Under US GAAP, lower of cost or market applies to inventory measured using last-in, first-out (LIFO) or the retail inventory method. The company compares recorded cost with a limited measure of current replacement cost called designated market.
Replacement cost is what the company would spend now to obtain goods with equivalent usefulness. It may differ from the amount the company expects to recover by selling the goods already held.
Establish the limits
The ceiling is net realizable value (NRV). Replacement cost above that ceiling would exceed the expected net proceeds from selling the inventory.
The floor is NRV less an allowance for an approximately normal profit. When replacement cost falls below the floor, the floor becomes designated market, which the company then compares with recorded cost. The floor can limit the write-down and prevent an unusually large profit when the goods are later sold. If recorded cost is already below designated market, no write-down is needed.
Course calculations supply the normal profit allowance; you do not need to estimate it.
| Replacement cost | Designated market |
|---|---|
| Above the ceiling | NRV |
| Between the floor and ceiling | Replacement cost |
| Below the floor | NRV less the normal profit allowance |
Compare designated market with cost
After applying the limits, report the lower of designated market and recorded cost. The loss is the amount by which recorded cost exceeds that carrying amount. If market exceeds cost, inventory remains at cost.
A low replacement cost alone does not establish a loss. When evidence indicates that the company will recover recorded cost with an approximately normal profit, no loss is recognized. Firm sales contracts can provide that protection.
The worked example uses replacement cost within the bounds. The practice question uses replacement cost below the floor.
Accounting sources
ASC 330-10-35-1A and 35-1C through 35-7 address this rule, including judgment about recovery. Consult the Market definition in the ASC Master Glossary. Open FASB's Inventory topic and select those locations; sign in or register if prompted.
Put the concept to work
Understand this concept
- Explain how the ceiling and floor limit replacement cost when calculating designated market for LIFO or retail-method inventory.
Apply this concept
- Calculate designated market, the required carrying amount, and the write-down for LIFO or retail-method inventory, showing both limits.
Learning resources
Choose a lesson, try an application, or inspect the sources behind this concept.
Build on these ideas
- Inventory net realizable value — Understand
To understand this concept: Required. NRV supplies the market ceiling and helps determine the floor.
- Lower of cost or market — Understand
To apply this concept: Required. The sequence prevents using unconstrained replacement cost.
Lessons
Worked examples and cases
Practice
Common mistaken ideas
Sources
Broader topics
Related concepts
Show 1 more related concepts
Use this idea next
- Lower of cost or market — Apply
Required level here: understand. Required. The sequence prevents using unconstrained replacement cost.
Used in these readings
These chapters explain or apply this concept. The label states how the chapter uses it.