In this chapter
- Inventory in the operating cycle
- Inventory held for resale
- Inventory in manufacturing
- Establish the acquisition cost
- Second Helping’s purchase
- Homefield’s production cost
- Recording Homefield’s manufacturing costs
- Record the same transactions under each system
- Purchase entries
- Sale entries and the inventory reconciliation
- Compare the records with a physical count
- What the periodic calculation includes
- Counting manufacturing inventory
- Periodic calculations for Homefield
- Establish which goods the company owns
- Goods in transit
- Goods held on consignment
- Return rights and repurchase arrangements
- Reconcile the year-end count and correct cutoff
- Second Helping at December 31, 2026
- Counted goods to owned goods
- Recorded goods to corrected goods
- The same cutoff facts under periodic accounting
Review and resources
Inventory connects the goods a company buys or makes with the profit it reports when it sells them. Costs assigned to unsold goods remain in inventory on the balance sheet. Costs assigned to goods sold become cost of goods sold on the income statement. We have used those account relationships in earlier chapters; now we examine how those amounts are established.
A warehouse count is only part of that work. Some goods on the shelves may belong to a supplier, while goods the company owns may still be in transit. The purchase invoice may also omit costs needed to bring goods to their present condition and location. Before reporting inventory, we must identify the goods the company owns, establish their cost, and reconcile the records with the goods actually held.
Those decisions affect both the asset retained and the expense reported. We will follow them through Second Helping, a fictional retailer selling cookware, dishes, and small appliances. All example amounts are in US dollars. For manufacturing, we use Homefield Advantage Athletics to examine how production changes inventory accounting.
Inventory in the operating cycle
Recall the inventory relationship from the cash-flow work: purchases add goods, sales remove their cost, and supplier payments settle the payable. Purchases, cost of goods sold, and cash paid can therefore differ. Here, we examine the costs and owned quantities behind those account balances.
Review inventory versus equipment in Chapter 9 and the inventory and supplier-payable accounts in Chapter 12.
Inventory held for resale
Second Helping buys cookware, dishes, and small appliances ready for resale. These goods are merchandise inventory. They ordinarily remain in that account until sale, when Second Helping transfers their cost to cost of goods sold.
Inventory in manufacturing
A perpetual inventory system updates inventory accounts as transactions occur. The manufacturing entries below use this system. Later, we compare these entries with periodic accounting, which determines ending inventory and cost of goods sold at period-end.
Unlike a retailer such as Second Helping, which purchases finished products for resale, a manufacturer purchases materials and transforms them into finished products. As production progresses, the manufacturer adds labor and other manufacturing costs to the materials used. At any given time, some materials may be awaiting production, some products may be partly completed, and others may be finished but not yet sold. Manufacturers use separate inventory accounts to track the costs associated with each stage.
Raw materials inventory holds materials acquired for production but not yet used. Direct materials can be traced economically to a product or batch. Indirect materials support production, but tracing their consumption to individual products or batches is impractical. Raw materials inventory can hold both types.
When direct materials are used, their cost moves to work in process inventory, which holds the cost of unfinished production. Manufacturers collect the cost of indirect materials used in Manufacturing Overhead, alongside other indirect factory costs. They allocate that pool to production using a reasonable basis, such as machine-hours. The allocated amount enters Work in Process.
Consider Homefield Advantage Athletics (Homefield), a sports equipment manufacturer that makes baseball gloves. Homefield can trace leather, padding, and thread to the gloves produced, so it treats them as direct materials. Equipment-cleaning supplies used across production batches are indirect materials. When used, their cost joins factory supervision and equipment depreciation in the overhead pool for allocation.
Work in Process also receives direct labor, the cost of production work that can be traced to a product or batch. Together, direct materials, direct labor, and allocated manufacturing overhead make up the production cost assigned to unfinished goods.
When production is complete, Homefield transfers the accumulated cost to finished goods inventory. Transfers between inventory accounts change the classification of an asset without creating an expense. In the normal production and sale sequence, Homefield transfers the cost to cost of goods sold when it sells the finished gloves.
Raw Materials
Unused direct and indirect materials
Direct materials used
Trace the cost to the product or batch.
Manufacturing Overhead
Indirect materials used join other indirect factory costs in this pool.
Allocate a share of the pool to production.
Work in Process
Direct materials, direct labor, and allocated overhead assigned to unfinished production
Production is completed.
Finished Goods
Completed goods awaiting sale
Goods are sold.
Cost of Goods Sold
The cost of the sold goods becomes expense.
A glove awaiting final stitching remains in work in process, even if workers expect to finish it tomorrow. Once complete, it moves to finished goods. The diagram follows normal production and sale; losses or write-downs can cause expense recognition before a sale. We examine physical-count losses later in this chapter and inventory write-downs later in the unit.
Homefield uses equipment-cleaning supplies that serve several production batches. Which account receives their cost when used, and how does that cost reach Work in Process?
Compare your answer.
Debit Manufacturing Overhead and credit Raw Materials for the supplies used. Homefield collects that cost with other indirect factory costs, then allocates overhead to production by debiting Work in Process and crediting Manufacturing Overhead. The supplies enter Work in Process through the allocation rather than as a direct materials charge.
Establish the acquisition cost
Inventory cost includes the costs of acquiring goods and bringing them to their existing condition and location (Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 330-10-30-1). For a retailer, these include the purchase price and inbound freight. For a manufacturer, they include direct materials, direct labor, and allocated manufacturing overhead, such as factory supervision. The company holds these costs in inventory until it sells the goods, then recognizes cost of goods sold.
Selling and general corporate administrative costs are period expenses. The company charges these costs directly to expense in the period incurred. Examples include sales commissions and salaries for corporate accounting staff.
For purchased goods, we adjust the invoice price for discounts, returns, and allowances, then add qualifying costs such as inbound freight.
Review cost classification and gross profit in Chapter 6. A cost retained in inventory enters cost of goods sold when the related goods are sold.
Chapter 14 approaches discounts, returns, and allowances from the seller's side. For Second Helping as buyer, the trade discount establishes the invoice price. Purchase returns remove goods and their cost; purchase allowances reduce the cost of goods kept. For purchases on credit, both returns and allowances reduce accounts payable if the invoice remains unpaid.
Review trade and settlement discounts and returns and allowances in Chapter 14. Here, calculate the buyer's inventory cost from the completed purchase.
Second Helping keeps a shipment but receives a supplier allowance for damaged packaging. Does that allowance change the number of goods in inventory, their cost, or both?
Compare your answer.
The allowance reduces acquisition cost without reducing the quantity retained. A return would remove goods as well as cost. Keep dollars and physical units separate when reconciling the purchase to the inventory received.
Second Helping’s purchase
In November 2026, Second Helping purchases 180 casserole dishes. The supplier's list price is $40 per dish, with a 25% trade discount. Second Helping returns 12 damaged dishes before payment. The supplier also allows $90 for torn packaging on the dishes Second Helping keeps. The retained dishes are undamaged and have the same inventory cost.
The supplier grants a 2% discount on the remaining invoice balance if Second Helping pays within the discount period. Second Helping qualifies and pays that amount. Normal inbound freight costs $525, paid separately without a discount. The supplier pays return freight; Second Helping incurs no additional return cost. All these events occur before any retained dishes are sold.
| Acquisition cost | Amount |
|---|---|
| List amount (180 dishes × $40 per dish) | $7,200 |
| Less: trade discount ($7,200 × 25%) | ($1,800) |
| Invoice price Invoice cost per dish: $5,400 ÷ 180 dishes = $30 per dish | $5,400 |
| Less: return (12 dishes × $30 per dish) | ($360) |
| Less: allowance | ($90) |
| Balance eligible for payment discount | $4,950 |
| Less: payment discount ($4,950 × 2%) | ($99) |
| Cash paid to supplier | $4,851 |
| Add: inbound freight | $525 |
| Inventory cost of retained dishes | $5,376 |
| Dishes retained (180 dishes − 12 dishes) | 168 dishes |
| Final cost per dish ($5,376 ÷ 168 dishes) | $32 per dish |
The return removes both dishes and their cost. The allowance and payment discount reduce cost without changing the quantity retained. Freight increases the cost of those same dishes without adding more goods.
Homefield’s production cost
A manufacturer includes direct materials used, direct labor, and allocated manufacturing overhead in production cost. Indirect materials enter through the overhead allocation. Adding their cost again as direct materials would count the same cost twice.
Under ASC 330-10-30-3 through 30-8, we allocate qualifying overhead to production and expense selling costs separately.
Abnormal freight, handling, and wasted materials are current-period expenses. General administrative costs ordinarily become expenses unless they clearly relate to production. These exclusions apply even when the related goods remain unsold at the reporting date.
In November 2026, Homefield continues making identical baseball gloves. Some materials and unfinished gloves are on hand at the start and end of the month. The following balances come from inventory counts and production records. For this numerical example, Raw Materials contains only direct materials. The supplied overhead amount covers the indirect factory costs assigned to production. We do not calculate the individual costs in that pool. There are no shortages, returns, or abnormal waste, and production occurs at normal capacity.
| Inventory | November 1 | November 30 |
|---|---|---|
| Raw Materials | $1,440 | $1,080 |
| Work in Process | $1,530 | $1,380 |
| Finished Goods | 35 gloves | 128 gloves |
During November, Homefield completes 250 gloves and sells 157 gloves. Both beginning finished gloves and gloves completed in November cost $51 per glove. The unfinished gloves’ costs are supplied from production records; we do not calculate their stage of completion here.
| November activity | Amount | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Materials purchased | $6,240 | Add to Raw Materials |
| Direct labor incurred | $3,840 | Add to Work in Process |
| Factory overhead allocated to production | $2,160 | Add to Work in Process |
| Advertising | $690 | Selling expense |
Materials purchased are not necessarily materials used. The cost of materials used moves to Work in Process; unused materials remain in Raw Materials.
Homefield adds three types of cost to Work in Process during November:
| Production cost added | Amount |
|---|---|
| Direct materials used | $6,600 |
| Direct labor | $3,840 |
| Allocated manufacturing overhead | $2,160 |
| Total added to Work in Process | $12,600 |
This total includes only costs incurred during November. To determine the cost of completed gloves, we also account for beginning and ending Work in Process. Homefield expenses the $690 advertising cost separately.
Recording Homefield’s manufacturing costs
Under a perpetual system, Homefield updates each inventory account as materials are purchased and used, production is completed, and gloves are sold. Assume materials purchases are on credit and direct labor is earned but not yet paid.
Homefield collects factory costs in Manufacturing Overhead, then credits that account when assigning overhead to Work in Process. The $2,160 allocation is supplied; the table shows its assignment, not the entries for individual factory costs such as utilities and depreciation.
Cost of goods manufactured is the cost transferred from Work in Process to Finished Goods when production is complete.
Completed gloves enter Finished Goods at their production cost. When gloves sell, their cost moves from Finished Goods to Cost of Goods Sold.
The journal entries show both accounts affected by each event:
| Production event | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase materials on credit. | Raw Materials $6,240 | Accounts Payable $6,240 |
| Use direct materials. | Work in Process $6,600 | Raw Materials $6,600 |
| Record direct labor earned. | Work in Process $3,840 | Wages Payable $3,840 |
| Assign factory overhead to production. | Work in Process $2,160 | Manufacturing Overhead $2,160 |
| Transfer completed gloves. | Finished Goods $12,750 | Work in Process $12,750 |
| Record the cost of gloves sold. | Cost of Goods Sold $8,007 | Finished Goods $8,007 |
The sale also requires a revenue entry at the selling price. The last row shows only the inventory-cost entry. Paying wages later settles Wages Payable; it does not add production cost again.
Record the same transactions under each system
Once we establish inventory cost, we need to record how that cost changes as goods are purchased and sold. Companies use different systems to maintain those records. The main distinction is whether they update the Inventory account throughout the period or determine its ending balance at period-end.
A perpetual inventory system updates inventory as purchases, sales, and other inventory movements occur. A periodic inventory system records purchases in a Purchases account rather than updating Inventory with each purchase. Related accounts track freight, returns, allowances, and purchase discounts during the period. At period-end, we establish ending inventory and derive the period's cost of goods sold. The periodic Inventory account ordinarily retains its beginning balance until that adjustment.
Both systems record sales revenue when the sale occurs. They differ in when they record the cost side of the sale. A periodic system can include quantity logs even though its general ledger does not update inventory cost after each sale. Software use alone therefore does not identify the accounting system.
Purchase entries
Under perpetual records, Second Helping records the purchase invoice and all cost adjustments directly in Inventory. The entries below use the acquisition facts just developed. Accounts Payable records what Second Helping owes the supplier, while the separate freight payment reduces Cash.
Under periodic records, Second Helping uses temporary purchase accounts for the same events. Purchases accumulates invoice costs; Freight-In accumulates inbound freight. Purchase Returns and Allowances and Purchase Discounts reduce the net purchase cost. We close those accounts when calculating cost of goods sold.
| Event | Periodic debit | Periodic credit |
|---|---|---|
| Record invoice. | Purchases $5,400 | Accounts Payable $5,400 |
| Return damaged dishes. | Accounts Payable $360 | Purchase Returns and Allowances $360 |
| Record price allowance. | Accounts Payable $90 | Purchase Returns and Allowances $90 |
| Pay inbound freight. | Freight-In $525 | Cash $525 |
| Pay supplier within discount period. | Accounts Payable $4,950 | Cash $4,851; Purchase Discounts $99 |
The supplier and freight payments are identical under both systems. The net purchase cost is also identical: $5,400 − $450 − $99 + $525 = $5,376. Different account names do not create different goods or change what Second Helping paid to acquire them.
Sale entries and the inventory reconciliation
Second Helping begins November with 75 dishes costing $32 each, or $2,400. It adds the 168 retained dishes at their final cost of $32 each. During November it sells 137 dishes on credit for $58 each. These are completed sales with no customer returns or remaining return rights. No other dish transactions occur before the count described below.
Under perpetual records, Second Helping also records the cost of the dishes sold. It uses inventory cost, not the selling price, for this entry.
Under periodic records, Second Helping makes the revenue entry at sale but waits until period-end to record cost of goods sold. Before considering a count difference, the goods reconcile as follows.
| Inventory movement | Dishes | Cost at $32 per dish |
|---|---|---|
| Beginning inventory: dishes on hand before November purchases | 75 | $2,400 |
| Net purchases: dishes retained after the purchase return | 168 | $5,376 |
| Available for sale: beginning inventory + net purchases | 243 | $7,776 |
| Less dishes sold, measured at inventory cost | (137) | ($4,384) |
| Expected ending inventory: available less sold | 106 | $3,392 |
Before the physical count, what dish balance does each Inventory account contain? Does the periodic balance establish how many dishes Second Helping still owns?
Compare your answer.
The perpetual account contains $3,392, representing 106 dishes at $32 each. The periodic account still contains the $2,400 beginning balance. That beginning balance does not establish ending inventory. We need the count, ownership information, and the period's purchase records to complete periodic inventory accounting.
Every dish has the same final unit cost in this example. We can therefore multiply the quantity sold or remaining by that unit cost without choosing among different purchase costs. The next chapter explains how to assign costs when purchase costs differ.
When a customer returns goods, the seller accounts for any return recovery asset already recorded. Under perpetual records, the seller restores the returned goods to Inventory and removes the related recovery asset. Cost of Goods Sold is not reduced again for an expected return already reflected in that asset.
Under periodic records, returned goods still on hand are included in ending inventory. The seller must also remove any related recovery asset so the same goods are not counted twice.
Review the refund liability and return recovery asset in Chapter 14 for their measurement and entries.
Compare the records with a physical count
A physical count checks whether the goods on hand match the inventory records. Even with a perpetual system, goods may be missing or damaged, and transactions may have been recorded incorrectly. When the count differs from the records, employees must investigate the cause before adjusting Inventory.
Inventory shrinkage is a shortage between the quantity that should be on hand and the quantity actually on hand. Theft, breakage, and unrecorded removals can cause shortages, but the count alone does not identify a cause. Receiving or shipping entries recorded in the wrong period can also create apparent shortages. Correct those timing errors before treating a remaining difference as shrinkage.
Second Helping's November count finds 102 dishes. Employees confirm that the count is complete, ownership is clear, and all purchases, returns, and sales were recorded correctly. The expected quantity was 106, so the remaining shortage is 4 dishes. At $32 per dish, the adjustment is $128.
Second Helping uses a separate Inventory Shrinkage Expense account here so we can follow the shortage. Companies may include ordinary shrinkage in cost of goods sold for reporting. The separate entry does not turn missing goods into a sale or create revenue.
| Cost reconciliation after the count | Amount |
|---|---|
| Goods available for sale | $7,776 |
| Cost assigned to recorded sales | $4,384 |
| Shortage expense | $128 |
| Ending inventory: 102 dishes × $32 per dish | $3,264 |
The cost of recorded sales, the shortage, and ending inventory add to the available cost. Reducing inventory at the selling price would remove more than the cost assigned to the missing goods.
What the periodic calculation includes
Under periodic accounting, cost of goods sold equals beginning inventory plus net purchase cost less ending inventory.
| Periodic cost of goods sold | Amount |
|---|---|
| Beginning inventory: 75 dishes × $32 per dish | $2,400 |
| Add net purchases: 168 retained dishes × $32 per dish | $5,376 |
| Cost of goods available for sale | $7,776 |
| Less ending inventory: 102 dishes counted × $32 per dish | ($3,264) |
| Cost of goods sold | $4,512 |
Periodic accounting assigns the cost of all goods absent from ending inventory to cost of goods sold. Here, that includes both the 137 dishes sold ($4,384) and the 4 missing dishes ($128). The calculation alone does not distinguish sales from shortages. Here, the separate sales-quantity information lets us compare expected and actual units.
The system determines which adjustment is needed. Under perpetual records, Inventory already reflects purchases and recorded sales. We credit Inventory to remove the missing goods still included in that balance.
Under periodic records, Inventory still holds its beginning balance until closing. The closing entry establishes ending inventory from the count and includes the shortage in Cost of Goods Sold. Adding the perpetual shortage entry afterward would reduce inventory and increase expense again. To report the shortage separately, reclassify its cost from Cost of Goods Sold to Inventory Shrinkage Expense instead.
The following combined closing entry removes beginning inventory, closes the purchase accounts, and records ending inventory and the derived expense. The Inventory debit records the final count; the Inventory credit removes the beginning balance. Inventory therefore ends with the same cost under either recordkeeping system.
Does the higher periodic Cost of Goods Sold balance mean Second Helping sold more dishes under that system?
Compare your answer.
No. The same 137 dishes were sold under both alternatives. The periodic expense includes the shortage. Under the perpetual presentation, $4,384 of cost of goods sold plus $128 of shrinkage expense equals the periodic $4,512 total. Comparing only the account labeled Cost of Goods Sold would overlook that presentation difference.
Counting manufacturing inventory
A manufacturer counts materials awaiting use, products still being made, and completed products separately. Production records connect those quantities to the costs in Raw Materials, Work in Process, and Finished Goods.
| Inventory account | What the count identifies | Cost to compare with the records |
|---|---|---|
| Raw Materials | Materials not yet used in production | Acquisition cost of the materials on hand |
| Work in Process | Products started but not completed | Materials, direct labor, and allocated overhead accumulated so far |
| Finished Goods | Completed products not yet sold | Full production cost of the completed products on hand |
An unfinished glove does not yet carry the cost of all the work needed to complete it. Its cost depends on the materials used and work performed so far. Counting unfinished gloves therefore does not establish their cost; production records must also identify the costs accumulated on those gloves.
Homefield’s November count and production records support these ending balances:
| Inventory account | Ending cost |
|---|---|
| Raw Materials: unused materials | $1,080 |
| Work in Process: costs accumulated on unfinished gloves | $1,380 |
| Finished Goods: 128 gloves × $51 per glove | $6,528 |
| Total manufacturing inventory | $8,988 |
The materials and unfinished gloves remain assets along with the completed gloves. Investigate count differences within the relevant inventory account before recording a correction or shortage.
Periodic calculations for Homefield
A manufacturer using periodic records determines ending inventory costs at period-end and calculates the costs used, completed, and sold in sequence. Unlike a retailer’s purchases of finished merchandise, materials purchases must first pass through production. Each calculation below supplies a cost needed in the next calculation.
Beginning Raw Materials plus net materials purchases, less ending Raw Materials, equals total materials used. If the account includes both direct and indirect materials, we also need the cost of materials issued to specific products or batches, or the cost issued for general factory use. Knowing either amount lets us calculate the other by subtraction.
Homefield's numerical example contains only direct materials, so total materials used equals direct materials used. There are no purchase returns, discounts, or separate freight in this example.
| Direct materials used | Amount |
|---|---|
| Beginning Raw Materials | $1,440 |
| Add November materials purchases | $6,240 |
| Less ending Raw Materials: unused materials | ($1,080) |
| Direct materials used | $6,600 |
Cost of goods manufactured equals beginning Work in Process plus direct materials used, direct labor, and allocated overhead, less ending Work in Process. Subtracting ending Work in Process leaves only the cost of completed gloves.
| Cost of goods manufactured | Amount |
|---|---|
| Beginning Work in Process | $1,530 |
| Add direct materials used | $6,600 |
| Add direct labor | $3,840 |
| Add allocated factory overhead | $2,160 |
| Less ending Work in Process: unfinished gloves | ($1,380) |
| Cost of goods manufactured | $12,750 |
Cost of goods sold equals beginning Finished Goods plus cost of goods manufactured, less ending Finished Goods.
| Cost of goods sold | Amount |
|---|---|
| Beginning Finished Goods: 35 gloves × $51 per glove | $1,785 |
| Add cost of goods manufactured | $12,750 |
| Less ending Finished Goods: 128 gloves × $51 per glove | ($6,528) |
| Cost of goods sold | $8,007 |
The periodic result equals the perpetual cost-of-sale entry: 157 gloves sold × $51 per glove = $8,007. Both systems also report the same ending balances in Raw Materials, Work in Process, and Finished Goods. The difference is when the inventory accounts are updated, not which production costs belong in inventory.
Establish which goods the company owns
A physical count shows where goods are, not who owns them. Include goods the company owns, even when they are held elsewhere. Exclude goods held for someone else. Use the control-transfer analysis from Chapter 8 to determine when ownership changes.
Review the point-in-time control indicators in Chapter 8 if you need the underlying revenue analysis.
Goods in transit
A carrier is a company that transports goods, such as a trucking company or shipping service. Goods in transit are goods between shipment and delivery. FOB stands for free on board.
These examples assume no other contract terms change when control transfers.
Read the shipping terms together with the shipment and delivery dates. A supplier invoice can arrive before or after control transfers. Who initially pays the carrier also does not, by itself, establish the transfer date.
A supplier ships Second Helping's order before year-end under FOB shipping-point terms. The carrier delivers it after year-end, and the invoice remains unpaid. Who includes the goods at year-end?
Compare your answer.
Second Helping includes the goods because control transferred at shipment under the stated contract. It also records the payable. Neither the later arrival nor the unpaid invoice changes that ownership conclusion.
Goods held on consignment
In a consignment, an owner places goods with another party that will try to sell them. The owner is the consignor; the selling party is the consignee. Delivery to the consignee does not itself establish a sale to that party.
Suppose Second Helping places dishes with a local shop on consignment. Second Helping can require their return or direct the shop to send them elsewhere. The shop has no unconditional obligation to pay for unsold dishes. Under those facts, Second Helping retains control and includes the unsold dishes in inventory. The shop excludes them from its own inventory even though they occupy its shelves.
ASC 606-10-55-79 through 55-80 address consignment arrangements and indicators of retained control. The same reasoning applies in reverse when a supplier places its goods in Second Helping's store. Employees must identify those goods during the count so we can exclude them from owned inventory.
Second Helping holds a supplier's pans on consignment and sends its own dishes to another shop on consignment. Which unsold goods belong in Second Helping's inventory?
Compare your answer.
Second Helping includes its dishes at the other shop and excludes the supplier's pans at its own store. The controlling fact is who retains control under each arrangement. The goods can remain owned inventory while another store holds them.
Return rights and repurchase arrangements
Recall that a customer can obtain control while retaining a return right. Under ASC 606-10-55-22 through 55-27, the seller accounts separately for expected returns. Goods transferred to customers are no longer inventory. The right to recover goods from expected returns is reported as a separate asset. The recovery asset concerns goods expected back, which are absent from the warehouse count.
A seller may deliver goods under a contract that requires or allows the seller to buy them back. The customer does not obtain control under such an arrangement, even after taking possession (ASC 606-10-55-68). Delivery alone therefore does not justify recording a sale or removing the goods from the seller’s inventory.
Can Second Helping include every dish delivered to customers in inventory merely because customers may return their purchases?
Compare your answer.
No. If control has transferred, Second Helping accounts for the sale and the expected returns separately. An ordinary customer return right differs from Second Helping retaining an obligation or right to repurchase the goods. The contract terms establish which analysis applies.
Reconcile the year-end count and correct cutoff
Cutoff means assigning transactions to the correct reporting period. A purchase or sale recorded in the wrong period can misstate both inventory and the related payable, receivable, revenue, or expense. Correcting cutoff therefore requires correcting the transaction, not just adjusting inventory to match the count.
For each shipment near year-end, compare the contract terms with the dated shipping and receiving records. Establish who controlled the goods at year-end, then compare that conclusion with the entries already recorded. Finally, reconcile the adjusted records with the goods actually owned. Investigate any remaining quantity difference.
Second Helping at December 31, 2026
Consider Second Helping’s inventory at December 31. All casserole dishes in this example cost $32 each. Second Helping uses perpetual records. Its unadjusted Inventory balance is $10,400, representing 325 dishes. Employees count 300 dishes on the premises.
Second Helping holds some dishes on consignment from a supplier and places some of its own dishes on consignment with another shop. The supplier can require Second Helping to return the supplier’s unsold dishes; Second Helping can require the other shop to return its unsold dishes. Neither Second Helping nor the other shop must pay for the dishes each holds on consignment unless those dishes sell.
The table below lists the contract and shipping facts. All transit contracts transfer control at the stated FOB point, with no other terms changing that point.
| Goods at December 31 | Quantity and supplied facts | Recorded at December 31, before adjustments |
|---|---|---|
| Supplier's consignment on the premises | 23 dishes are included in the physical count. | Correctly excluded from Second Helping's ledger. |
| Second Helping's consignment at another shop | 41 dishes remain unsold. | Correctly included in Second Helping's ledger. |
| Incoming shipment, FOB shipping point | 27 dishes shipped December 29; received January 3. | Purchase and payable omitted. |
| Outgoing shipment, FOB destination | 16 dishes shipped December 30; delivered January 4. | Sale and cost of goods sold recorded early. |
| Incoming shipment, FOB destination | 19 dishes shipped December 28; received January 2. | Correctly excluded; no payable recorded. |
| Outgoing shipment, FOB shipping point | 11 dishes shipped December 31; delivered January 3. | Sale and cost of goods sold correctly recorded. |
The 16 dishes shipped December 30 under FOB destination terms were sold on credit at $58 per dish. Second Helping recorded the sale before the dishes reached the customer on January 4. The company has neither collected payment nor obtained an unconditional right to payment before delivery.
The 27 dishes shipped by the supplier on December 29 under FOB shipping-point terms were purchased on credit at $32 per dish, with no additional freight. Second Helping had not recorded the purchase or payable by December 31. All other entries are correct. Employees confirm the count after recounting; no other owned goods are elsewhere.
Counted goods to owned goods
To determine how many dishes Second Helping owns at year-end, adjust the physical count for goods owned by others and goods held elsewhere. Subtract the supplier-owned dishes included in the count, then add Second Helping’s dishes held at the other shop and in transit.
| Owned-inventory calculation | Dishes |
|---|---|
| Counted on the premises | 300 |
| Less supplier's consignment | (23) |
| Owned goods on the premises | 277 |
| Add own consignment at another shop | 41 |
| Add incoming shipping-point purchase | 27 |
| Add outgoing destination shipment | 16 |
| Total owned at year-end | 361 |
Required ending inventory is 361 dishes × $32 per dish = $11,552. The incoming destination shipment still belongs to the supplier. The outgoing shipping-point shipment already belongs to the customer. Neither enters Second Helping's owned total.
Recorded goods to corrected goods
The year-end adjusting entries below address cutoff errors and inventory shrinkage. First, correct purchases and sales recorded in the wrong period. Then record any remaining inventory shortage.
| Inventory-account reconciliation | Amount |
|---|---|
| Unadjusted Inventory | $10,400 |
| Add omitted incoming purchase | $864 |
| Restore prematurely removed outgoing goods | $512 |
| Balance after cutoff corrections | $11,776 |
| Less verified shortage | ($224) |
| Adjusted Inventory | $11,552 |
After these entries, Inventory reports the $11,552 cost of the dishes Second Helping owns at year-end. Correcting the cutoff errors first reveals a $224 shortage that would be hidden if we simply increased Inventory to match the count.
The same cutoff facts under periodic accounting
Now suppose Second Helping uses periodic accounting for the same December shipments. The ownership facts and physical count stay the same. The incoming shipping-point purchase is still omitted, but the premature destination sale has only a revenue entry. No inventory-cost entry was recorded at shipment.
The incoming shipping-point goods belonged to Second Helping before year-end. The company must record the omitted purchase and payable:
Second Helping also includes those goods in ending inventory. Recording the purchase recognizes the acquisition and supplier obligation. Including the goods in ending inventory keeps their cost out of cost of goods sold because they remain unsold. Doing only one leaves the periodic closing calculation incomplete.
The outgoing destination goods still belonged to Second Helping at year-end. Reverse the premature revenue entry:
Include those goods in ending inventory as well. There is no inventory-cost entry to reverse under the stated periodic records. The other shipments were recorded in the correct period and require no transaction correction.
The ownership-adjusted count still establishes ending inventory of $11,552. Use that ending inventory and the corrected net purchases in the periodic closing calculation. Do not carry over the perpetual Inventory-account reconciliation: the periodic account retains its beginning balance until closing. As in the November comparison, the periodic calculation includes any shortage in cost of goods sold unless its cost is separately identified and reclassified.