Compare one primary company with two peers using their annual financial statements and notes.
Explain the companies' reported results and accounting choices using calculations, filing facts,
and Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) guidance. Submit an Excel workbook and a written report in Word or PDF at each stage: the 40-point midpoint
and the 70-point final company analysis.
Everything for the final company analysis is on the
final company analysis page. This page covers company selection and the midpoint.
Project dates
Final submission deadline. The final project and take-home case assignment are due Thursday, December 17 at 1 p.m. Eastern time. This is earlier than the usual 11:59 p.m. deadline. I will accept the final company analysis up to 24 hours late, until Friday, December 18 at 1 p.m. Eastern time. Late company analyses receive a deduction of 10% of the possible points, unless an approved extension or protected absence applies. The separate take-home case assignment may be submitted late until Friday, December 18 at 11:59 p.m. Eastern time, unless I have agreed to other arrangements.
All deadlines below are in Eastern time in 2026. Submit your work through D2L.
Submission
Due
Points
Company choices
Friday, October 9, 11:59 p.m.
Not graded
Replacements, if required
Wednesday, October 14, 11:59 p.m.
Not graded
Midpoint company analysis
Friday, October 30, 11:59 p.m.
40
Final company analysis
Thursday, December 17, 1 p.m.
70
Separate take-home analysis
Thursday, December 17, 1 p.m.
30
The 30-point take-home analysis uses supplied company facts and has separate instructions.
It is not one of the company-project submissions described below.
Choose your primary company and two peers
Submit only 3 ticker symbols in D2L and identify your primary company. Choose 2 peers
in the same industry. Use each company's most recent Form 10-K, prepared under
US generally accepted accounting principles (US GAAP), with the same reporting currency.
The filings must include 2 comparable annual income statements, 2 annual cash-flow periods,
and 2 balance-sheet dates. The companies' latest annual periods must overlap by at least 9 months.
Banks, insurers, investment funds, brokerages, and similar financial institutions are not eligible.
Choose a group that has enough information for both stages. All 3 companies need the
required midpoint amounts. For the final, the primary company and one selected peer per topic
must supply information for 5 topics. The same peer may serve every topic.
Include at least 2 Regular reporting topics and
at least 1 Specific event or exposure topic.
Green means the saved filing search found the required information. Yellow means the
search has not confirmed it; yellow topics do not count toward the required total.
A yellow result does not prove that the filing lacks the information.
The checker does not submit your choices to D2L.
Read the topic questions before selecting your companies. A reported account balance alone
may not provide the disclosures needed for the required comparison.
Midpoint: 40 points
Submit an Excel workbook and a written report in Word or PDF containing 3 written elements.
Complete all 3:
Explain the primary company's profitability and compare it with both peers in the income analysis.
Explain the selected ASC guidance and apply it to a company item in the ASC research and application.
Assess reported earnings using operating cash flow and compare all 3 companies in the operating-cash-flow analysis.
Use separate headings for the income analysis, ASC research and application, and operating-cash-flow analysis.
Keep financial statements and calculations in the Excel workbook. Include all ASC research in the written report.
The lengths below are suggestions, not required minimums or maximums. Answer every part of each question fully.
Answers will be graded for completeness, accuracy, and reasoning rather than word count.
Use your primary company and both peers. Use each company's 2 most recent fiscal years.
Submit
Excel workbook + Word or PDF reportInclude income analysis, ASC research and application, and operating-cash-flow analysis. Submit through D2L.
Company periods
3 companies, 2 fiscal yearsUse the 2 most recent fiscal years.
Due
October 30, 202611:59 p.m. Eastern time
Required report section 1 · Unit 2
Income analysis
Suggested length: 300 to 400 words, excluding tables, calculations, and citations. The ASC research has a separate suggested length.
How did the primary company's reported profitability change over the 2 most
recent fiscal years, and how does its most recent-year profitability compare with both
peers? Explain how 1 selected ASC research item affects your interpretation of those results.
Complete this calculation work for all 3 companies and both fiscal years:
Rebuild gross profit, operating income, and income before income taxes from the reported statement lines.
Calculate gross profit rate, operating margin, and net profit margin.
Identify the statement lines and expense classifications you use. Explain differences that affect a comparison.
Use the calculations to explain the primary company's profitability change and its
comparison with each peer. Choose 1 item from the ASC research menu.
Refer to your ASC research finding when it affects your interpretation of profitability.
Give the full explanation in the separate ASC research and application section.
Required report section 2 · ASC research
ASC research and application
Suggested length: 200 to 300 words, excluding tables, calculations, and citations.
Choose 1 item from the approved ASC research menu that appears in your primary company's filing.
Answer its fixed research question in this report section:
State your selected question and identify the ASC topic, subtopic, section, and paragraph that directly answer it.
Explain the accounting guidance in your own words.
Identify the company item, its filing note location, and the income-statement subtotal it affects.
Apply the guidance to that item and explain how it affects your interpretation of profitability.
Include the ASC question, citations, guidance explanation, and company application in this written-report section.
Refer to the research finding in your income analysis without repeating the full explanation.
Required report section 3 · Unit 4
Operating-cash-flow analysis
Suggested length: 350 to 500 words, excluding tables, calculations, and citations.
How does operating cash flow affect your assessment of the primary company's
reported earnings over the 2 most recent fiscal years? Compare the primary company with
both peers, using the course-defined free-cash-flow measure. Explain whether earnings and
operating cash flow move together, differ, or show a mixed pattern. State what the reported
cash-flow information does and does not show.
For this project, free cash flow equals net cash provided by operating activities minus
cash paid for property, plant, and equipment. It is a course-defined measure, not a
US generally accepted accounting principles (US GAAP)
subtotal. It may differ from a company's own free-cash-flow measure.
Complete the following cash-flow work:
Rebuild the primary company's most recent indirect-method reconciliation from net income to operating cash flow.
Identify its 2 largest reconciling adjustments by absolute amount. Classify each as noncash or an operating working-capital change.
Calculate the course-defined free cash flow for all 3 companies and both years.
Compare net income, operating cash flow, and free cash flow over both years for all 3 companies.
Organize this report section into 3 short parts: your primary-company conclusion,
the 2 largest adjustments, and a comparison with each peer plus 1 limit of the filing information.
You do not need to estimate customer cash collections.
Enter the full balance sheet, income statement, and cash-flow statement for each company.
Keep the reported labels, units, periods, and totals. Include the 2 years used in your analysis.
Identify the filing and statement locations.
Use a separate tab for each company's balance sheet, income statement, and cash-flow statement.
Keep separate tabs for income calculations and cash-flow calculations. You decide how to arrange
the calculations and checks within those tabs. Use spreadsheet formulas, not typed calculation results.
The workbook template provides blank work areas. Keep the supplied tab names, and add rows, columns, or extra tabs as needed.
Choose the statement labels, line order, classifications, subtotal placement, and formulas yourself.
Complete the company name, period, currency, and units fields on each statement tab.
Enter each balance-sheet date and the beginning and ending dates for each income and cash-flow period.
Record assumptions and explain any combined lines or presentation differences that affect
your work. A reader must be able to follow a report amount back to its formula and filing source.
The final uses a separate workbook. You do not need to copy the midpoint statement tabs.
Do not add unfinished final calculations to the midpoint submission.
Before you submit the midpoint
Attach the editable Excel workbook with financial statements, calculation formulas, and filing locations.
Attach 1 Word or PDF report with separate income analysis, ASC research and application, and operating-cash-flow sections.
Identify filing locations for amounts and company facts, and exact ASC citations for the accounting guidance.
State whether you used an AI tool. If you did, name it and describe its contribution.
Check every calculation, source, citation, and conclusion before submitting both files through D2L.
Choose one ASC research item
Required at midpoint
Choose 1 item below that appears in your primary company's filing. The Accounting
Standards Codification (ASC) supplies the accounting guidance; the filing supplies the company facts.
Include this research in a separate section of your midpoint Word or PDF report.
Both the income analysis and the operating-cash-flow analysis are required.
Your research response
Answer the fixed question for your choice. Identify the ASC topic, subtopic, section,
and paragraph that directly answer it. Explain the guidance in your own words.
Identify the company item, its note location, and the income-statement subtotal it affects.
Explain how the item changes your interpretation of profitability.
The questions concern different kinds of guidance. You do not need to use section 25
for every choice. A paragraph is acceptable when it directly answers your selected question.
Stock-based compensation
When does a company recognize compensation cost for goods or services received in a share-based payment transaction?
Restructuring or exit costs
When does a company recognize a liability for an exit or disposal activity?
Foreign-currency transaction gain or loss
When can a foreign-currency transaction gain or loss be excluded from net income?
Derivative gain or loss
How does hedge designation affect the reporting of a change in a derivative's fair value?
Pension or other postretirement cost
Where must a company report service cost and the other components of net periodic benefit cost in the income statement?
Lease cost
What lease costs must a lessee recognize in profit or loss after the commencement date?
Advertising cost
When must advertising costs be expensed?
Income-tax expense or benefit
What measurement basis does ASC require for current and deferred income taxes?
Valuation allowance for deferred tax assets
What evidence does a company consider when deciding whether a valuation allowance for deferred tax assets is needed?
Equity-method income or loss
When does an investor recognize its share of an investee's earnings or losses?
Noncontrolling-interest allocation
How does a consolidated company attribute net income or loss between the parent and noncontrolling interest?
Change in accounting estimate
When does a company account for a change in accounting estimate prospectively?
Midpoint rubric
40 points
The rubric totals 40 points. There are no separate points for copying financial statements.
The reliability of your calculations and the quality of your analysis are what will be graded.
Criterion
Points
Full-credit work
Income numerical work
4
Reliable subtotals, margins, formulas, and source-line mapping for all required company-years.
Profitability comparison
5
Explain the primary company's 2-year profitability pattern and compare it with both peers using the required measures.
ASC research and application
6
Give an accurate ASC citation and rule, explain the company item, and show how it affects the income analysis.
Client-ready income analysis
3
Reach a specific, useful conclusion. Explain implications and relevant limits rather than restating amounts or ratios.
Cash-flow numerical work
6
Correct free-cash-flow calculations for all required company-years and a complete primary-company indirect-method reconciliation.
Earnings, cash-flow, and free-cash-flow comparison
5
Explain the primary company's 2-year earnings-to-cash pattern and compare it with both peers.
Cash-flow limits and judgment
4
State what the cash-flow information supports and does not support. Avoid conclusions that the filings cannot establish.
Client-ready cash-flow analysis
3
Provide a specific, useful conclusion supported by the company's cash-flow information rather than a generic description.
Filing evidence and workpaper traceability
4
Identify filing locations, assumptions, formulas, and inputs so a reader can check the analysis.
Total
40
Different statement labels are acceptable when you correctly connect them to the required
calculations. A single incorrect source-line choice receives one deduction under the relevant
calculation criterion, not a new deduction for every result using that input.
Write a company-specific analysis that a client or manager can use. Explain what the
results mean and where the available information limits your conclusion. Repeating figures
or giving a general description of an accounting topic is not enough for full credit.
AI use is allowed. State whether you used a tool, name it, and explain its contribution.
Check every calculation, filing fact, ASC citation, and conclusion yourself.
Final company analysis
The final company analysis page holds everything for the final:
the due date, the files to submit, the topics each primary company supports, the instructions,
and every topic's requirements.
Sources and AI use
Identify the filing locations for your numbers and company facts. Use the ASC for the
accounting guidance. Keep your formulas and source amounts available so a reader can
check your calculations. Distinguish reported facts from your calculations and assumptions.
You may use AI tools. State whether you used one, name the tool, and describe its
contribution. You remain responsible for every number, source, ASC citation, and conclusion.
Write an analysis that a client or manager can use. Explain the selected companies' results,
make comparisons using verified sources, and state what the available information cannot establish.
Your grade is based on the submitted work, regardless of whether you used AI.
See the syllabus for course policies and the
schedule for class dates.