation after you try the problem.

Problems 19 and 20 have related parts. Open "Review the scenario" within a part to see its background again. Amounts are in US dollars. Keep unrounded averages during calculations; round dollar answers to cents and turnover to two decimal places.

Review Chapter 16 as needed.

1. Correct the cost assigned to a sale

A shop uses specific identification for custom-built guitars. Its records show:

Guitar serial number Acquisition cost Purchase order
G14 $3,200 Earliest
G27 $4,800 Next
G38 $2,100 Latest

The delivery receipt identifies G27 as the guitar sold. The customer pays $6,500. An employee records the earliest guitar's cost as expense, saying that older costs should leave first.

Calculate the correct cost of goods sold, the required increase in that expense, and gross profit. Explain what happens to the inventory balance when the error is corrected.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

The delivery receipt identifies G27. Under specific identification, trace that serial number to its recorded acquisition cost of $4,800. Purchase order does not select the cost.

Increase in cost of goods sold = $4,800 − $3,200 = $1,600

Gross profit = $6,500 − $4,800 = $1,700

Inventory must decrease by another $1,600. The employee removed too little cost from inventory and recorded too little expense.

2. Recover a missing purchase price

A retailer uses first-in, first-out (FIFO). It begins May with 6 lamps at $10 each. It buys 10 more before making any sales, but the purchase's unit price is missing from a copied schedule.

The verified ending count is 7 lamps, and the FIFO ending inventory balance is $105. There are no other purchases, losses, or adjustments. Recover the missing unit purchase price and calculate May cost of goods sold.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

All 7 ending lamps carry costs from the latest purchase under FIFO. That purchase contained enough lamps to cover the ending quantity.

Unit purchase price = $1057 lamps = $15 per lamp

Cost of goods sold = 6 × $10 + 10 × $15 − $105 = $105

3. Test which costs are latest

A store uses last-in, first-out (LIFO). Its inventory available before its only sale is:

Layer Units Unit cost
Beginning inventory 4 $12
June 3 purchase 6 $20
June 18 purchase 5 $15

It sells 8 units on June 22. An employee records $160 of cost of goods sold by multiplying the sold quantity by the highest unit price. Calculate the correct LIFO expense and its overstatement. Explain why selecting the highest price fails.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

Correct expense = 5 × $15 + (8 − 5) × $20 = $135

Overstatement = $160 − $135 = $25

LIFO follows acquisition order. The latest purchase costs less than the earlier purchase here. The employee also assigns more units at the highest price than that layer contains.

4. Reconstruct the quantity sold

A store uses periodic weighted average. Beginning inventory contains 10 mugs at $8 each. Its only purchase adds 30 mugs at $12 each.

The verified cost-of-goods-sold balance is $275, but the sales-quantity total is missing from the report. Sales are the only inventory outflow. Determine how many mugs the store sold and the cost of its unsold mugs.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

Weighted-average unit cost = 10 × $8 + 30 × $1210 + 30 = $11

Units sold = $275$11 per mug = 25 mugs

Ending inventory = $440 − $275 = $165

The expense balance records sold units at the weighted-average cost. Dividing by that cost recovers the missing quantity.

5. Correct a moving-average calculation

A store has 12 pitchers at $10 each and sells 8 before its next purchase. It then buys 6 at $15 each. An employee calculates a new moving average using all the original pitchers plus the new purchase. Calculate the correct average and explain the employee's error.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

New average = $40 + $904 + 6 = $13.00 per pitcher

The earlier sale removed both units and their costs. Average only the inventory still on hand with the new purchase.

6. Evaluate a software-change claim

A retailer plans to replace periodic inventory records with perpetual software. It will retain FIFO. Assume the same beginning inventory, purchases, sales, and physical ending count under either system, with no errors or losses.

A manager expects higher gross profit solely because the software will record inventory costs sooner. Which response is supported?

Choose the best answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

Answer: D

D is correct. Perpetual records assign costs at each sale, but FIFO gives the same total cost of goods sold for these transactions under either system. The software changes when the cost entries are recorded; it does not create the claimed gross profit increase.

7. Find a perpetual LIFO timing error

A retailer begins August with 10 units at $20 each. It sells 6 on August 4 and buys 8 at $25 on August 10. Under perpetual LIFO, an employee records the August 4 sale cost as $150, using the August 10 price. Calculate the correct sale cost and the amount of the overstatement. Explain why the later price does not apply.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

August 4 cost of goods sold = 6 × $20 = $120

Overstatement = $150 − $120 = $30

Only beginning inventory was available when the retailer recorded the sale. Perpetual LIFO uses the latest costs available on that sale date.

8. Reconcile equal sales with different profits

Two stores have the same goods available at a total acquisition cost of $900. They sell the same quantity for revenue of $1,200 each and have the same ending quantity. There are no other inventory adjustments.

The FIFO store reports ending inventory of $300; the LIFO store reports $240. A manager says equal sales must mean equal gross profit. Calculate each store's gross profit and explain the difference using the inventory balances.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

FIFO cost of goods sold = $900 − $300 = $600

FIFO gross profit = $1,200 − $600 = $600

LIFO cost of goods sold = $900 − $240 = $660

LIFO gross profit = $1,200 − $660 = $540

The FIFO store retains $60 more cost in inventory. It therefore assigns that much less cost to expense and reports that much more gross profit. Equal sales revenue does not establish equal expense.

9. Choose evidence for a replacement-cost estimate

A retailer provides its LIFO inventory balance and a reserve explicitly measured as FIFO minus LIFO. A lender wants an estimate of what replacing the goods would cost today. Supplier prices have changed since the last purchases.

Which additional information directly supports that estimate?

Choose the best answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

Answer: B

B is correct. Match the quantities and types of goods on hand with current supplier prices for those goods. Adding the disclosed reserve gives FIFO acquisition cost, which need not equal today's replacement cost.

10. Check the basis of a disclosed difference

A company reports inventory at $50,000 under LIFO. Its note says current cost exceeds the reported amount by $20,000. A separate schedule values the same inventory at $60,000 under FIFO.

An employee adds the disclosed current-cost difference to LIFO and calls the result FIFO inventory. Calculate the actual FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve. Explain which inventory basis the employee calculated.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve = $60,000 − $50,000 = $10,000

Employee's amount = $50,000 + $20,000 = $70,000

The employee calculated current-cost inventory. The note and the separate schedule use different comparison bases; their differences from LIFO cannot be substituted for each other.

11. Adjust expense when the reserve decreases

A company's FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve falls from $5,000 at the start of 2027 to $4,200 at year-end. Reported LIFO cost of goods sold is $110,000. Purchases are the same under both methods, and there are no other adjustments. Calculate FIFO cost of goods sold.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

FIFO cost of goods sold = $110,000 + $5,000 − $4,200 = $110,800

Converting to FIFO adds the beginning inventory difference and subtracts the ending difference. Because the ending difference is smaller, FIFO cost of goods sold exceeds LIFO cost of goods sold.

12. Test the effect of seasonal inventory

A retailer reports cost of goods sold of $120,000 for January through April. Its inventory records show:

Date Inventory cost
January 1 $10,000
January 31 $10,000
February 28 $30,000
March 31 $50,000
April 30 $30,000

A report uses only January 1 and April 30 and shows turnover of 6 times. Recalculate average inventory and turnover using the four month-end balances. Explain why the revised ratio differs even though sales have not changed.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

Average inventory = $10,000 + $30,000 + $50,000 + $30,0004 = $30,000

Four-month turnover = $120,000$30,000 = 4 times

The endpoint average is $20,000. It misses the larger inventory balance in March. The monthly average includes that balance, so the denominator rises and turnover falls. The change reflects a different inventory estimate, not a change in sales activity.

13. Correct a manufacturer comparison

A manufacturer reports quarterly cost of goods sold of $60,000. Its average inventory costs for the quarter are $4,000 in raw materials, $6,000 in work in process, and $10,000 in finished goods.

A manager divides cost of goods sold by finished goods and reports turnover of 6 times. A competitor reports total-inventory turnover of 3 times for the same quarter on the same cost basis. The manager claims that the manufacturer sells inventory twice as fast.

Calculate the manufacturer's total-inventory turnover and assess the claim.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

Average total inventory = $4,000 + $6,000 + $10,000 = $20,000

Total-inventory turnover = $60,000$20,000 = 3 times

The manager compared different inventory definitions. Once all manufacturing inventory is included, the two reported ratios are equal. The original comparison does not establish faster selling.

14. Investigate an apparent turnover improvement

A retailer's turnover rises after suppliers begin delivering late. Average inventory falls, unit sales decline, and customers complain that shelves are empty. The cost method and reporting-period length are unchanged.

Which response best addresses whether inventory management improved?

Choose the best answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

Answer: A

A is correct. The lower inventory balance raises turnover relative to the goods held, but the store may be losing sales because goods are unavailable. Unfilled orders and stock availability help test that explanation.

15. Finish an incomplete dollar-value LIFO calculation

A company adopts dollar-value LIFO with one pool costing $80,000. At the end of its first year, inventory costs $110,000 at current prices. The supplied price index is 1.25, using the adoption year as the base year.

An employee divides the current-price amount by the index and reports $88,000 as LIFO inventory. Identify the missing step. Calculate the correct LIFO balance and the amount by which the employee understated it.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

The employee correctly converted the ending pool to base-year prices. That amount identifies pool growth but does not finish the layer valuation.

New layer at base-year prices = $88,000 − $80,000 = $8,000

New layer cost = $8,000 × 1.25 = $10,000

LIFO inventory = $80,000 + $10,000 = $90,000

Understatement = $90,000 − $88,000 = $2,000

Keep the original layer at its original cost and price the new layer using its acquisition-year index.

16. Compare equal dollar increases

Two companies each adopt dollar-value LIFO with a single pool costing $60,000. Each reports a first-year ending pool of $75,000 at current prices. Company A's supplied index is 1.25; Company B's is 1.20. Each index uses that company's adoption year as its base year.

A manager says the equal dollar increases mean equal additions to the pools. Calculate each new layer at base-year prices and assess that claim.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

Company A new layer = $75,0001.25 − $60,000 = $0

Company B new layer = $75,0001.20 − $60,000 = $2,500

Company A's entire increase is explained by its price index. Company B's pool increased even after removing its smaller price increase. Equal current-price dollar increases do not establish equal growth measured at base-year prices.

17. Test whether liquidation raises profit

A retailer begins with 20 units at $30 each, buys 50 at $22, and then sells 60. It uses LIFO. For comparison, use $22 as the current cost of every unit sold.

The controller says using older layers must increase gross profit. Calculate LIFO cost of goods sold and cost of goods sold at the stated current-cost benchmark. Determine whether the controller's claim holds and quantify the gross profit difference.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

LIFO cost of goods sold = 50 × $22 + 10 × $30 = $1,400

Current-cost benchmark = 60 × $22 = $1,320

The older costs are higher here. LIFO expense exceeds the current-cost benchmark by $80, so gross profit is lower by that amount. Liquidation does not always increase profit.

18. Request evidence for a liquidation claim

A company's positive FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve decreases but remains positive. Its manager calls the entire decrease a profit benefit from LIFO liquidation. The note provides no explanation of the change.

Which additional evidence would directly test the claimed liquidation benefit?

Choose the best answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

Answer: C

C is correct. Determine whether the company used older layers, then compare their costs with the costs used as the profit benchmark. Reserve changes can also reflect prices or product mix, so the reserve decline alone does not measure a liquidation benefit.

19. Resolve conflicting inventory reports

Copper Kettle uses a perpetual system for travel mugs. Its September records contain only these transactions. There are no shortages or other adjustments.

Date Transaction Unit acquisition cost
September 1 Beginning inventory: 10 mugs $18
September 4 Buy 6 mugs $25
September 8 Sell 12 mugs
September 15 Buy 8 mugs $20
September 20 Sell 5 mugs

The September 8 entry records cost of goods sold of $258. The report omits the method name. Two month-end schedules show the same verified quantity, 7 mugs, but different inventory costs: $126 and $132. Neither schedule names its inventory system.

19a. Identify the method from the first entry

Review the scenario

Copper Kettle uses a perpetual system for travel mugs. Its September records contain only these transactions. There are no shortages or other adjustments.

Date Transaction Unit acquisition cost
September 1 Beginning inventory: 10 mugs $18
September 4 Buy 6 mugs $25
September 8 Sell 12 mugs
September 15 Buy 8 mugs $20
September 20 Sell 5 mugs

The September 8 entry records cost of goods sold of $258. The report omits the method name. Two month-end schedules show the same verified quantity, 7 mugs, but different inventory costs: $126 and $132. Neither schedule names its inventory system.

Calculate the September 8 sale cost under FIFO, LIFO, and moving average. Which method matches the recorded entry?

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

FIFO = 10 × $18 + (12 − 10) × $25 = $230

LIFO = 6 × $25 + (12 − 6) × $18 = $258

Moving average sale cost = 10 × $18 + 6 × $2510 + 6 × 12 = $247.50

Only LIFO matches the recorded expense. The physical quantity sold would be the same under all three methods.

19b. Explain the conflicting ending balances

Review the scenario

Copper Kettle uses a perpetual system for travel mugs. Its September records contain only these transactions. There are no shortages or other adjustments.

Date Transaction Unit acquisition cost
September 1 Beginning inventory: 10 mugs $18
September 4 Buy 6 mugs $25
September 8 Sell 12 mugs
September 15 Buy 8 mugs $20
September 20 Sell 5 mugs

The September 8 entry records cost of goods sold of $258. The report omits the method name. Two month-end schedules show the same verified quantity, 7 mugs, but different inventory costs: $126 and $132. Neither schedule names its inventory system.

Use perpetual LIFO for the recorded transactions. Calculate total September cost of goods sold and select the ending-inventory schedule that agrees with the records. Then calculate periodic LIFO cost of goods sold to explain the other schedule. Does the difference establish missing mugs?

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

Perpetual LIFO expense = $258 + 5 × $20 = $358

Perpetual LIFO ending inventory = $490 − $358 = $132

Periodic LIFO expense = 8 × $20 + 6 × $25 + (17 − 8 − 6) × $18 = $364

Periodic LIFO leaves $126 in inventory. Both schedules value the same 7 mugs. Their different cost assignments do not establish a physical shortage.

19c. Test the direction of the average-cost difference

Review the scenario

Copper Kettle uses a perpetual system for travel mugs. Its September records contain only these transactions. There are no shortages or other adjustments.

Date Transaction Unit acquisition cost
September 1 Beginning inventory: 10 mugs $18
September 4 Buy 6 mugs $25
September 8 Sell 12 mugs
September 15 Buy 8 mugs $20
September 20 Sell 5 mugs

The September 8 entry records cost of goods sold of $258. The report omits the method name. Two month-end schedules show the same verified quantity, 7 mugs, but different inventory costs: $126 and $132. Neither schedule names its inventory system.

For a separate comparison, apply moving average and periodic weighted average to the same September transactions. Calculate total September cost of goods sold under each system. Which is higher here, and how does the later, lower-cost purchase affect the comparison?

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

Periodic weighted-average expense = $49024 × 17 ≈ $347.08

After the first sale, 4 mugs remain at a total cost of $82.50. The September 15 purchase adds 8 mugs at a total cost of $160.

New moving average after September 15 = $82.50 + $1604 + 8 ≈ $20.208333 per mug

September 20 expense = 5 mugs × $20.208333 per mug ≈ $101.04

Moving-average expense = $247.50 + $101.04 = $348.54

Moving-average expense is higher here. The September 15 purchase lowers the periodic average applied to all September sales. Under perpetual records, that purchase affects the average for the second sale but does not change the expense already recorded on September 8.

20. Compare two retailers on the same basis

Retailer A uses LIFO; Retailer B uses FIFO. Each reports 2027 sales revenue of $200,000. Their notes provide the following amounts. A's reserve is explicitly FIFO minus LIFO. Assume identical purchases under A's alternative cost methods, no other conversion adjustments, and a consistent inventory definition.

Amount Retailer A: LIFO Retailer B: FIFO
Beginning inventory $40,000 $46,000
Ending inventory $45,000 $50,000
Cost of goods sold $140,000 $142,000
Beginning FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve $8,000 Not applicable
Ending FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve $5,000 Not applicable

The retailers sell different product mixes. No data on quantities sold, unfilled orders, or obsolete goods are supplied.

20a. Test the reported profit ranking

Review the scenario

Retailer A uses LIFO; Retailer B uses FIFO. Each reports 2027 sales revenue of $200,000. Their notes provide the following amounts. A's reserve is explicitly FIFO minus LIFO. Assume identical purchases under A's alternative cost methods, no other conversion adjustments, and a consistent inventory definition.

Amount Retailer A: LIFO Retailer B: FIFO
Beginning inventory $40,000 $46,000
Ending inventory $45,000 $50,000
Cost of goods sold $140,000 $142,000
Beginning FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve $8,000 Not applicable
Ending FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve $5,000 Not applicable

The retailers sell different product mixes. No data on quantities sold, unfilled orders, or obsolete goods are supplied.

Which retailer initially appears to have higher gross profit? Convert A's cost of goods sold and gross profit to FIFO. Calculate B's gross profit and determine whether the ranking changes.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

A initially reports gross profit of $60,000, exceeding B's $58,000. Convert both of A's inventory balances when adjusting expense:

A FIFO expense = $140,000 + $8,000 − $5,000 = $143,000

A FIFO gross profit = $200,000 − $143,000 = $57,000

B FIFO gross profit = $200,000 − $142,000 = $58,000

The ranking reverses: B has higher gross profit on the common FIFO basis. A's decreasing reserve increases its FIFO expense relative to reported LIFO expense.

20b. Make the turnover comparison consistent

Review the scenario

Retailer A uses LIFO; Retailer B uses FIFO. Each reports 2027 sales revenue of $200,000. Their notes provide the following amounts. A's reserve is explicitly FIFO minus LIFO. Assume identical purchases under A's alternative cost methods, no other conversion adjustments, and a consistent inventory definition.

Amount Retailer A: LIFO Retailer B: FIFO
Beginning inventory $40,000 $46,000
Ending inventory $45,000 $50,000
Cost of goods sold $140,000 $142,000
Beginning FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve $8,000 Not applicable
Ending FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve $5,000 Not applicable

The retailers sell different product mixes. No data on quantities sold, unfilled orders, or obsolete goods are supplied.

Calculate both retailers' 2027 inventory turnover on a FIFO basis. Use each retailer's average beginning and ending inventory. Explain why converting only A's ending balance would leave an inconsistent calculation.

Enter your answer.
Show explanationHide explanation

A beginning FIFO inventory = $40,000 + $8,000 = $48,000

A ending FIFO inventory = $45,000 + $5,000 = $50,000

A average FIFO inventory = $48,000 + $50,0002 = $49,000

A FIFO turnover = $143,000$49,000 ≈ 2.92 times

B average FIFO inventory = $46,000 + $50,0002 = $48,000

B FIFO turnover = $142,000$48,000 ≈ 2.96 times

A's numerator and both balances in its denominator must use FIFO. Adjusting only ending inventory would mix cost bases in both the expense and average-inventory calculations.

20c. Decide what the comparison establishes

Review the scenario

Retailer A uses LIFO; Retailer B uses FIFO. Each reports 2027 sales revenue of $200,000. Their notes provide the following amounts. A's reserve is explicitly FIFO minus LIFO. Assume identical purchases under A's alternative cost methods, no other conversion adjustments, and a consistent inventory definition.

Amount Retailer A: LIFO Retailer B: FIFO
Beginning inventory $40,000 $46,000
Ending inventory $45,000 $50,000
Cost of goods sold $140,000 $142,000
Beginning FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve $8,000 Not applicable
Ending FIFO-minus-LIFO reserve $5,000 Not applicable

The retailers sell different product mixes. No data on quantities sold, unfilled orders, or obsolete goods are supplied.

A manager concludes that B's higher FIFO gross profit and turnover prove that B manages inventory better. Write a response that separates what the adjusted figures establish from what still needs investigation. Identify operating information that could change the conclusion.

Compare your answer

The common FIFO basis removes one accounting-method difference. B has higher gross profit and turnover on that basis for the stated year, but those results do not establish better inventory management.

Different product mixes can involve different margins and holding periods. Review product-level sales and margins, stock availability and unfilled orders, seasonal inventory balances, and obsolete goods. For example, higher turnover caused by shortages would not establish better service to customers. The supplied statements do not resolve these operating questions.