Draft · Unit 2 · Objectives 2.3a–2.3f

Apply the revenue model

The five-step revenue model determines how much revenue a company recognizes and when it recognizes it.

About 35 minutes to read

Work in progress

These materials change during the semester. Report an error or an unclear passage.

Course objectives

  • 2.3a Determine whether an arrangement should be accounted for as a contract with a customer under ASC 606.
  • 2.3b Determine the performance obligations in a customer contract.
  • 2.3c Determine the transaction price for a customer contract.
  • 2.3d Allocate the transaction price to performance obligations.
  • 2.3e Determine when and how much revenue to recognize for each performance obligation.
  • 2.3f Classify and account for the balances arising from a customer contract.

Listen to this chapter

Work in progress

These materials change during the semester. Report an error or an unclear passage.

1 hr 6 min Listen on YouTube Download the MP3 (60.9 MB) 35 chapters Download the transcript

Transcript Includes practice answers
  1. 0:00 You are listening to Reading 2-3 of the A C C 300 course reading: Apply the revenue model. The chapter takes the five steps of Topic 606 in order.
  2. 0:12 Identify the contract, identify the performance obligations, determine the transaction price, allocate that price, and recognize revenue when control transfers.
  3. 0:25 Then it shows how the order of performance, billing, and collection produces a receivable, a contract asset, or a contract liability.
  4. 0:36 Sable Ridge Instruments applies all five steps to one Fairmont Health contract, and the chapter ends with a Northline Components contract for you to work on your own.
  5. 0:49 The written chapter shows the contract exhibit, the diagrams, the tables, and three interactive Atlas checks, and it hides each Northline answer until you ask for it.
  6. 1:03 A signed contract may state one price for several goods and services.
  7. 1:09 Suppose a company signs the contract in November, receives an advance in December, performs consulting work from January through March, and sends its final invoice in April.
  8. 1:23 The signature, cash receipt, work, and invoice occur on different dates. Revenue must follow the transfer of the promised service, not whichever date is easiest to observe.
  9. 1:37 The company therefore must determine what it promised, how much consideration it expects, and when the customer obtains control of each promised good or service. Topic 606 organizes that work into five steps.
  10. 1:54 The five-step revenue model. Each step uses work completed during earlier steps. Step 1, identify the contract. Which enforceable arrangement does the company account for?
  11. 2:08 The result is the contract, or the combined contracts, to analyze. Step 2, identify the performance obligations. Which promises transfer distinct goods or services? The result is the units for allocation and recognition.
  12. 2:27 Step 3, determine the transaction price. How much consideration does the company expect to be entitled to? The result is the amount available to allocate. Step 4, allocate the transaction price.
  13. 2:43 How much of the transaction price belongs to each obligation? The result is an allocated amount for each obligation. Step 5, recognize revenue. When does the customer obtain control of each promised good or service?
  14. 3:01 The result is revenue recognized at a point in time or over time.
  15. 3:06 The five steps determine revenue. Billing and collection then determine whether the balance sheet reports a receivable, contract asset, contract liability, or some combination of those accounts. One model, many settings.
  16. 3:26 These principles appear in many settings, including consulting projects, software implementations, subscriptions, engineering engagements, and many construction contracts.
  17. 3:42 An industry label can signal that specialized guidance applies. When A S C Topic 606 governs the arrangement, the contract's promises and the way control transfers drive the revenue conclusions.
  18. 4:00 Some arrangements are governed partly or entirely by other accounting guidance. Those specialized rules are outside this course.
  19. 4:12 Here, the goal is to understand the core revenue decisions and apply them to a new customer contract. Students should also recognize when more guidance may be needed.
  20. 4:27 Step 1: Identify the contract to account for.
  21. 4:30 A company applies the revenue model to a contract with a customer only when all five of these conditions are satisfied: The parties approved the arrangement and are committed to perform.
  22. 4:44 The company can identify each party's rights to the goods or services. The company can identify the payment terms.
  23. 4:52 The arrangement has commercial substance, which means it is expected to change the risk, timing, or amount of the company's future cash flows.
  24. 5:03 Collection of substantially all the consideration to which the company expects to be entitled for the goods or services that will transfer is probable.
  25. 5:14 This assessment considers the customer's ability and intention to pay when payment is due. These conditions establish whether the company has a contract to which it can apply Topic 606.
  26. 5:27 A signed document alone does not establish that conclusion. In United States generally accepted accounting principles, probable means that an event is likely to occur.
  27. 5:39 A S C Topic 606 does not assign that term a fixed numerical percentage, so the conclusion depends on the available evidence rather than a mechanical cutoff.
  28. 5:51 The amount the company expects to be entitled to may be less than the stated price when the company expects to grant a price concession. That commercial judgment is different from credit risk.
  29. 6:05 A customer who cannot or does not intend to pay an amount the company still expects to be entitled to may fail the collectibility criterion; the company cannot treat that failure as a price concession merely to qualify
  30. 6:21 the arrangement for Topic 606.
  31. 6:23 Check your understanding. A customer signs an order, but the order does not identify the goods the company must deliver. Can the company apply the five-step revenue model to that order yet? Pause to consider your answer.
  32. 6:40 Here is the explanation. No. The company cannot identify the parties' rights to the goods or services. One of the five contract conditions is not satisfied. Check your understanding.
  33. 6:55 A company expects to accept 96,000 dollars as full payment on a stated 100,000 dollars price because it routinely grants this customer a 4,000 dollars commercial concession.
  34. 7:08 The customer has the ability and intention to pay 96,000 dollars when due. Does the 4,000 dollars difference automatically cause the collectibility criterion to fail? Pause to consider your answer.
  35. 7:24 Here is the explanation. No. The company evaluates probable collection of substantially all the 96,000 dollars it expects to be entitled to after the expected price concession.
  36. 7:37 The answer would differ if the company still expected to be entitled to 100,000 dollars but doubted the customer's ability or intention to pay it.
  37. 7:49 Cash received before Step 1 is satisfied. If the criteria are not met, the company stops before Step 2 and continues to reassess the arrangement. Cash received is generally a liability rather than revenue.
  38. 8:05 For an equipment arrangement that has not qualified as a Topic 606 contract, Customer Deposit Liability describes why the company still owes the customer performance or repayment.
  39. 8:19 The entry when Step 1 is not satisfied, recorded when cash is received.
  40. 8:26 Debit Cash, 5,000 dollars, an asset. Credit Customer Deposit Liability, 5,000 dollars, a liability.
  41. 8:37 The company keeps the liability until the arrangement later meets the Step 1 criteria or a limited revenue condition in A S C Topic 606, Subtopic 10, Section 25, paragraph 7 occurs.
  42. 8:51 Those conditions include contract termination with nonrefundable consideration.
  43. 8:57 They also include circumstances in which the company has no remaining obligations and has received all, or substantially all, nonrefundable consideration.
  44. 9:08 If the arrangement later qualifies, the company begins applying A S C Topic 606. Any advance for goods or services the company still owes becomes a Contract Liability.
  45. 9:21 That situation differs from a payment made in advance under a valid service contract. When the contract criteria are met but the service remains unperformed, the credit is a Contract Liability.
  46. 9:36 A company's ledger may use a more specific title, such as Unearned Service Revenue or Deferred Subscription Revenue. The account remains a contract liability under A S C Topic 606.
  47. 9:49 The entry for an advance under a valid contract, recorded when cash is received.
  48. 9:56 Debit Cash, 12,000 dollars, an asset. Credit Contract Liability, 12,000 dollars, a liability.
  49. 10:08 Check your understanding. A customer in severe financial difficulty pays a nonrefundable 5,000 dollars deposit on a 40,000 dollars machine.
  50. 10:19 At inception, the seller concludes that collection of substantially all expected consideration is not probable. What does the seller report? Pause to consider your answer. Here is the explanation.
  51. 10:34 Debit Cash and credit Customer Deposit Liability for 5,000 dollars. The seller reports no revenue because the arrangement has not qualified as a Topic 606 contract.
  52. 10:46 Calling the deposit nonrefundable does not, by itself, show that the machine transferred or that the liability may be released. Credit deterioration after a valid contract exists raises a different accounting question.
  53. 11:03 An existing receivable is evaluated under the credit-loss guidance rather than reduced through revenue.
  54. 11:11 A significant change in the customer's ability to pay may also require the company to reassess the Step 1 criteria for the remaining contract.
  55. 11:22 Chapter 14, Receivables, explains the allowance for credit losses under Topic 326. For now, distinguish an inception collectibility failure from a later change in the credit quality of an existing receivable.
  56. 11:37 Decide whether separate agreements form one contract.
  57. 11:42 Agreements entered into at or near the same time with the same customer or its related parties are combined when at least one of these conditions applies: the agreements were negotiated as a package with one commercial
  58. 11:59 objective. the consideration in one agreement depends on the price or performance of the other. promises in the agreements form one performance obligation.
  59. 12:12 Combining contracts changes the set of promises and consideration analyzed in the remaining steps. The fact that two agreements involve the same customer is not sufficient by itself.
  60. 12:27 Step 2: Identify the performance obligations. Begin with an inventory of the goods and services promised to the customer.
  61. 12:36 Include promises stated in the contract and promises created by the company's customary practices or published policies. Exclude administrative and setup activities that do not transfer a good or service to the customer.
  62. 12:53 A performance obligation is a promise to transfer either: a distinct good or service, or a distinct bundle of goods or services.
  63. 13:03 a qualifying series of distinct goods or services that are substantially the same and have the same pattern of transfer to the customer.
  64. 13:14 Apply both parts of the distinct test. A promised good or service is distinct only when the answer to both questions is yes.
  65. 13:25 Is the promised good or service distinct? A decision tree with two questions. Question 1, capable of being distinct. Can the customer benefit from the good or service on its own or with a readily available resource?
  66. 13:42 If no, combine the promise with other promises and apply both questions to the resulting bundle. If yes, go to Question 2, distinct within the contract.
  67. 13:54 Is the promise separately identifiable from the other promises in the contract? If no, combine the promise with other promises and test the bundle. If yes, account for the promise as a separate performance obligation.
  68. 14:12 How to answer each question. The next two explanations follow the decision tree in order. Use each one to answer the matching numbered question before moving to the next question.
  69. 14:25 Question 1: Can the customer benefit from it? Answer yes when the customer can use, consume, sell, or otherwise benefit from the good or service either on its own or together with a resource that is readily available.
  70. 14:41 A resource is readily available when the customer already has it or can obtain it separately.
  71. 14:48 Answer no when the customer can benefit from the promised good or service only by receiving another promised good or service that is not yet readily available to the customer.
  72. 15:00 Question 2: Is the promise separately identifiable in the contract? Consider whether the company: provides a significant service that integrates the item with other promises into one combined output.
  73. 15:15 significantly modifies or customizes another promised item. provides items that are highly dependent on or highly interrelated with one another.
  74. 15:26 Answer no when these factors show that the promise is an input to a combined output rather than a separately identifiable promise.
  75. 15:35 Combine it with the specific promised goods or services in the contract to which it is not separately identifiable. Reapply both questions to that combined group.
  76. 15:47 The company continues only until it identifies a group that satisfies both parts of the distinct test; it does not add unrelated promises merely to create a bundle. Check your understanding.
  77. 16:01 A vendor delivers standard equipment and installs it. Other vendors can perform the installation, and the installation does not modify the equipment. Are delivery and installation necessarily one performance obligation?
  78. 16:18 Pause to consider your answer. Here is the explanation. No. The customer can benefit from each promise, and the facts do not indicate significant integration, modification, or interdependence.
  79. 16:32 The two promises are distinct on these facts. The Step 2 conclusion matters in later steps.
  80. 16:39 Each performance obligation identified in Step 2 is a unit of account: the company allocates part of the transaction price to it in Step 4 and determines when to recognize that amount as revenue in Step 5.
  81. 16:54 Microsoft's revenue note provides a real example of this judgment.
  82. 16:59 Microsoft accounts for some software licenses separately, but it combines certain desktop applications and cloud services when their integration, interdependence, and interrelationship make them one performance
  83. 17:14 obligation.
  84. 17:15 The business setting is different from Atlas, but the distinct-goods-and-services question is the same. Account for a qualifying series as one performance obligation.
  85. 17:27 The series rule requires a company to account for a series of distinct goods or services as one performance obligation when the goods or services are substantially the same and have the same pattern of transfer to the
  86. 17:41 customer. That pattern exists only when both of these conditions are met: Each distinct good or service in the series would qualify for over-time recognition if the company accounted for it separately.
  87. 17:55 The company would use the same method to measure progress toward complete satisfaction of each distinct good or service.
  88. 18:04 For example, each day of a qualifying daily monitoring service may be distinct, but the company accounts for the series of daily services as one performance obligation.
  89. 18:15 Separate product deliveries that transfer at points in time do not qualify merely because the products are similar or have the same price.
  90. 18:25 Step 3: Determine the transaction price. The transaction price is the consideration the company expects to be entitled to for transferring the promised goods or services.
  91. 18:37 Begin with fixed consideration, then evaluate amounts that can change. Estimate variable consideration. Refunds, rebates, price concessions, bonuses, penalties, and performance payments can make consideration variable.
  92. 18:53 Estimation has two parts. First, select the method that better predicts the amount of consideration to which the company will be entitled.
  93. 19:03 Then apply that method to estimate the amount: Expected value: probability-weight the possible amounts. This method often fits a range of outcomes or many similar contracts.
  94. 19:15 Most likely amount: use the single most likely outcome. This method often fits an uncertainty with two possible outcomes, such as receiving all or none of a bonus. Use the chosen method consistently for that uncertainty.
  95. 19:31 The resulting amount is the estimate of variable consideration; it is not automatically included in the transaction price.
  96. 19:40 The variable consideration constraint is the separate requirement that limits how much of that estimate the company may include in the transaction price.
  97. 19:52 Include an amount only to the extent that it is probable that recognizing it will not cause a significant reversal of cumulative revenue when the uncertainty is resolved.
  98. 20:04 Here too, probable means likely to occur, not a fixed percentage.
  99. 20:09 Relevant evidence includes how much of the outcome is outside the company's control, how long the uncertainty will remain, and whether experience with similar contracts predicts the outcome.
  100. 20:22 If the company has received or has a right to consideration that it expects to refund, it reports a refund liability for the amount it does not expect to retain.
  101. 20:34 The same expected refund is excluded from the transaction price. The company updates both estimates when the facts change.
  102. 20:44 Estimation and constraint answer different questions: Estimation: Which method better predicts the consideration, and what amount results when the company applies that method?
  103. 20:57 Constraint: How much of that estimated amount may the company include in the transaction price without creating a probable significant reversal of cumulative revenue later?
  104. 21:10 Identify a significant financing component. A contract has a significant financing component when the timing of payment provides a significant financing benefit to the customer or the company.
  105. 21:24 If the customer receives the good or service well before paying, the company may be financing the customer. If the customer pays well before receiving the good or service, the customer may be financing the company.
  106. 21:40 Why separate financing from revenue? Revenue should measure the price of the good or service when control transfers.
  107. 21:48 An additional amount charged solely because the customer pays later is interest, not revenue from the good or service. Likewise, a payment made in advance may include financing provided by the customer.
  108. 22:03 Separating the financing effect ensures that revenue reflects the amount attributable to the promised good or service, while the effect of paying early or late is recognized separately as interest over the financing
  109. 22:19 period. Use this process: Compare payment with transfer. Identify when the customer pays and when control of the promised good or service transfers. Identify who receives the financing benefit.
  110. 22:33 Later payment may finance the customer; early payment may finance the company. Decide whether the financing benefit is significant.
  111. 22:42 Consider the time between payment and transfer, the difference between the promised amount and the cash selling price, and relevant market interest rates. Separate the two components.
  112. 22:56 Measure revenue at the cash selling price when control transfers. Recognize the financing effect as interest over the financing period.
  113. 23:05 Suppose a company sells equipment to a customer and transfers control of the equipment today.
  114. 23:12 The cash selling price is 100,000 dollars, but the contract requires the customer to pay 121,000 dollars two years from now. The two-year delay provides financing to the customer.
  115. 23:26 The company recognizes 100,000 dollars of equipment revenue when it transfers control, not 121,000 dollars. It recognizes the remaining 21,000 dollars as interest income over the two years.
  116. 23:41 The contract has not produced extra equipment revenue merely because the customer pays later. A long interval does not automatically create a financing component.
  117. 23:54 For example, payment terms may protect one party from the other party's failure to perform, or the timing of payment may depend on a future event outside either party's control.
  118. 24:08 In those cases, the payment schedule may serve a purpose other than financing.
  119. 24:14 Topic 606 permits a practical expedient: a company need not adjust for a significant financing component when it expects, at contract inception, that one year or less will pass between transfer and payment.
  120. 24:30 In this course, a problem requiring an adjustment will provide the cash selling price or the information needed to calculate it.
  121. 24:40 Step 4: Allocate the transaction price. The first three steps supply the inputs for Step 4. Step 1 established that the company has a contract to which Topic 606 applies.
  122. 24:53 Step 2 identified the separate performance obligations in that contract. Step 3 determined one total transaction price for the contract.
  123. 25:03 Step 4 now answers the next question: How much of that total transaction price belongs to each performance obligation?
  124. 25:12 Why the company allocates the transaction price. Step 2 produced a list of performance obligations; in the figure there are five.
  125. 25:22 Step 3 produced one total transaction price for the contract as a whole, not yet assigned to any of them.
  126. 25:30 Step 4 divides that one total among the obligations, one allocated amount for each, and the allocated amounts add to the total transaction price. The five obligations in the figure are illustrative.
  127. 25:45 An actual contract may contain a different number, and their relative standalone selling prices determine the allocated shares.
  128. 25:55 The company allocates the transaction price in proportion to the performance obligations' standalone selling prices at contract inception.
  129. 26:05 A standalone selling price is the price at which the company would sell a promised good or service separately to a similar customer in similar circumstances.
  130. 26:17 If an observable standalone selling price is unavailable, the company estimates it using reasonably available information.
  131. 26:26 Possible approaches include an adjusted market assessment or expected cost plus an appropriate margin.
  132. 26:34 Unless estimating the standalone selling price is the question, this course will provide the amount needed for allocation. For each obligation:
  133. 26:44 The allocation percentage equals the obligation's standalone selling price divided by the total of the standalone selling prices.
  134. 26:56 The allocated transaction price equals the transaction price multiplied by the allocation percentage.
  135. 27:07 The final allocations must add to the transaction price. A contract or list price is not automatically a standalone selling price.
  136. 27:17 Relative standalone selling prices provide a consistent basis for associating consideration with the goods and services transferred to the customer.
  137. 27:28 Without that basis, invoice labels or management preference could move revenue among obligations, and therefore among reporting periods, even though the economics of the exchange had not changed.
  138. 27:43 Topic 606 contains exceptions for a discount or variable amount that relates to only part of a contract. Apply an exception only when the facts establish all of its conditions.
  139. 27:57 For variable consideration, the payment must relate specifically to an obligation or distinct item, and assigning the amount there must remain consistent with the allocation objective for the contract as a whole.
  140. 28:13 Step 5: Recognize revenue when control transfers. Step 4 assigned part of the transaction price to each performance obligation. Step 5 determines when each allocated amount becomes revenue.
  141. 28:27 Apply the timing analysis separately because the customer may obtain control of different goods or services at different times. Begin by determining whether a performance obligation qualifies for over-time recognition.
  142. 28:43 It qualifies when any one of these three conditions is satisfied: The customer simultaneously receives and consumes the benefits as the company performs.
  143. 28:54 Service or software example: A customer receives continuous access to a software-as-a-service application for one year.
  144. 29:02 Each day of access provides benefit during that day; the customer does not wait until year-end to receive the entire benefit.
  145. 29:11 The company's performance creates or enhances an asset that the customer controls as the asset is created or enhanced.
  146. 29:20 Service or software example: A developer modifies software that the customer already controls in the customer's environment. The customer controls the enhanced software as the developer completes the work.
  147. 29:35 Physical-product example: A contractor constructs an addition on land and an existing building controlled by the customer. The customer controls the construction in progress as the addition is built.
  148. 29:49 The company's performance creates an asset with no alternative use to the company, and the company has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. Both parts are required.
  149. 30:03 The asset lacks alternative use when the company cannot readily redirect it to another customer.
  150. 30:10 The payment right must compensate the company for work completed to date, including a reasonable profit margin, if the customer terminates for a reason other than the company's failure to perform.
  151. 30:25 Service or intangible example: An engineering firm develops plans for a customer's unique facility.
  152. 30:32 The plans cannot be redirected to another customer, and the contract gives the firm an enforceable right to payment for work completed to date if the customer cancels for convenience.
  153. 30:45 Physical-product example: A manufacturer builds a turbine to a customer's unique specifications.
  154. 30:52 The turbine cannot be sold to another customer without significant rework, and the contract provides an enforceable right to payment for work completed to date, including a reasonable profit margin.
  155. 31:06 The examples illustrate the conditions; the product or service label does not determine the answer. Apply the relevant contract, control, alternative-use, and payment-right facts to each performance obligation.
  156. 31:21 Over-time recognition: select a measure of progress. If at least one condition is satisfied, recognize the allocated amount as the company performs.
  157. 31:34 The company must then choose a measure of progress that faithfully depicts how performance transfers to the customer. An output measure uses results delivered to the customer.
  158. 31:49 An input measure uses resources consumed or efforts expended relative to the total expected inputs. Elapsed time is appropriate only when effort and benefit are transferred evenly through the period.
  159. 32:07 Accenture example: why cost can measure progress.
  160. 32:11 In its 2025 Form 10 K, Part II, Item 8, Note 2, "Revenues," Accenture explains that it uses costs incurred relative to estimated total costs for certain technology-integration consulting contracts.
  161. 32:25 The note gives the reason: "Incurred cost represents work performed, which corresponds with, and thereby best depicts, the transfer of control to the client." The important point is not that consulting companies always
  162. 32:42 use a cost-to-cost measure. Accenture uses that input measure because the costs incurred for these contracts correspond to work transferred to the client.
  163. 32:54 If significant costs did not reflect progress toward transferring the promised service, including them without adjustment would distort the measure of progress.
  164. 33:06 The company would need to adjust the input measure or select a different measure that better depicts performance.
  165. 33:14 Point-in-time recognition: identify when control transfers. If none of the three conditions is satisfied, recognize the allocated amount at the point when the customer obtains control.
  166. 33:29 To identify that point, consider indicators that control of the promised asset has transferred to the customer, including: the company has a present right to payment. legal title has transferred.
  167. 33:45 physical possession has transferred. the customer has the significant risks and rewards of ownership. the customer has accepted the asset. No single indicator applies mechanically in every contract.
  168. 34:00 Evaluate the indicators together against the transfer of control.
  169. 34:06 Record and report the contract. Revenue, billing, and cash collection are different events. Their order determines the customer-contract accounts.
  170. 34:18 In Chapter 1's journal-entry sequence, cash received before service created unearned revenue because the company still owed the service.
  171. 34:30 Chapter 2's accruals and deferrals showed the opposite timing: performance can create revenue and a receivable before collection.
  172. 34:41 A S C Topic 606 retains those debit-and-credit patterns and adds an important distinction between a conditional contract asset and an unconditional receivable.
  173. 34:54 How the order of events determines the contract balances. On the first path, performance comes first. Step 1, the company performs and transfers the promised good or service.
  174. 35:11 It recognizes revenue and records a contract asset, because payment remains conditional. Step 2, the right to payment becomes unconditional. The company records a receivable and replaces the contract asset.
  175. 35:30 Step 3, the company collects. It records cash and replaces the receivable. On the second path, billing or collection comes first. Step 1, the company bills or collects before performance.
  176. 35:47 It records a contract liability, because it still owes goods or services. Step 2, the company performs. It recognizes revenue and reduces the contract liability.
  177. 36:02 Event, Bill or collect before performance; Typical entry, Debit Receivable or Cash; credit Contract Liability; Statement effect, A liability remains until the company transfers the promised good or service.
  178. 36:22 Event, Perform before the right to payment is unconditional; Typical entry, Debit Contract Asset; credit Revenue; Statement effect, The asset remains conditional on something other than the passage of time.
  179. 36:42 Event, The right becomes unconditional; Typical entry, Debit Receivable; credit Contract Asset; Statement effect, The conditional right becomes a receivable.
  180. 36:57 Event, Collect a receivable; Typical entry, Debit Cash; credit Receivable; Statement effect, Collection changes the asset held, not revenue.
  181. 37:11 Event, Recognize revenue after an advance billing; Typical entry, Debit Contract Liability; credit Revenue; Statement effect, Performance reduces the remaining obligation to the customer.
  182. 37:29 A receivable is an unconditional right to consideration: only the passage of time is required before payment is due.
  183. 37:38 A contract asset is a right to consideration that still depends on another condition, usually further performance.
  184. 37:47 A contract liability is an obligation to transfer goods or services for consideration already received or due. The company presents unconditional receivables separately.
  185. 38:01 For the remaining rights and obligations in one contract, the relationship between performance and payment produces a contract asset or a contract liability.
  186. 38:14 Adobe: why two future-revenue measures differ.
  187. 38:17 Adobe's 2025 Form 10 K, Part II, Item 8, Note 2, "Revenue," includes a section titled "Deferred Revenue and Remaining Performance Obligations." It describes deferred revenue as: "billings or payments received in advance
  188. 38:33 of revenue recognition" The same section explains that remaining performance obligations represent: "contracted revenue that has not yet been recognized" Adobe reported 7.03 billion dollars of deferred revenue and 22.52
  189. 38:49 billion dollars of remaining performance obligations as of November 28, 2025.
  190. 38:55 The amounts differ because remaining performance obligations include both deferred revenue and contracted amounts that have not yet been billed.
  191. 39:06 Deferred revenue answers whether billing or payment occurred before performance. Remaining performance obligations answer how much contracted revenue has not yet been recognized.
  192. 39:19 Neither amount is automatically revenue for the next year because Adobe must still satisfy the related performance obligations, and some of the revenue will be recognized after the next 12 months.
  193. 39:33 Apply the five steps to Fairmont Health. The exhibit below contains the selected terms needed for the accounting analysis. It is a teaching document, not a complete legal agreement. Read the business terms first.
  194. 39:51 Each step then returns to the relevant language and explains what it establishes.
  195. 39:58 Selected contract terms between Sable Ridge Instruments, the seller, and Fairmont Health, the customer. Agreement date April 1, for the S R 400 diagnostic system. Clause A, purpose.
  196. 40:13 Fairmont will use the S R 400 system in its diagnostic-testing operations. Sable will provide the equipment, supplies, and services described below, and Fairmont will pay the stated consideration.
  197. 40:28 Clause B, goods and services.
  198. 40:31 Sable will provide one standard S R 400 analyzer; installation and validation; 1,200 test kits in 12 scheduled batches; and continuous calibration monitoring from April 1 through March 31 three years later.
  199. 40:47 Clause C, equipment and installation. Sable will deliver the analyzer by May 15. Fairmont may direct its use after delivery and acceptance.
  200. 40:59 Installation uses standard procedures, does not modify the analyzer, and may be performed by other qualified vendors. Sable will complete installation and validation by December 20. Clause D, kits and monitoring.
  201. 41:16 Each kit batch may be used when delivered. The first three batches are scheduled for October 31, November 30, and December 31; the remaining batches follow the delivery schedule in the agreement.
  202. 41:31 The analyzer can use compatible kits from qualified suppliers. Monitoring provides continuous access to calibration support throughout the three-year service period. Clause E, price adjustment.
  203. 41:47 Total stated consideration is 360,000 dollars. Fairmont will receive a 12,000 dollars credit if it processes more than 500 tests by December 15. Clause F, billing and payment.
  204. 42:01 Sable will invoice 208,000 dollars when Fairmont accepts the analyzer, 40,000 dollars when installation and validation are complete, 8,000 dollars as each kit batch is delivered, and the remaining 16,000 dollars in equal
  205. 42:19 quarterly monitoring installments.
  206. 42:22 Each invoice is due within 30 days. Any earned credit will reduce the next invoice. Clause G, approval and remedies. This agreement becomes effective when signed by authorized representatives of both parties.
  207. 42:41 Each party must perform its stated obligations. Either party may enforce the agreement and seek the stated remedies following the other party's breach. Both parties' authorized signatures are on file.
  208. 43:00 Identify the contract. The five conditions require evidence from both the agreement and Sable's customer records.
  209. 43:10 Evidence supporting the five contract conditions. Condition 1, approval and commitment. Clause G and both signatures show approval, enforceable obligations, and commitment to perform. Condition 2, identifiable rights.
  210. 43:30 Clauses B through D state the goods and services Fairmont will receive and when it can use them. Condition 3, identifiable payment terms.
  211. 43:44 Clauses E and F state the consideration, possible credit, invoice events, and 30-day payment period. Condition 4, commercial substance. Clause A exchanges a diagnostic system for consideration.
  212. 44:02 The exchange changes the timing, amount, and risk of the parties' future cash flows. Condition 5, probable collection.
  213. 44:13 Sable's credit file shows Fairmont has paid prior purchases when due and has sufficient resources to pay this agreement.
  214. 44:25 Together, that evidence satisfies all five conditions. Sable therefore accounts for the agreement as a contract with a customer under A S C Topic 606.
  215. 44:37 Sable signs a separate agreement with Fairmont's research affiliate two months later.
  216. 44:44 It was negotiated separately, its price does not depend on the April agreement, and its promises do not combine with the April promises. Sable does not combine the two agreements.
  217. 44:58 Identify the performance obligations. Clauses B through D identify the promises and supply the facts needed for the distinct analysis. Fairmont can use the standard analyzer with kits from a qualified supplier.
  218. 45:14 Another qualified vendor can perform the standard installation, which does not significantly integrate, modify, or customize the analyzer. The analyzer and installation are therefore distinct.
  219. 45:28 Each scheduled kit batch is usable when delivered and is not integrated with another promise. Each batch is distinct and transfers separately at a point in time.
  220. 45:41 The calculations below aggregate the identical batch allocations for display; that presentation does not turn the batches into a Topic 606 series.
  221. 45:52 Fairmont receives and consumes the calibration-monitoring benefit each day. Each day would qualify for over-time recognition, and Sable uses the same elapsed-time measure for each day.
  222. 46:05 The monitoring services therefore form one series performance obligation.
  223. 46:11 Determine the transaction price. Apply the Step 3 decisions in order: Begin with fixed consideration. Clause E states a fixed contract amount of 360,000 dollars. Identify the variable amount and its possible outcomes.
  224. 46:28 If Fairmont processes more than 500 tests by December 15, it receives the 12,000 dollars credit and Sable is entitled to 348,000 dollars.
  225. 46:38 If Fairmont does not exceed 500 tests, there is no credit and Sable is entitled to 360,000 dollars. Select and apply the estimation method. Because the credit has two possible outcomes, Sable uses the most likely amount.
  226. 46:55 Fairmont processed 780 tests with its prior analyzer, the current year follows the same pattern, and little time remains before the measurement date.
  227. 47:07 The more likely outcome is that Fairmont earns the 12,000 dollars credit, producing an estimated transaction price of 348,000 dollars. Apply the constraint.
  228. 47:19 The 12,000 dollars credit is the maximum reduction under the contract.
  229. 47:24 If Fairmont does not earn it, consideration increases to 360,000 dollars; it does not fall below the 348,000 dollars estimate because of this uncertainty.
  230. 47:36 Using 348,000 dollars therefore does not expose recognized revenue to a later downward reversal from the usage credit, so Sable does not constrain the estimate further.
  231. 47:49 Fairmont exceeds 500 tests on December 15, and Sable issues the credit. The uncertainty is resolved before year-end, and the final consideration remains 348,000 dollars.
  232. 48:02 Fixed consideration of 360,000 dollars, minus the expected credit of 12,000 dollars, equals a transaction price of 348,000 dollars.
  233. 48:18 Clause F ties invoices to acceptance, completion, delivery, and quarterly service. The scheduled payments occur close to the related transfers and do not provide either party with a significant financing benefit.
  234. 48:35 Sable therefore does not discount the consideration or recognize a separate interest component. Its transaction price remains 348,000 dollars. Allocate the transaction price.
  235. 48:48 Step 3 produced one 348,000 dollars transaction price, and Step 2 identified the obligations that must receive portions of it.
  236. 48:58 Sable's pricing records show standalone selling prices of 200,000 dollars for the analyzer, 40,000 dollars for installation and validation, 120,000 dollars for the kit batches, and 40,000 dollars for monitoring.
  237. 49:15 Sable first allocates the 360,000 dollars fixed consideration in proportion to those prices.
  238. 49:22 Clause E makes the credit depend specifically on kit volume, and assigning it to the kit batches is consistent with the allocation objective for the full contract.
  239. 49:35 Sable therefore assigns the 12,000 dollars variable amount to the kit batches.
  240. 49:41 The allocation table has four obligations. The analyzer: standalone selling price 200,000 dollars, fixed consideration 180,000 dollars, final allocation 180,000 dollars.
  241. 50:00 Installation and validation: standalone selling price 40,000 dollars, fixed consideration 36,000 dollars, final allocation 36,000 dollars.
  242. 50:16 The twelve kit batches: standalone selling price 120,000 dollars, fixed consideration 108,000 dollars, expected credit negative 12,000 dollars, final allocation 96,000 dollars.
  243. 50:35 The calibration-monitoring series: standalone selling price 40,000 dollars, fixed consideration 36,000 dollars, final allocation 36,000 dollars.
  244. 50:52 In total: standalone selling prices 400,000 dollars, fixed consideration 360,000 dollars, expected credit negative 12,000 dollars, final allocation 348,000 dollars.
  245. 51:10 The final allocation ties to the 348,000 dollars transaction price. Determine when to recognize each allocation.
  246. 51:19 Apply the Step 5 timing decision to each obligation before calculating the amount recognized through December 31.
  247. 51:29 The analyzer and installation use different recognition patterns, but both are fully recognized by year-end. The analyzer transfers at one point on May 15.
  248. 51:42 Installation transfers over time, and Sable has completed it by December 20. The kit and monitoring obligations are only partially recognized by year-end.
  249. 51:55 For the kits, 3 of 12 delivered batches means Sable recognizes 25 percent of the 96,000 dollars allocation:
  250. 52:04 The kit allocation of 96,000 dollars, multiplied by 25 percent delivered, equals kit revenue of 24,000 dollars.
  251. 52:19 For monitoring, Fairmont receives and consumes the benefit as Sable performs. Because the service and benefit are even throughout the three years, elapsed time faithfully depicts progress.
  252. 52:36 Nine of 36 months have passed by December 31:
  253. 52:40 The monitoring allocation of 36,000 dollars, multiplied by 9 months out of 36, equals monitoring revenue of 9,000 dollars.
  254. 52:55 The completed analysis, obligation by obligation. The analyzer: point in time. Clause C gives Fairmont control upon delivery and acceptance on May 15. Allocation 180,000 dollars, revenue 180,000 dollars.
  255. 53:16 Installation and validation: over time, under condition 2. The work enhances the analyzer Fairmont controls, and Sable completes the work on December 20. Allocation 36,000 dollars, revenue 36,000 dollars.
  256. 53:37 The twelve kit batches: point in time for each batch. Fairmont controls 3 of the 12 kit batches delivered by December 31. Allocation 96,000 dollars, revenue 24,000 dollars.
  257. 53:55 The calibration-monitoring series: over time, under condition 1, measured using elapsed time. Fairmont receives the benefit evenly, and 9 of 36 months have passed. Allocation 36,000 dollars, revenue 9,000 dollars.
  258. 54:17 In total: allocation 348,000 dollars, revenue through December 31 of 249,000 dollars.
  259. 54:26 Report Fairmont's year-end balances. By December 31, Sable has invoiced Fairmont 264,000 dollars after issuing the expected 12,000 dollars credit.
  260. 54:42 Fairmont has paid 228,000 dollars, leaving a 36,000 dollars unconditional receivable. Sable has recognized 249,000 dollars of revenue.
  261. 54:57 Contract activity through December 31. Amount invoiced, 264,000 dollars. Less revenue recognized, 249,000 dollars. Contract liability, 15,000 dollars.
  262. 55:22 Sable presents the 36,000 dollars receivable separately from the 15,000 dollars contract liability. The credit to Fairmont has already settled the expected refund, so no refund liability remains at December 31.
  263. 55:40 Check your understanding. Suppose Sable completes the 36,000 dollars installation, but billing still depends on Fairmont's quality group validating the work in January.
  264. 55:54 Does Sable report a receivable or a contract asset on December 31? Pause to consider your answer. Here is the explanation. Sable reports a contract asset. Its right to payment still depends on customer validation.
  265. 56:13 The right becomes a receivable when only the passage of time remains before payment is due.
  266. 56:20 Apply the model independently: Northline Components. Northline Components and a customer sign a written agreement for a standard controller and a custom production mold.
  267. 56:32 The agreement identifies both items, requires the customer to pay 40,000 dollars when the controller is delivered and 80,000 dollars as specified mold milestones are reached, and can be terminated only under stated
  268. 56:46 conditions. Both parties are committed to perform. Northline's credit review shows that the customer has sufficient financing and a reliable payment history.
  269. 56:57 The arrangement is expected to change the timing and amount of Northline's future cash flows. Northline earns another 10,000 dollars if the customer approves the mold by March 31.
  270. 57:09 Approval either occurs or does not occur. At December 31, all engineering tests are complete, the customer has approved every prior mold at this stage, and no remaining factor is outside Northline's control.
  271. 57:23 The controller is an off-the-shelf product that the customer can use with its existing equipment. Northline also designs and builds a mold for a new product with dimensions unique to the customer.
  272. 57:36 Northline does not integrate the controller and mold, and neither item modifies the other. Their standalone selling prices are 40,000 dollars and 80,000 dollars.
  273. 57:47 The customer pays the 10,000 dollars bonus only if the mold passes the customer's specified approval tests. Northline regularly sells similar molds for 90,000 dollars when they have passed the same tests.
  274. 58:01 Northline delivers the controller on December 15. The contract prohibits Northline from redirecting the unfinished mold to another customer, and its unique dimensions would make another use impractical.
  275. 58:14 The customer must pay for work completed to date plus a reasonable profit if it cancels for a reason other than Northline's failure to perform. Applicable law makes that clause enforceable.
  276. 58:30 Northline uses labor and machine costs to measure progress because those inputs correspond to the design and production work transferred to the customer.
  277. 58:42 At December 31, qualifying costs incurred are 20,000 dollars and total expected qualifying costs are 80,000 dollars. No abnormal waste is included.
  278. 58:54 By December 31, Northline has billed 40,000 dollars for the controller and an unconditional 15,000 dollars mold milestone. The customer has paid the controller invoice but has not paid the milestone invoice.
  279. 59:11 Question 1: Should Northline account for the agreement as a contract with a customer under A S C Topic 606? Pause to consider your answer. Here is the explanation. Yes.
  280. 59:25 The signed agreement and the parties' commitment show approval. The promised items and payment schedule identify each party's rights and the payment terms.
  281. 59:39 The expected change in future cash flows gives the arrangement commercial substance. The customer's financing and reliable payment history support the conclusion that collection is probable.
  282. 59:55 All five contract criteria are therefore met.
  283. 59:58 Question 2: What are the performance obligations? Pause to consider your answer. Here is the explanation. The standard controller and custom mold are two performance obligations.
  284. 1:00:12 The customer can benefit from the controller with equipment it already has and from the mold in its production process.
  285. 1:00:22 Northline does not provide a significant integration service, and neither item modifies or depends on the other. The two promises therefore pass both parts of the distinct test.
  286. 1:00:36 Question 3: What is the transaction price? Pause to consider your answer. Here is the explanation. The bonus has two outcomes, and the most likely amount better predicts the consideration for this contract.
  287. 1:00:55 The approval history, completed engineering tests, and lack of remaining factors outside Northline's control support including the 10,000 dollars.
  288. 1:01:08 Northline concludes that it is probable that a significant reversal will not occur.
  289. 1:01:16 Fixed consideration of 120,000 dollars, plus the bonus of 10,000 dollars, equals a transaction price of 130,000 dollars.
  290. 1:01:30 Question 4: How is the transaction price allocated? Pause to consider your answer. Here is the explanation.
  291. 1:01:39 The 120,000 dollars fixed consideration is allocated in proportion to the 40,000 dollars and 80,000 dollars standalone selling prices.
  292. 1:01:50 The approval terms tie the bonus to the mold, and the resulting 90,000 dollars mold allocation is consistent with the price Northline charges for similar approved molds.
  293. 1:02:04 Those facts support assigning the 10,000 dollars bonus to the mold rather than spreading it across both obligations.
  294. 1:02:13 The allocation table has two obligations. The controller: fixed consideration 40,000 dollars, final allocation 40,000 dollars.
  295. 1:02:29 The mold: fixed consideration 80,000 dollars, bonus 10,000 dollars, final allocation 90,000 dollars. In total: fixed consideration 120,000 dollars, bonus 10,000 dollars, final allocation 130,000 dollars.
  296. 1:02:53 Question 5: How much revenue is recognized by December 31? Pause to consider your answer. Here is the explanation. The controller transfers at a point in time when the customer obtains control on December 15.
  297. 1:03:11 Northline recognizes its 40,000 dollars allocation. The mold satisfies the third over-time condition. Its unique dimensions and the contractual restriction prevent Northline from redirecting it.
  298. 1:03:27 The termination clause gives Northline a right to payment for work completed to date, including a reasonable profit. Neither fact would be enough by itself; the third condition requires both.
  299. 1:03:43 The cost-based input measure depicts Northline's design and production work. Qualifying costs show 25 percent progress: 20,000 dollars divided by 80,000 dollars.
  300. 1:03:56 The billing milestone does not measure progress because it states when Northline may invoice, not how much work Northline has transferred.
  301. 1:04:08 The mold allocation of 90,000 dollars, multiplied by 25 percent progress, equals mold revenue of 22,500 dollars.
  302. 1:04:23 Total revenue is 40,000 dollars plus 22,500 dollars equals 62,500 dollars. Question 6: What remains on the balance sheet? Pause to consider your answer. Here is the explanation.
  303. 1:04:42 The unpaid 15,000 dollars milestone is a receivable because Northline's right to that amount is unconditional.
  304. 1:04:54 Northline has recognized 62,500 dollars and billed 55,000 dollars, so the remaining 7,500 dollars is a contract asset. Collection of the controller invoice removes that receivable; it does not change revenue.
  305. 1:05:17 Northline has no contract liability because performance is ahead of billing.
  306. 1:05:26 Sources. F A S B Accounting Standards Update 2014-09, Revenue from Contracts with Customers. F A S B Revenue Recognition Implementation questions and answers. Microsoft 2025 Form 10 K, Note 1 revenue recognition.
  307. 1:05:42 Accenture 2025 Form 10 K, Note 2 revenue recognition. Adobe 2025 Form 10 K, deferred revenue and remaining performance obligations. Return to the written chapter for the Northline Components contract.
  308. 1:05:58 Work the six questions in order before opening any answer.
  309. 1:06:03 Decide whether the agreement is a contract under Topic 606, name the performance obligations, set the transaction price, allocate it, compute the revenue recognized through December 31, and state what remains on the
  310. 1:06:20 balance sheet. Then try the three Atlas checks and the variable-consideration explorer on the page.
In this chapter
  1. One model, many settings
  2. Step 1: Identify the contract to account for
  3. Cash received before Step 1 is satisfied
  4. Decide whether separate agreements form one contract
  5. Step 2: Identify the performance obligations
  6. Apply both parts of the distinct test
  7. How to answer each question
  8. Account for a qualifying series as one performance obligation
  9. Step 3: Determine the transaction price
  10. Estimate variable consideration
  11. Identify a significant financing component
  12. Step 4: Allocate the transaction price
  13. Step 5: Recognize revenue when control transfers
  14. Over-time recognition: select a measure of progress
  15. Point-in-time recognition: identify when control transfers
  16. Record and report the contract
  17. Adobe: why two future-revenue measures differ
  18. Apply the five steps to Fairmont Health
  19. 1. Identify the contract
  20. 2. Identify the performance obligations
  21. 3. Determine the transaction price
  22. 4. Allocate the transaction price
  23. 5. Determine when to recognize each allocation
  24. Report Fairmont's year-end balances
  25. Apply the model independently: Northline Components
  26. Question 1: Should Northline account for the agreement as a contract with a customer under ASC 606?
  27. Question 2: What are the performance obligations?
  28. Question 3: What is the transaction price?
  29. Question 4: How is the transaction price allocated?
  30. Question 5: How much revenue is recognized by December 31?
  31. Question 6: What remains on the balance sheet?
  32. Sources
Review and resources
  1. Generated and standalone practice
  2. Key concepts
  3. Optional lessons
  4. Problems
  5. Primary sources

A signed contract may state one price for several goods and services. Suppose a company signs the contract in November, receives an advance in December, performs consulting work from January through March, and sends its final invoice in April. The signature, cash receipt, work, and invoice occur on different dates. Revenue must follow the transfer of the promised service, not whichever date is easiest to observe.

The company therefore must determine what it promised, how much consideration it expects, and when the customer obtains control of each promised good or service.

Topic 606 organizes that work into five steps.

Step 1
Identify the contract
Which enforceable arrangement does the company account for?
Result: the contract or combined contracts to analyze
→
Step 2
Identify the performance obligations
Which promises transfer distinct goods or services?
Result: the units for allocation and recognition
→
Step 3
Determine the transaction price
How much consideration does the company expect to be entitled to?
Result: the amount available to allocate
→
Step 4
Allocate the transaction price
How much of the transaction price belongs to each obligation?
Result: an allocated amount for each obligation
→
Step 5
Recognize revenue
When does the customer obtain control of each promised good or service?
Result: revenue recognized at a point in time or over time

The five steps determine revenue. Billing and collection then determine whether the balance sheet reports a receivable, contract asset, contract liability, or some combination of those accounts.

One model, many settings

These principles appear in many settings, including consulting projects, software implementations, subscriptions, engineering engagements, and many construction contracts. An industry label can signal that specialized guidance applies. When ASC 606 governs the arrangement, the contract's promises and the way control transfers drive the revenue conclusions.

Some arrangements are governed partly or entirely by other accounting guidance. Those specialized rules are outside this course. Here, the goal is to understand the core revenue decisions and apply them to a new customer contract. Students should also recognize when more guidance may be needed.

Step 1: Identify the contract to account for

A company applies the revenue model to a contract with a customer only when all five of these conditions are satisfied:

  1. The parties approved the arrangement and are committed to perform.
  2. The company can identify each party's rights to the goods or services.
  3. The company can identify the payment terms.
  4. The arrangement has commercial substance, which means it is expected to change the risk, timing, or amount of the company's future cash flows.
  5. Collection of substantially all the consideration to which the company expects to be entitled for the goods or services that will transfer is probable. This assessment considers the customer's ability and intention to pay when payment is due.

These conditions establish whether the company has a contract to which it can apply Topic 606. A signed document alone does not establish that conclusion. In US GAAP, probable means that an event is likely to occur. ASC 606 does not assign that term a fixed numerical percentage, so the conclusion depends on the available evidence rather than a mechanical cutoff.

Common mistake
  • Mistaken idea: A signed agreement is automatically a Topic 606 contract

    Mistaken reasoning: This mistake treats signatures as sufficient and skips scope, enforceability, rights, payment terms, commercial substance, termination, and collectibility.

    Read the full explanation

The amount the company expects to be entitled to may be less than the stated price when the company expects to grant a price concession. That commercial judgment is different from credit risk. A customer who cannot or does not intend to pay an amount the company still expects to be entitled to may fail the collectibility criterion; the company cannot treat that failure as a price concession merely to qualify the arrangement for Topic 606.

Common mistake
  • Mistaken idea: Every customer cash shortfall is a credit loss

    Correction: First determine why the customer will pay less. A discount, return, or agreed price reduction can change the selling price and reduce revenue. Failure to collect an amount the customer still owes creates a credit loss. For example, a customer who earns an early-payment discount has paid the full amount required by the sales terms. The seller records lower revenue, not a credit loss. If the customer owes the full price but cannot pay it, the seller estimates a credit loss on that receivable. The expected cash shortfall alone does not explain which treatment applies.

    Read the full explanation
Quick checkA customer signs an order, but the order does not identify the goods the company must deliver. Can the company apply the five-step revenue model to that order yet?

Answer: No. The company cannot identify the parties' rights to the goods or services. One of the five contract conditions is not satisfied.

Quick checkA company expects to accept $96,000 as full payment on a stated $100,000 price because it routinely grants this customer a $4,000 commercial concession. The customer has the ability and intention to pay $96,000 when due. Does the $4,000 difference automatically cause the collectibility criterion to fail?

Answer: No. The company evaluates probable collection of substantially all the $96,000 it expects to be entitled to after the expected price concession. The answer would differ if the company still expected to be entitled to $100,000 but doubted the customer's ability or intention to pay it.

Cash received before Step 1 is satisfied

If the criteria are not met, the company stops before Step 2 and continues to reassess the arrangement. Cash received is generally a liability rather than revenue. For an equipment arrangement that has not qualified as a Topic 606 contract, Customer Deposit Liability describes why the company still owes the customer performance or repayment.

Entry when Step 1 is not satisfied

When cash is received
Account
Debit
Credit
Account type
Cash
$5,000
asset
Customer Deposit Liability
$5,000
liability

The company keeps the liability until the arrangement later meets the Step 1 criteria or a limited revenue condition in ASC 606-10-25-7 occurs. Those conditions include contract termination with nonrefundable consideration. They also include circumstances in which the company has no remaining obligations and has received all, or substantially all, nonrefundable consideration.

If the arrangement later qualifies, the company begins applying ASC 606. Any advance for goods or services the company still owes becomes a Contract Liability.

That situation differs from advance payment under a valid service contract. When the contract criteria are met but the service remains unperformed, the credit is a Contract Liability. A company's ledger may use a more specific title, such as Unearned Service Revenue or Deferred Subscription Revenue. The account remains a contract liability under ASC 606.

Entry for an advance under a valid contract

When cash is received
Account
Debit
Credit
Account type
Cash
$12,000
asset
Contract Liability
$12,000
liability
Quick checkA customer in severe financial difficulty pays a nonrefundable $5,000 deposit on a $40,000 machine. At inception, the seller concludes that collection of substantially all expected consideration is not probable. What does the seller report?

Answer: Debit Cash and credit Customer Deposit Liability for $5,000. The seller reports no revenue because the arrangement has not qualified as a Topic 606 contract. Calling the deposit nonrefundable does not, by itself, show that the machine transferred or that the liability may be released.

Credit deterioration after a valid contract exists raises a different accounting question. An existing receivable is evaluated under the credit-loss guidance rather than reduced through revenue. A significant change in the customer's ability to pay may also require the company to reassess the Step 1 criteria for the remaining contract. Chapter 14, Receivables, explains the allowance for credit losses under Topic 326. For now, distinguish an inception collectibility failure from a later change in the credit quality of an existing receivable.

Decide whether separate agreements form one contract

Agreements entered into at or near the same time with the same customer or its related parties are combined when at least one of these conditions applies:

  • the agreements were negotiated as a package with one commercial objective;
  • the consideration in one agreement depends on the price or performance of the other; or
  • promises in the agreements form one performance obligation.

Combining contracts changes the set of promises and consideration analyzed in the remaining steps. The fact that two agreements involve the same customer is not sufficient by itself.

Step 2: Identify the performance obligations

Begin with an inventory of the goods and services promised to the customer. Include promises stated in the contract and promises created by the company's customary practices or published policies. Exclude administrative and setup activities that do not transfer a good or service to the customer.

A performance obligation is a promise to transfer either:

  • a distinct good or service, or a distinct bundle of goods or services; or
  • a qualifying series of distinct goods or services that are substantially the same and have the same pattern of transfer to the customer.

Apply both parts of the distinct test

A promised good or service is distinct only when the answer to both questions is yes.

Is the promised good or service distinct?
  1. 1. Capable of being distinct
    Can the customer benefit from the good or service on its own or with a readily available resource?
    No
    Yes
  2. 2. Distinct within the contract
    Is the promise separately identifiable from the other promises in the contract?
    No
    Yes
Combine the promise with other promises. Apply both questions to the resulting bundle.
Account for the promise as a separate performance obligation.

How to answer each question

The next two explanations follow the decision tree in order. Use each one to answer the matching numbered question before moving to the next question.

Question 1: Can the customer benefit from it?

Answer yes when the customer can use, consume, sell, or otherwise benefit from the good or service either on its own or together with a resource that is readily available. A resource is readily available when the customer already has it or can obtain it separately. Answer no when the customer can benefit from the promised good or service only by receiving another promised good or service that is not yet readily available to the customer.

Question 2: Is the promise separately identifiable in the contract?

Consider whether the company:

  • provides a significant service that integrates the item with other promises into one combined output;
  • significantly modifies or customizes another promised item; or
  • provides items that are highly dependent on or highly interrelated with one another.

Answer no when these factors show that the promise is an input to a combined output rather than a separately identifiable promise. Combine it with the specific promised goods or services in the contract to which it is not separately identifiable. Reapply both questions to that combined group. The company continues only until it identifies a group that satisfies both parts of the distinct test; it does not add unrelated promises merely to create a bundle.

Quick checkA vendor delivers standard equipment and installs it. Other vendors can perform the installation, and the installation does not modify the equipment. Are delivery and installation necessarily one performance obligation?

Answer: No. The customer can benefit from each promise, and the facts do not indicate significant integration, modification, or interdependence. The two promises are distinct on these facts.

The Step 2 conclusion matters in later steps. Each performance obligation identified in Step 2 is a unit of account: the company allocates part of the transaction price to it in Step 4 and determines when to recognize that amount as revenue in Step 5.

Common mistake
  • Mistaken idea: Every contract or invoice line is a performance obligation

    Mistaken reasoning: This mistake copies document labels instead of inventorying promises and testing distinctness, setup activities, series guidance, options, and warranties.

    Read the full explanation

Microsoft's revenue note provides a real example of this judgment. Microsoft accounts for some software licenses separately, but it combines certain desktop applications and cloud services when their integration, interdependence, and interrelationship make them one performance obligation. The business setting is different from Atlas, but the distinct-goods-and-services question is the same.

Account for a qualifying series as one performance obligation

The series rule requires a company to account for a series of distinct goods or services as one performance obligation when the goods or services are substantially the same and have the same pattern of transfer to the customer. That pattern exists only when both of these conditions are met:

  1. Each distinct good or service in the series would qualify for over-time recognition if the company accounted for it separately.
  2. The company would use the same method to measure progress toward complete satisfaction of each distinct good or service.

For example, each day of a qualifying daily monitoring service may be distinct, but the company accounts for the series of daily services as one performance obligation. Separate product deliveries that transfer at points in time do not qualify merely because the products are similar or have the same price.

Step 3: Determine the transaction price

The transaction price is the consideration the company expects to be entitled to for transferring the promised goods or services. Begin with fixed consideration, then evaluate amounts that can change.

Common mistake
  • Mistaken idea: The invoice total is the transaction price

    Mistaken reasoning: This mistake substitutes billing labels for fixed and variable consideration, financing, noncash consideration, customer payments, and scope analysis.

    Read the full explanation

Estimate variable consideration

Refunds, rebates, price concessions, bonuses, penalties, and performance payments can make consideration variable. Estimation has two parts. First, select the method that better predicts the amount of consideration to which the company will be entitled. Then apply that method to estimate the amount:

  • Expected value: probability-weight the possible amounts. This method often fits a range of outcomes or many similar contracts.
  • Most likely amount: use the single most likely outcome. This method often fits an uncertainty with two possible outcomes, such as receiving all or none of a bonus.

Use the chosen method consistently for that uncertainty. The resulting amount is the estimate of variable consideration; it is not automatically included in the transaction price.

The variable consideration constraint is the separate requirement that limits how much of that estimate the company may include in the transaction price. Include an amount only to the extent that it is probable that recognizing it will not cause a significant reversal of cumulative revenue when the uncertainty is resolved. Here too, probable means likely to occur, not a fixed percentage. Relevant evidence includes how much of the outcome is outside the company's control, how long the uncertainty will remain, and whether experience with similar contracts predicts the outcome.

If the company has received or has a right to consideration that it expects to refund, it reports a refund liability for the amount it does not expect to retain. The same expected refund is excluded from the transaction price. The company updates both estimates when the facts change.

Estimation and constraint answer different questions:

  • Estimation: Which method better predicts the consideration, and what amount results when the company applies that method?
  • Constraint: How much of that estimated amount may the company include in the transaction price without creating a probable significant reversal of cumulative revenue later?
Common mistake
  • Mistaken idea: A probability-weighted variable estimate is recognized in full

    Mistaken reasoning: This mistake confuses the estimation method with the separate constraint on significant reversal.

    Read the full explanation
Common mistake
  • Mistaken idea: A sales discount becomes expense when cash is collected

    Mistaken reasoning: This mistake records invoice price revenue first and treats a supported settlement discount as a later operating cost.

    Read the full explanation

Identify a significant financing component

A contract has a significant financing component when the timing of payment provides a significant financing benefit to the customer or the company. If the customer receives the good or service well before paying, the company may be financing the customer. If the customer pays well before receiving the good or service, the customer may be financing the company.

Why separate financing from revenue? Revenue should measure the price of the good or service when control transfers. An additional amount charged solely because the customer pays later is interest, not revenue from the good or service. Likewise, an advance payment may include financing provided by the customer. Separating the financing effect ensures that revenue reflects the amount attributable to the promised good or service, while the effect of paying early or late is recognized separately as interest over the financing period.

Use this process:

  1. Compare payment with transfer. Identify when the customer pays and when control of the promised good or service transfers.
  2. Identify who receives the financing benefit. Later payment may finance the customer; early payment may finance the company.
  3. Decide whether the financing benefit is significant. Consider the time between payment and transfer, the difference between the promised amount and the cash selling price, and relevant market interest rates.
  4. Separate the two components. Measure revenue at the cash selling price when control transfers. Recognize the financing effect as interest over the financing period.

Suppose a company sells equipment to a customer and transfers control of the equipment today. The cash selling price is $100,000, but the contract requires the customer to pay $121,000 two years from now. The two-year delay provides financing to the customer. The company recognizes $100,000 of equipment revenue when it transfers control, not $121,000. It recognizes the remaining $21,000 as interest income over the two years. The contract has not produced extra equipment revenue merely because the customer pays later.

A long interval does not automatically create a financing component. For example, payment terms may protect one party from the other party's failure to perform, or the timing of payment may depend on a future event outside either party's control. In those cases, the payment schedule may serve a purpose other than financing.

Topic 606 permits a practical expedient: a company need not adjust for a significant financing component when it expects, at contract inception, that one year or less will pass between transfer and payment. In this course, a problem requiring an adjustment will provide the cash selling price or the information needed to calculate it.

Step 4: Allocate the transaction price

The first three steps supply the inputs for Step 4. Step 1 established that the company has a contract to which Topic 606 applies. Step 2 identified the separate performance obligations in that contract. Step 3 determined one total transaction price for the contract. Step 4 now answers the next question: How much of that total transaction price belongs to each performance obligation?

Why the company allocates the transaction price
Step 4 allocates the total↓

The five obligations and segment widths are illustrative. An actual contract may contain a different number of obligations, and their relative standalone selling prices determine the allocated shares.

The company allocates the transaction price in proportion to the performance obligations' standalone selling prices at contract inception. A standalone selling price is the price at which the company would sell a promised good or service separately to a similar customer in similar circumstances.

If an observable standalone selling price is unavailable, the company estimates it using reasonably available information. Possible approaches include an adjusted market assessment or expected cost plus an appropriate margin. Unless estimating the standalone selling price is the question, this course will provide the amount needed for allocation.

For each obligation:

The final allocations must add to the transaction price. A contract or list price is not automatically a standalone selling price.

Common mistake
  • Mistaken idea: Invoice lines control revenue allocation

    Mistaken reasoning: This mistake allocates stated line prices without establishing standalone selling prices or testing allocation exceptions.

    Read the full explanation

Relative standalone selling prices provide a consistent basis for associating consideration with the goods and services transferred to the customer. Without that basis, invoice labels or management preference could move revenue among obligations and reporting periods without a change in what the company promised the customer.

Topic 606 contains exceptions for a discount or variable amount that relates to only part of a contract. Apply an exception only when the facts establish all of its conditions. For variable consideration, the payment must relate specifically to an obligation or distinct item. Assigning the amount there must also remain consistent with the allocation objective for the contract as a whole.

Step 5: Recognize revenue when control transfers

Step 4 assigned part of the transaction price to each performance obligation. Step 5 determines when each allocated amount becomes revenue. Apply the timing analysis separately because the customer may obtain control of different goods or services at different times.

Begin by determining whether a performance obligation qualifies for over-time recognition. It qualifies when any one of these three conditions is satisfied:

  1. The customer simultaneously receives and consumes the benefits as the company performs.

    • Service or software example: A customer receives continuous access to a SaaS application for one year. Each day of access provides benefit during that day; the customer does not wait until year-end to receive the entire benefit.
  2. The company's performance creates or enhances an asset that the customer controls as the asset is created or enhanced.

    • Service or software example: A developer modifies software that the customer already controls in the customer's environment. The customer controls the enhanced software as the developer completes the work.
    • Physical-product example: A contractor constructs an addition on land and an existing building controlled by the customer. The customer controls the construction in progress as the addition is built.
  3. The company's performance creates an asset with no alternative use to the company, and the company has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. Both parts are required. The asset lacks alternative use when the company cannot readily redirect it to another customer. The payment right must compensate the company for work completed to date, including a reasonable profit margin, if the customer terminates for a reason other than the company's failure to perform.

    • Service or intangible example: An engineering firm develops plans for a customer's unique facility. The plans cannot be redirected to another customer, and the contract gives the firm an enforceable right to payment for work completed to date if the customer cancels for convenience.
    • Physical-product example: A manufacturer builds a turbine to a customer's unique specifications. The turbine cannot be sold to another customer without significant rework, and the contract provides an enforceable right to payment for work completed to date, including a reasonable profit margin.

The examples illustrate the conditions; the product or service label does not determine the answer. Apply the relevant contract, control, alternative-use, and payment-right facts to each performance obligation.

Over-time recognition: select a measure of progress

If at least one condition is satisfied, recognize the allocated amount as the company performs. The company must then choose a measure of progress that faithfully depicts how performance transfers to the customer. An output measure uses results delivered to the customer. An input measure uses resources consumed or efforts expended relative to the total expected inputs. Elapsed time is appropriate only when effort and benefit are transferred evenly through the period.

Common mistake
  • Mistaken idea: Cost incurred proves over-time control and progress

    Mistaken reasoning: This mistake uses incurred cost first, without establishing an over time criterion or whether the input depicts performance.

    Read the full explanation

Accenture example: why cost can measure progress

In its 2025 Form 10-K, Part II, Item 8, Note 2, "Revenues," Accenture explains that it uses costs incurred relative to estimated total costs for certain technology-integration consulting contracts. The note gives the reason:

"Incurred cost represents work performed, which corresponds with, and thereby best depicts, the transfer of control to the client."

The important point is not that consulting companies always use a cost-to-cost measure. Accenture uses that input measure because the costs incurred for these contracts correspond to work transferred to the client. If significant costs did not reflect progress toward transferring the promised service, including them without adjustment would distort the measure of progress. The company would need to adjust the input measure or select a different measure that better depicts performance.

Point-in-time recognition: identify when control transfers

If none of the three conditions is satisfied, recognize the allocated amount at the point when the customer obtains control. To identify that point, consider indicators that control of the promised asset has transferred to the customer, including:

  • the company has a present right to payment;
  • legal title has transferred;
  • physical possession has transferred;
  • the customer has the significant risks and rewards of ownership; and
  • the customer has accepted the asset.

No single indicator applies mechanically in every contract. Evaluate the indicators together against the transfer of control.

Common mistake
  • Mistaken idea: Shipment always transfers control

    Mistaken reasoning: The shipment date is not always the sale date. Control may transfer at delivery or another event required by the contract.

    Read the full explanation

Record and report the contract

Performance, the right to payment, and cash collection determine the customer-contract accounts. Sending an invoice alone does not establish an unconditional right to payment.

In the journal-entry examples in Chapter 1, cash received before service created unearned revenue because the company still owed the service. The accrual and deferral examples in Chapter 2 showed the opposite timing: performance can create revenue and a receivable before collection. ASC 606 retains those debit-and-credit patterns and adds an important distinction between a conditional contract asset and an unconditional receivable.

Performance comes first
1 · Perform
Transfer the promised good or service
Recognize revenue
Record a contract asset because payment remains conditional
→
2 · Right becomes unconditional
Record a receivable
Replace the contract asset
→
3 · Collect
Record cash
Replace the receivable
Payment precedes performance
1 · Payment received or due
Any amount due must be unconditional
Record a contract liability
The company still owes goods or services
→
2 · Perform
Transfer the promised good or service
Recognize revenue
Reduce the contract liability
Event Typical entry Statement effect
Receive cash before performance Debit Cash; credit Contract Liability The company owes goods or services to the customer
An unconditional payment becomes due before performance Debit Receivable; credit Contract Liability The customer owes payment, and the company owes goods or services
Perform before the right to payment is unconditional Debit Contract Asset; credit Revenue The asset remains conditional on something other than the passage of time
The right becomes unconditional Debit Receivable; credit Contract Asset The conditional right becomes a receivable
Collect a receivable Debit Cash; credit Receivable Collection changes the asset held, not revenue
Perform after recording a contract liability Debit Contract Liability; credit Revenue Performance reduces the remaining obligation to the customer

A receivable is an unconditional right to consideration: only the passage of time is required before payment is due. A contract asset is a right to consideration that still depends on another condition, usually further performance. A contract liability is an obligation to transfer goods or services for consideration already received or due. Under ASC 606-10-45-2, the company records the contract liability when it receives payment or an unconditional payment becomes due, whichever occurs first.

Common mistake
  • Mistaken idea: A receivable and contract asset are synonyms

    Correction: A receivable is an unconditional payment right. A contract asset is a right for goods or services already transferred that remains conditional on something other than time. Both can exist before cash collection, which makes the mistaken comparison plausible.

    Read the full explanation

The company presents unconditional receivables separately. For the remaining rights and obligations in one contract, the relationship between performance and payment produces a contract asset or a contract liability.

Adobe: why two future-revenue measures differ

Adobe's 2025 Form 10-K, Part II, Item 8, Note 2, "Revenue," includes a section titled "Deferred Revenue and Remaining Performance Obligations." It describes deferred revenue as:

"billings or payments received in advance of revenue recognition"

The same section explains that remaining performance obligations represent:

"contracted revenue that has not yet been recognized"

Adobe reported $7.03 billion of deferred revenue and $22.52 billion of remaining performance obligations as of November 28, 2025. The amounts differ because remaining performance obligations include both deferred revenue and contracted amounts that have not yet been billed. Deferred revenue answers whether billing or payment occurred before performance. Remaining performance obligations answer how much contracted revenue has not yet been recognized. Neither amount is automatically revenue for the next year because Adobe must still satisfy the related performance obligations, and some of the revenue will be recognized after the next 12 months.

Apply the five steps to Fairmont Health

The exhibit below contains the selected terms needed for the accounting analysis. It is a teaching document, not a complete legal agreement. Read the business terms first. Each step then returns to the relevant language and explains what it establishes.

Selected contract termsSable Ridge Instruments and Fairmont HealthAgreement date: April 1 · SR-400 diagnostic system
SellerSable Ridge Instruments
CustomerFairmont Health
A · Purpose

Fairmont will use the SR-400 system in its diagnostic-testing operations. Sable will provide the equipment, supplies, and services described below, and Fairmont will pay the stated consideration.

B · Goods and services

Sable will provide one standard SR-400 analyzer; installation and validation; 1,200 test kits in 12 scheduled batches; and continuous calibration monitoring from April 1 through March 31 three years later.

C · Equipment and installation

Sable will deliver the analyzer by May 15. Fairmont may direct its use after delivery and acceptance. Installation uses standard procedures, does not modify the analyzer, and may be performed by other qualified vendors. Sable will complete installation and validation by December 20.

D · Kits and monitoring

Each kit batch may be used when delivered. The first three batches are scheduled for October 31, November 30, and December 31; the remaining batches follow the delivery schedule in the agreement. The analyzer can use compatible kits from qualified suppliers. Monitoring provides continuous access to calibration support throughout the three-year service period.

E · Price adjustment

Total stated consideration is $360,000. Fairmont will receive a $12,000 credit if it processes more than 500 tests by December 15.

F · Billing and payment

Sable will invoice $208,000 when Fairmont accepts the analyzer, $40,000 when installation and validation are complete, $8,000 as each kit batch is delivered, and the remaining $16,000 in equal quarterly monitoring installments. Each invoice is due within 30 days. Any earned credit will reduce the next invoice.

G · Approval and remedies

This agreement becomes effective when signed by authorized representatives of both parties. Each party must perform its stated obligations. Either party may enforce the agreement and seek the stated remedies following the other party's breach.

Sable Ridge InstrumentsAuthorized signature on file
Fairmont HealthAuthorized signature on file

1. Identify the contract

The five conditions require evidence from both the agreement and Sable's customer records.

1 · Approval and commitment

Clause G and both signatures show approval, enforceable obligations, and commitment to perform.

2 · Identifiable rights

Clauses B through D state the goods and services Fairmont will receive and when it can use them.

3 · Identifiable payment terms

Clauses E and F state the consideration, possible credit, invoice events, and 30-day payment period.

4 · Commercial substance

Clause A exchanges a diagnostic system for consideration. The exchange changes the timing, amount, and risk of the parties' future cash flows.

5 · Probable collection

Sable's credit file shows Fairmont has paid prior purchases when due and has sufficient resources to pay this agreement.

Together, that evidence satisfies all five conditions. Sable therefore accounts for the agreement as a contract with a customer under ASC 606.

Sable signs a separate agreement with Fairmont's research affiliate two months later. It was negotiated separately, its price does not depend on the April agreement, and its promises do not combine with the April promises. Sable does not combine the two agreements.

2. Identify the performance obligations

Clauses B through D identify the promises and supply the facts needed for the distinct analysis. Fairmont can use the standard analyzer with kits from a qualified supplier. Another qualified vendor can perform the standard installation, which does not significantly integrate, modify, or customize the analyzer. The analyzer and installation are therefore distinct.

Each scheduled kit batch is usable when delivered and is not integrated with another promise. Each batch is distinct and transfers separately at a point in time. The calculations below aggregate the identical batch allocations for display; that presentation does not turn the batches into a Topic 606 series.

Fairmont receives and consumes the calibration-monitoring benefit each day. Each day would qualify for over-time recognition, and Sable uses the same elapsed-time measure for each day. The monitoring services therefore form one series performance obligation.

3. Determine the transaction price

Apply the Step 3 decisions in order:

  1. Begin with fixed consideration. Clause E states a fixed contract amount of $360,000.
  2. Identify the variable amount and its possible outcomes. If Fairmont processes more than 500 tests by December 15, it receives the $12,000 credit and Sable is entitled to $348,000. If Fairmont does not exceed 500 tests, there is no credit and Sable is entitled to $360,000.
  3. Select and apply the estimation method. Because the credit has two possible outcomes, Sable uses the most likely amount. Fairmont processed 780 tests with its prior analyzer, the current year follows the same pattern, and little time remains before the measurement date. The more likely outcome is that Fairmont earns the $12,000 credit, producing an estimated transaction price of $348,000.
  4. Apply the constraint. The $12,000 credit is the maximum reduction under the contract. If Fairmont does not earn it, consideration increases to $360,000; it does not fall below the $348,000 estimate because of this uncertainty. Using $348,000 therefore does not expose recognized revenue to a later downward reversal from the usage credit, so Sable does not constrain the estimate further.

Fairmont exceeds 500 tests on December 15, and Sable issues the credit. The uncertainty is resolved before year-end, and the final consideration remains $348,000.

Clause F ties invoices to acceptance, completion, delivery, and quarterly service. The scheduled payments occur close to the related transfers and do not provide either party with a significant financing benefit. Sable therefore does not discount the consideration or recognize a separate interest component. Its transaction price remains $348,000.

4. Allocate the transaction price

Step 3 produced one $348,000 transaction price, and Step 2 identified the obligations that must receive portions of it. Sable's pricing records show standalone selling prices of $200,000 for the analyzer, $40,000 for installation and validation, $120,000 for the kit batches, and $40,000 for monitoring. Sable first allocates the $360,000 fixed consideration in proportion to those prices. Clause E makes the credit depend specifically on kit volume, and assigning it to the kit batches is consistent with the allocation objective for the full contract. Sable therefore assigns the $12,000 variable amount to the kit batches.

Obligation Standalone selling price Fixed consideration Expected credit Final allocation
Analyzer $200,000 $180,000 — $180,000
Installation and validation 40,000 36,000 — 36,000
Twelve kit batches 120,000 108,000 $(12,000) 96,000
Calibration-monitoring series 40,000 36,000 — 36,000
Total $400,000 $360,000 $(12,000) $348,000

The final allocation ties to the $348,000 transaction price.

5. Determine when to recognize each allocation

Apply the Step 5 timing decision to each obligation before calculating the amount recognized through December 31.

The analyzer and installation use different recognition patterns, but both are fully recognized by year-end. The analyzer transfers at one point on May 15. Installation transfers over time, and Sable has completed it by December 20.

The kit and monitoring obligations are only partially recognized by year-end. For the kits, 3 of 12 delivered batches means Sable recognizes 25% of the $96,000 allocation:

For monitoring, Fairmont receives and consumes the benefit as Sable performs. Because the service and benefit are even throughout the three years, elapsed time faithfully depicts progress. Nine of 36 months have passed by December 31:

The completed analysis produces the following obligation-by-obligation summary:

Obligation Recognition pattern and evidence Allocation and revenue through December 31
Analyzer Point in time. Clause C gives Fairmont control upon delivery and acceptance on May 15. Allocation: $180,000
Revenue: $180,000
Installation and validation Over time (condition 2). The work enhances the analyzer Fairmont controls; Sable completes the work on December 20. Allocation: $36,000
Revenue: $36,000
Twelve kit batches Point in time for each batch. Fairmont controls 3 of the 12 kit batches delivered by December 31. Allocation: $96,000
Revenue: $24,000
Calibration-monitoring series Over time (condition 1), measured using elapsed time. Fairmont receives the benefit evenly; 9 of 36 months have passed. Allocation: $36,000
Revenue: $9,000
Total Allocation: $348,000
Revenue: $249,000

Report Fairmont's year-end balances

By December 31, Sable has invoiced Fairmont $264,000 after issuing the expected $12,000 credit. Fairmont has paid $228,000, leaving a $36,000 unconditional receivable. Sable has recognized $249,000 of revenue.

Contract activity through December 31 Amount
Amount invoiced $264,000
Revenue recognized (249,000)
Contract liability $15,000

Sable presents the $36,000 receivable separately from the $15,000 contract liability. The credit to Fairmont has already settled the expected refund, so no refund liability remains at December 31.

Quick checkSuppose Sable completes the $36,000 installation, but billing still depends on Fairmont's quality group validating the work in January. Does Sable report a receivable or a contract asset on December 31?

Answer: Sable reports a contract asset. Its right to payment still depends on customer validation. The right becomes a receivable when only the passage of time remains before payment is due.

Apply the model independently: Northline Components

Northline Components and a customer sign a written agreement for a standard controller and a custom production mold. The agreement identifies both items, requires the customer to pay $40,000 when the controller is delivered and $80,000 as specified mold milestones are reached, and can be terminated only under stated conditions. Both parties are committed to perform. Northline's credit review shows that the customer has sufficient financing and a reliable payment history. The arrangement is expected to change the timing and amount of Northline's future cash flows.

Northline earns another $10,000 if the customer approves the mold by March 31. Approval either occurs or does not occur. At December 31, all engineering tests are complete, the customer has approved every prior mold at this stage, and no remaining factor is outside Northline's control.

The controller is an off-the-shelf product that the customer can use with its existing equipment. Northline also designs and builds a mold for a new product with dimensions unique to the customer. Northline does not integrate the controller and mold, and neither item modifies the other. Their standalone selling prices are $40,000 and $80,000.

The customer pays the $10,000 bonus only if the mold passes the customer's specified approval tests. Northline regularly sells similar molds for $90,000 when they have passed the same tests. Northline delivers the controller on December 15.

The contract prohibits Northline from redirecting the unfinished mold to another customer, and its unique dimensions would make another use impractical. The customer must pay for work completed to date plus a reasonable profit if it cancels for a reason other than Northline's failure to perform. Applicable law makes that clause enforceable. Northline uses labor and machine costs to measure progress because those inputs correspond to the design and production work transferred to the customer. At December 31, qualifying costs incurred are $20,000 and total expected qualifying costs are $80,000. No abnormal waste is included.

By December 31, Northline has billed $40,000 for the controller and an unconditional $15,000 mold milestone. The customer has paid the controller invoice but has not paid the milestone invoice.

Question 1: Should Northline account for the agreement as a contract with a customer under ASC 606?

Show the answer

Yes. The signed agreement and the parties' commitment show approval. The promised items and payment schedule identify each party's rights and the payment terms. The expected change in future cash flows gives the arrangement commercial substance. The customer's financing and reliable payment history support the conclusion that collection is probable. All five contract criteria are therefore met.

Question 2: What are the performance obligations?

Show the answer

The standard controller and custom mold are two performance obligations. The customer can benefit from the controller with equipment it already has and from the mold in its production process. Northline does not provide a significant integration service, and neither item modifies or depends on the other. The two promises therefore pass both parts of the distinct test.

Question 3: What is the transaction price?

Show the answer

The bonus has two outcomes, and the most likely amount better predicts the consideration for this contract. The approval history, completed engineering tests, and lack of remaining factors outside Northline's control support including the $10,000. Northline concludes that it is probable that a significant reversal will not occur.

Question 4: How is the transaction price allocated?

Show the answer

The $120,000 fixed consideration is allocated in proportion to the $40,000 and $80,000 standalone selling prices. The approval terms tie the bonus to the mold, and the resulting $90,000 mold allocation is consistent with the price Northline charges for similar approved molds. Those facts support assigning the $10,000 bonus to the mold rather than spreading it across both obligations.

Obligation Fixed consideration Bonus Final allocation
Controller $40,000 — $40,000
Mold 80,000 $10,000 90,000
Total $120,000 $10,000 $130,000

Question 5: How much revenue is recognized by December 31?

Show the answer

The controller transfers at a point in time when the customer obtains control on December 15. Northline recognizes its $40,000 allocation.

The mold satisfies the third over-time condition. Its unique dimensions and the contractual restriction prevent Northline from redirecting it. The termination clause gives Northline a right to payment for work completed to date, including a reasonable profit. Neither fact would be enough by itself; the third condition requires both.

The cost-based input measure depicts Northline's design and production work. Qualifying costs show 25% progress: $20,000 ÷ $80,000. The billing milestone does not measure progress because it states when Northline may invoice, not how much work Northline has transferred.

Total revenue is $40,000 + $22,500 = $62,500.

Question 6: What remains on the balance sheet?

Show the answer

The unpaid $15,000 milestone is a receivable because Northline's right to that amount is unconditional. Northline has recognized $62,500 and billed $55,000, so the remaining $7,500 is a contract asset. Collection of the controller invoice removes that receivable; it does not change revenue. Northline has no contract liability because performance is ahead of billing.

Sources

Sensitivity explorer

See what changes when one assumption changes

This is not a question, and there is no answer to submit. The worked Fairmont analysis above identifies the treatment supported by its facts. This tool lets you replace one assumption at a time and observe which contract and financial-statement amounts would change.

Assumed usage-credit outcome
Variable-consideration estimation method
Assumed constraint conclusion
Assumed allocation of the customer credit
Amounts produced by the selected assumptions
Estimated customer credit $12,000
Transaction price $348,000
Allocated to test kits $96,000
Revenue recognized in 2026 $249,000
Contract liability $15,000
Sable's net income $600,000
Sable's total assets $7,654,000

Showing the assumptions used in the worked Fairmont analysis. No displayed amount differs from the example above. JavaScript enables the hypothetical alternatives.

How to use this tool: begin with the worked Fairmont assumptions, change one selection, and compare the highlighted amounts. A changed result shows which amounts depend on that assumption. It does not mean the alternative is supported by Fairmont's actual facts.
Optional practice

Practice a complete contract or one decision at a time

Work through a generated contract that applies all six chapter objectives, or use 24 standalone multiple-choice questions for focused practice. Every generated case includes a worked answer, and every multiple-choice response receives immediate feedback.

Open the generated case and practice questions

Key concepts in this chapter

Use now

These pages explain ideas used in this chapter.

In class

Class materials

Materials from meeting 8 on Thu 9/24: View the class slides, or download the PDF, 8.4 MB.

Unit 2: Reporting performance, disposals, and revenue