In this chapter
- Allocating the cost of service
- When depreciation becomes an expense
- Matching depreciation to how an asset provides service
- Straight-line depreciation
- Units-of-production depreciation
- Accelerated depreciation
- Double-declining-balance depreciation
- Sum-of-the-years'-digits depreciation
- Comparing depreciation methods
- Selecting a method from the operating facts
- Depreciation on the tax return
- Depreciation across reporting periods
- When depreciation begins
- Calculating depreciation for a partial year
- Activity-based depreciation and partial periods
- Depreciation conventions
- Partial years under accelerated methods
- When depreciation ends
- Depreciating components and groups of assets
- Depreciating significant components separately
- Components under US GAAP and international standards
- Depreciating groups of assets
- Revising depreciation estimates
- Calculating revised depreciation
- Distinguishing estimate changes from errors
- Changing depreciation methods
- Disposing of tangible assets
- Removing an asset from the accounts
- Selling an asset
- How disposal affects the financial statements
- Retiring an asset without selling it
- Involuntary conversions
Review and resources
Straight-line depreciation, the year-end depreciation entry, and carrying amount are assumed in this chapter. If you need to review them, read the straight-line depreciation refresher first.
In Chapter 19, Double Feature Cinemas recorded its laser projector at a cost of $84,000. The projector became ready for use on April 1, 2026. Double Feature expects to use it for 6 years and recover $12,000 when it disposes of it.
The company must allocate the cost of using the projector across those years. Expensing the entire purchase in 2026 would assign no cost to later years, even though the projector continues to screen movies. Depreciation allocates that cost over the expected period of use.
The allocation depends on how the asset provides service, not its resale price. New information may change the estimated useful life or residual value. Double Feature must then revise its remaining depreciation and, when it sells the projector, remove the asset and account for the proceeds.
Double Feature has a December year-end. Amounts are in US dollars.
Allocating the cost of service
Review the cost of purchased equipment in Chapter 19 if you need to revisit which expenditures enter the asset account.
The calculations use the following terms from the introductory course:
- Depreciation allocates cost less estimated residual value over an asset's estimated useful life. Under US GAAP, the allocation must be systematic and rational (ASC 360-10-35-4). It does not measure changes in market value.
- Useful life is the period over which the company expects to use the asset. It can be shorter than the asset's physical life, because a company may replace a working asset with newer technology. In estimating useful lives for groups of assets, companies consider wear and tear, obsolescence, and maintenance and replacement policies (ASC 360-10-35-8).
- Residual value, also called salvage value, is the amount the company expects to recover when it disposes of the asset at the end of its useful life. The company excludes that expected recovery from depreciation because it expects to recover it through disposal rather than use.
- The depreciable amount is recorded cost less residual value. Double Feature's projector cost $84,000 and has an estimated residual value of $12,000, so its depreciable amount is $72,000.
Land generally has an indefinite useful life, so companies do not depreciate it.
- Mistaken idea: Depreciation measures an asset's market-value decline
Correction: Depreciation allocates an asset's depreciable amount to the periods in which the company uses the asset. It does not estimate the price a buyer would pay for the asset today.
Read the full explanation
When depreciation becomes an expense
Depreciation does not always become an expense immediately. Double Feature uses its projector to screen movies, so it records depreciation expense in the period in which it provides those screenings.
A manufacturer includes depreciation of production equipment in manufacturing overhead. The portion allocated to goods becomes part of inventory, then cost of goods sold when those goods are sold. The depreciation calculation and the timing of the resulting expense are therefore separate questions.
For fixed production overhead, the company bases its allocation on normal capacity: the production range expected under normal operating conditions (ASC 330-10-30-3). Abnormally low output does not justify assigning all fixed overhead to the few units produced. Any overhead left unallocated becomes an expense of the period rather than increasing inventory cost (ASC 330-10-30-6 and 30-7).
A paint manufacturer includes allocated mixer depreciation in the cost of its paint. Suppose some of that paint remains unsold at year-end. Where does the manufacturer report the depreciation allocated to the unsold paint: inventory or cost of goods sold for the current period?
Compare your answer.
The depreciation stays in inventory as part of the unsold paint's cost. It becomes cost of goods sold when the paint is sold.
Matching depreciation to how an asset provides service
Equipment wears out through use, and newer technology can make working equipment obsolete. Before choosing a depreciation method, the company considers how it expects to use the asset and what will limit its useful service.
Some equipment provides relatively even service each year. For other equipment, wear depends mainly on how much it operates or produces. Still other equipment provides more productive service early in its life. The company matches its allocation of cost to that expected pattern of service.
| Expected pattern of service | Method that may fit |
|---|---|
| Relatively even service over time | Straight-line |
| Service consumed mainly through measured production or use | Units of production |
| Greater productive service in earlier years | Accelerated |
The company bases its method on those operating facts rather than a preferred amount of reported income. These relationships guide the choice; they do not automatically require a particular method.
True Color Paint blends water-based architectural paint for independent paint stores. Its existing plant uses a mixer that became ready on January 1, 2026. True Color reports on a calendar year basis, and the following amounts are in US dollars. We use the same asset to compare methods, changing the assumed service pattern for each alternative. Unless an example states an alternative, True Color depreciates the mixer by the straight-line method, because it expects the mixer's capacity to be available evenly each year.
| Mixer estimate | Amount |
|---|---|
| Cost | $210,000 |
| Estimated residual value | $10,000 |
| Estimated useful life | 5 years |
| Depreciable amount | $200,000 |
Every method starts with the same $210,000 carrying amount and, under these estimates, ends at the same $10,000 residual value. The total depreciation is the difference:
Depreciable amount = Cost − Residual value = $210,000 − $10,000 = $200,000.
The methods differ in how they allocate that total among years. Straight-line, units of production, and sum-of-the-years'-digits calculate charges from the fixed depreciable amount. Double-declining balance calculates charges from beginning carrying amount and uses residual value as a lower limit.
Straight-line depreciation
The straight-line method allocates an equal share of the depreciable amount to each full year of useful life. It fits service expected to be available relatively evenly across that life.
Annual depreciation = Cost − Residual valueUseful life.
For True Color's mixer, cost less residual value is the $200,000 depreciable amount calculated above. Its useful life is 5 years.
Annual depreciation = Depreciable amountUseful life = $200,0005 years = $40,000 per year.
Different production volumes do not necessarily mean different amounts of service. The mixer can remain available to provide even service while customer orders vary.
Units-of-production depreciation
An activity method allocates the depreciable amount according to measured use. The units-of-production method uses output; another activity measure could be operating hours. The measure should represent consumption of the asset's service more faithfully than time alone.
First divide the depreciable amount by the estimated total activity over the asset's useful life. The result is depreciation cost per unit of the chosen activity measure. Multiply that rate by actual activity during the reporting period.
Depreciation per unit of activity = Cost − Residual valueEstimated lifetime activity.
The rate's units depend on the activity measure. An estimate in operating hours produces a cost per operating hour; an estimate in units of output produces a cost per unit of output. Use the same activity measure in the lifetime estimate and the reporting-period amount.
Period depreciation = Depreciation per unit of activity × Actual activity in the period.
For the mixer example, assume that wear depends mainly on gallons processed. True Color estimates 1,000,000 gallons over the mixer's useful life, not per year. Gallons are therefore the activity unit for this example.
Depreciation per gallon = Depreciable amountEstimated lifetime gallons = $200,0001,000,000 gallons = $0.20 per gallon.
The $0.20 rate assigns part of the mixer's depreciable cost to each gallon. In 2026, True Color processes 250,000 gallons.
2026 depreciation = Actual gallons processed × Depreciation per gallon = 250,000 gallons × $0.20 per gallon = $50,000.
With unchanged estimates, different production volumes change the annual charge while the rate per gallon stays fixed. Management needs reliable activity records and an estimate of lifetime production that it can justify. Straight-line may still be appropriate when service depends mainly on elapsed time rather than measured use.
Accelerated depreciation
An accelerated method assigns more depreciation to earlier periods and less to later periods. It may fit equipment expected to provide greater productive service early in its life. For example, output per operating hour may decline as a machine ages.
Obsolescence can also reduce useful service before equipment physically wears out. Newer technology may make existing equipment less useful in later years. But obsolescence can shorten useful life without changing the pattern within that life. Equipment could provide even service for 3 years before replacement; straight-line over those 3 years could fit.
A company may also justify accelerated depreciation when it expects maintenance costs to rise as equipment ages (ASC 360-10-35-7). Neither rising maintenance costs nor greater early service automatically requires a particular method. The company must justify a systematic and rational allocation using its expectations about the asset (ASC 360-10-35-4).
Declining balance and sum-of-the-years'-digits are accelerated methods. They produce declining charges through different calculations.
Double-declining-balance depreciation
The double-declining-balance method (DDB) uses a fixed annual rate equal to twice the straight-line rate. The straight-line rate is an equal annual share of the whole depreciable amount, based on estimated useful life.
DDB annual rate = 2 × 100%Estimated useful life in years.
DDB depreciation = Beginning carrying amount × DDB rate.
DDB doubles the straight-line percentage, not the straight-line dollar charge. Each year, multiply the beginning carrying amount by the DDB rate. Stop depreciating when carrying amount reaches residual value, and reduce the final charge if needed to avoid going below it.
Each year's ending carrying amount becomes the next year's beginning balance, while the rate stays fixed.
For True Color's mixer, a 5-year useful life gives a straight-line share of one-fifth per year. Double that percentage to find the DDB rate:
Straight-line annual rate = 100%Useful life in years = 100%5 years = 20% per year.
Double-declining annual rate = 2 × Straight-line annual rate = 2 × 20% = 40% per year.
The mixer's first beginning carrying amount is $210,000. Each year, subtract depreciation to find the ending carrying amount. That balance becomes the next year's beginning carrying amount.
Applying the DDB rate may leave some depreciable cost unallocated at the end of useful life. A company can apply DDB during the asset's life and adjust the final year's charge to allocate the remaining carrying amount above residual value. Alternatively, it can adopt a plan that switches to straight-line earlier, spreading the remaining depreciable amount over the years left. A switch to straight-line is not required for every asset depreciated using DDB.
True Color uses DDB through 2029, then makes a final-year adjustment in 2030. For that last year, subtract residual value from beginning carrying amount instead of multiplying by the DDB rate. This completes the allocation within the mixer's five-year useful life and leaves its residual value undepreciated.
| Year | Depreciation calculation BB carrying amount × DDB rate |
Ending carrying amount BB carrying amount − CY depreciation |
|---|---|---|
| 2026: DDB | $210,000 × 40% = $84,000 | $210,000 − $84,000 = $126,000 |
| 2027: DDB | $126,000 × 40% = $50,400 | $126,000 − $50,400 = $75,600 |
| 2028: DDB | $75,600 × 40% = $30,240 | $75,600 − $30,240 = $45,360 |
| 2029: DDB | $45,360 × 40% = $18,144 | $45,360 − $18,144 = $27,216 |
| 2030: adjustment BB carrying amount − residual value |
$27,216 − $10,000 = $17,216 | $27,216 − $17,216 = $10,000 |
Through 2029, the rate stays at 40% while the carrying amount it applies to falls. The final-year charge is the remaining $27,216 carrying amount less $10,000 residual value, or $17,216. With only one year left, this adjustment gives the same charge as switching to straight-line for that year.
Sum-of-the-years'-digits depreciation
The sum-of-the-years'-digits method applies declining fractions to the fixed depreciable amount. The numerator is useful life remaining at the beginning of the year. The denominator is the sum of the years of life remaining at the start of each year. For a five-year asset, those remaining lives are 5 years at the start of the first year, 4 at the start of the second, then 3, 2, and 1. The denominator is therefore 5 + 4 + 3 + 2 + 1 = 15.
The numerator falls each year while the denominator stays fixed. Together, the numerators total the denominator, so the fractions allocate the entire depreciable amount over useful life.
Annual depreciation = Depreciable amount × Years remainingSum of years' digits.
For a long useful life, use this shortcut instead of adding every number. Here, n is the original useful life in whole years:
Sum of years' digits = n × (n + 1)2.
True Color estimates a five-year useful life for the mixer, so substitute 5 for n to calculate the denominator:
Sum of years' digits = 5 × (5 + 1)2 = 5 × 62 = 302 = 15.
That denominator stays at 15 each year. At the beginning of 2026, all five years of useful life remain, so the first numerator is 5:
First-year depreciation = Depreciable amount × Years remainingSum of years' digits = $200,000 × 515 = $66,666.67.
Double-declining balance applies a fixed rate to a declining carrying amount. Sum-of-the-years'-digits applies a declining fraction to a fixed depreciable amount.
Under sum-of-the-years'-digits, why does annual depreciation fall even though the depreciable amount stays the same?
Compare your answer.
The numerator—the years of useful life remaining—falls each year, while the denominator stays fixed. The company therefore allocates a smaller fraction of the same depreciable amount each year.
Comparing depreciation methods
Suppose True Color plans to use the mixer heavily at first, then gradually shift production to another line. Its accountant compares how the methods would allocate the mixer's cost across those years. The business question is which allocation best reflects the service True Color expects to obtain from the mixer. The company must support its choice with operating evidence.
For this comparison, assume the mixer processes 250,000 gallons in 2026, 230,000 in 2027, 210,000 in 2028, 180,000 in 2029, and 130,000 in 2030. That totals the estimated 1,000,000 gallons over its useful life. Assume no estimate changes, impairment, or early disposal.
The table shows alternative depreciation schedules for that same mixer, not charges that True Color records together. Read each column to see when it allocates the $200,000 depreciable amount.
| Year | Straight-line | Units of production | Double-declining balance | Sum-of-the-years'-digits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $40,000 | $50,000 | $84,000 | $66,666.67 |
| 2027 | $40,000 | $46,000 | $50,400 | $53,333.33 |
| 2028 | $40,000 | $42,000 | $30,240 | $40,000 |
| 2029 | $40,000 | $36,000 | $18,144 | $26,666.67 |
| 2030 | $40,000 | $26,000 | $17,216 | $13,333.33 |
| Total allocation | $200,000 | $200,000 | $200,000 | $200,000 |
Each schedule ends with $10,000 of carrying amount. The rounded sum-of-the-years'-digits amounts total exactly $200,000. The final declining-balance charge allocates the remaining amount above residual value under the stated convention.
Straight-line assigns equal annual amounts. Units of production follows gallons processed, so its charges decline here because assumed production declines. Declining charges are built into the accelerated methods, regardless of this particular production schedule. A larger charge leaves a lower carrying amount at that date, while total depreciation stays the same.
The depreciation entry credits accumulated depreciation rather than Cash. It allocates an existing recorded cost; it does not record another payment for the mixer. Choosing a depreciation method therefore changes the timing of cost allocation, not the acquisition cost or cash payments.
Annual depreciation (US dollars)
Carrying amount over time (US dollars)
Every method starts at $210,000.00. Subsequent points are year-end balances. The dashed line marks residual value of $10,000.00.
Annual depreciation stays equal while carrying amount falls by the same amount each year.
View exact annual amounts
| Year | Beginning carrying amount | Depreciation | Ending carrying amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $210,000.00 | $40,000.00 | $170,000.00 |
| 2027 | $170,000.00 | $40,000.00 | $130,000.00 |
| 2028 | $130,000.00 | $40,000.00 | $90,000.00 |
| 2029 | $90,000.00 | $40,000.00 | $50,000.00 |
| 2030 | $50,000.00 | $40,000.00 | $10,000.00 |
Annual depreciation (US dollars)
Carrying amount over time (US dollars)
Every method starts at $210,000.00. Subsequent points are year-end balances. The dashed line marks residual value of $10,000.00.
Annual depreciation follows gallons processed, not elapsed time. The declining charges here reflect the production estimates in this example.
View exact annual amounts
| Year | Beginning carrying amount | Depreciation | Ending carrying amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $210,000.00 | $50,000.00 | $160,000.00 |
| 2027 | $160,000.00 | $46,000.00 | $114,000.00 |
| 2028 | $114,000.00 | $42,000.00 | $72,000.00 |
| 2029 | $72,000.00 | $36,000.00 | $36,000.00 |
| 2030 | $36,000.00 | $26,000.00 | $10,000.00 |
Annual depreciation (US dollars)
Carrying amount over time (US dollars)
Every method starts at $210,000.00. Subsequent points are year-end balances. The dashed line marks residual value of $10,000.00.
From 2026 through 2029, depreciation is 40% of beginning carrying amount. In 2030, the planned switch to straight-line allocates the remaining amount above residual value; the final charge is not 40%.
View exact annual amounts
| Year | Beginning carrying amount | Depreciation | Ending carrying amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $210,000.00 | $84,000.00 | $126,000.00 |
| 2027 | $126,000.00 | $50,400.00 | $75,600.00 |
| 2028 | $75,600.00 | $30,240.00 | $45,360.00 |
| 2029 | $45,360.00 | $18,144.00 | $27,216.00 |
| 2030 | $27,216.00 | $17,216.00 | $10,000.00 |
Annual depreciation (US dollars)
Carrying amount over time (US dollars)
Every method starts at $210,000.00. Subsequent points are year-end balances. The dashed line marks residual value of $10,000.00.
The depreciable amount stays fixed. Each year, a smaller fraction of that amount becomes depreciation.
View exact annual amounts
| Year | Beginning carrying amount | Depreciation | Ending carrying amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $210,000.00 | $66,666.67 | $143,333.33 |
| 2027 | $143,333.33 | $53,333.33 | $90,000.00 |
| 2028 | $90,000.00 | $40,000.00 | $50,000.00 |
| 2029 | $50,000.00 | $26,666.67 | $23,333.33 |
| 2030 | $23,333.33 | $13,333.33 | $10,000.00 |
Selecting a method from the operating facts
Suppose True Color finds from its maintenance records that mixer wear follows gallons processed more closely than elapsed time. If gallons reliably measure service consumed, True Color would select units of production. If the mixer instead provides even service through its availability, True Color would select straight-line. Greater early productivity or rising maintenance costs could instead support an accelerated method. True Color must justify that allocation from the expected operating conditions, not merely from the method's name.
True Color includes the mixer's depreciation in manufacturing overhead and allocates that overhead to the paint it produces. The allocated cost stays in inventory until True Color sells the paint, when it becomes cost of goods sold. A difference in depreciation therefore does not necessarily produce an immediate, equal difference in income statement expense.
True Color's maintenance records indicate that mixer wear follows gallons processed. A used equipment dealer also reports that mixers lose most of their resale price in their first 2 years. Which method fits these facts: straight-line, units of production, or an accelerated method?
Compare your answer.
Units of production fits these facts if gallons reliably measure service consumed. The falling resale price is not a reason to choose an accelerated method, because depreciation allocates cost and does not measure market value. Straight-line's lower first-year charge is also not a reason to choose straight-line.
- Mistaken idea: Depreciation method is a convenience choice
Correction: Hold cost, residual value, useful life, and readiness date constant. Compare how each method assigns the same depreciable amount across periods. Then choose a method that fits the asset's expected use. Consider activity, the passage of time, and any greater early productivity or rising maintenance costs. ASC 360-10-35-4 requires a systematic and rational allocation. Under ASC 360-10-35-7, declining balance can fit an asset that is more productive in its early years. Neither paragraph permits choosing a method to reach a target income.
Read the full explanation
Depreciation on the tax return
Depreciation in financial statements follows GAAP. Depreciation deductions on a US income tax return follow tax law, so the same asset can have different annual amounts under the two systems.
For many tangible assets, tax depreciation follows the Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS). Those rules specify recovery periods and methods rather than relying on the company's estimate of useful service. See IRS Publication 946 for the tax rules. This course does not calculate tax depreciation.
A tax deduction is not automatically an acceptable depreciation expense for financial reporting. A company cannot use tax recovery deductions for that purpose when the recovery period falls outside a reasonable range of useful life (ASC 360-10-35-9). ACC 301 covers the deferred income taxes that can result from differences between financial reporting and tax depreciation.
Depreciation across reporting periods
An asset can become ready for use partway through a reporting year. For a method based on time, the company must determine what portion of the annual depreciation belongs in that reporting period. A method based on actual use instead measures activity during the period.
When depreciation begins
Depreciation begins when an asset is ready for its intended use. Purchase, payment, and the first revenue earned from the asset need not occur on that date. Readiness makes the asset available to provide service.
The seller's invoice for Double Feature's projector was dated March 1, 2026. After delivery, installation, and testing, the projector became ready on April 1 at a recorded cost of $84,000. Double Feature therefore excludes March from depreciation. The projector is available to provide service in April even if screenings begin later.
Double Feature expects even service over a 6-year useful life and estimates residual value of $12,000. It uses straight-line depreciation under those original estimates.
Depreciable amount = Cost − Residual value = $84,000 − $12,000 = $72,000.
Annual depreciation = Depreciable amountUseful life = $72,0006 years = $12,000.
Calculating depreciation for a partial year
For a time-based allocation, multiply the annual depreciation by the fraction of the year included in the reporting period. Under a monthly convention, that fraction is the months available for use divided by 12 months.
Partial-year depreciation = Annual depreciation × Fraction of the year in service.
Double Feature uses a monthly convention and counts each full month the projector is available. April through December gives 9 months out of 12 for the first reporting year.
2026 depreciation = Annual depreciation × Months in service12 = $12,000 × 912 = $9,000.
Carrying amount, December 31, 2026 = Beginning carrying amount − Period depreciation = $84,000 − $9,000 = $75,000.
The straight-line depreciation refresher shows this calculation, the December 31 entry, and a practice question.
If the original estimates remained unchanged and the projector stayed in use, each intervening full year would receive $12,000. The final 3 months would fall in January through March 2032.
Final-period depreciation = Annual depreciation × Months remaining in useful life12 = $12,000 × 312 = $3,000.
The initial 9 months, intervening full years, and final 3 months span 6 years of service across 7 calendar years. The reporting-year boundaries do not change the total useful life.
Assume no estimate changes or early disposal. The dots mark the start of depreciation on April 1, 2026, and its end on March 31, 2032. The amount below each year is the depreciation recorded for that calendar year.
Depreciation begins
Depreciation ends
Activity-based depreciation and partial periods
The projector example prorates an annual depreciation because straight-line measures service by time. Under an activity method, actual production during the period already measures use. Suppose True Color's mixer becomes ready on September 1, 2026. It produces 250,000 gallons from September through December. Use the depreciation rate of $0.20 per gallon calculated in the earlier units-of-production example.
2026 depreciation = Actual gallons processed × Depreciation per gallon = 250,000 gallons × $0.20 = $50,000.
The recorded gallons already measure production after readiness. Multiplying by 412 would treat some of those actual gallons as if they had not been produced. No additional calendar adjustment is needed. Use a time fraction for a time-based allocation and actual activity for an activity-based allocation.
Depreciation conventions
A depreciation convention sets how a company counts a partial year. Double Feature counts full months from the month the asset becomes ready for use. A half-year convention counts half a year in the first year and half in the final year, regardless of the exact readiness date. This simplifies recordkeeping but is appropriate only when it reasonably approximates the service provided.
Partial years under accelerated methods
Accelerated charges change as an asset ages. The additional application below uses a convention that splits each service year's charge across the calendar years it overlaps. Other reasonable conventions can produce different allocations.
Additional worked example: accelerated depreciation across calendar years.
For this DDB timing example, assume the mixer becomes ready on April 1, 2026. Here, a service year is a 12-month period beginning on the readiness date or its anniversary. The first runs from April 2026 through March 2027; the second runs from April 2027 through March 2028.
First calculate the charges for those full service years. The cost, rate, and useful life are unchanged from the January example:
First service-year depreciation = Beginning carrying amount × DDB rate = $210,000 × 40% = $84,000.
Carrying amount after the first service year = Beginning carrying amount − Service-year depreciation = $210,000 − $84,000 = $126,000.
Second service-year depreciation = Beginning carrying amount × DDB rate = $126,000 × 40% = $50,400.
The shaded portions belong to calendar 2027: $21,000 + $37,800 = $58,800.
Calendar 2026 contains the first 9 months of the first service year. Calendar 2027 contains its final 3 months and the first 9 months of the second. Allocate each full service-year charge to the months falling in each calendar year:
| Period | Depreciation Service-year depreciation × Fraction of service year |
|---|---|
| April–December 2026 | $84,000 × 912 = $63,000 |
| January–March 2027 | $84,000 × 312 = $21,000 |
| April–December 2027 | $50,400 × 912 = $37,800 |
2027 total = January–March depreciation + April–December depreciation
= $21,000 + $37,800 = $58,800.
A new January does not restart the asset's first year of service. Identify the boundaries of each service year before splitting charges between reporting years.
When depreciation ends
Stop depreciating an asset when its depreciable amount has been fully allocated, when it is disposed of, or when it qualifies as held for sale (ASC 360-10-35-43). Chapter 21 explains the held-for-sale criteria.
An asset can remain in use after it is fully depreciated. Record no further depreciation under unchanged estimates, but keep its cost and accumulated depreciation in the accounts until disposal.
A temporary shutdown does not ordinarily stop time-based depreciation. Under an activity method, however, no measured use means no depreciation for that period.
Depreciating components and groups of assets
The methods discussed so far treat each piece of equipment as a single asset. Companies must also determine which costs belong together for depreciation. They may depreciate significant components separately or combine suitable assets in a pool. In either case, the company must allocate depreciable cost systematically and rationally (ASC 360-10-35-4).
Depreciating significant components separately
A machine may contain significant parts with different useful lives. Component depreciation allocates each part's cost over its own estimated useful life rather than using one life for the whole machine.
For this alternative, True Color divides the mixer's cost between two components: the drive mechanism and the mixer body. Both are ready at the beginning of 2026, but the drive will need replacement sooner than the body. True Color therefore estimates a separate useful life and residual value for each component, replacing the earlier estimates for the mixer as a whole.
| Component | Cost | Useful life | Residual value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Drive mechanism | $70,000 | 3 years | $0 |
| Mixer body | $140,000 | 7 years | $10,000 |
| Total | $210,000 | $10,000 |
True Color applies the straight-line calculation to each component's own cost, residual value, and useful life. It then adds the component charges to find depreciation for the whole mixer.
Drive depreciable amount = Drive cost − Drive residual value = $70,000 − $0 = $70,000.
Annual drive depreciation = Drive depreciable amountDrive useful life = $70,0003 years = $23,333.33.
Body depreciable amount = Body cost − Body residual value = $140,000 − $10,000 = $130,000.
Annual body depreciation = Body depreciable amountBody useful life = $130,0007 years = $18,571.43.
Combined annual depreciation = Annual drive depreciation + Annual body depreciation = $23,333.33 + $18,571.43 = $41,904.76.
The displayed annual amounts are rounded to cents. The final charge for each component must complete its depreciable amount without reducing carrying amount below residual value.
Both original components receive depreciation during the initial 3 years. After that, the original drive has no depreciable amount remaining. Depreciation for a replacement would require separate facts about its cost, readiness, and estimated service.
The $40,000 charge under the earlier estimate for the whole mixer and $41,904.76 component charge are alternatives. Both approaches allocate the same total depreciable amount of $200,000 for the original mixer. Separate component lives change when that cost is allocated, not the total: the drive's allocation ends after three years, while the body's continues for seven. Any replacement drive has its own cost and depreciation. Separate records also make it possible to remove a replaced component's cost and accumulated depreciation, as in Chapter 19.
An airline expects to replace an aircraft's cabin seats several times before retiring the airframe. What would be wrong with depreciating the original seats over the airframe's useful life?
Compare your answer.
That would allocate some of the original seats' cost to periods after the airline expects to replace them. Depreciating the seats separately allocates their cost over their own expected use, while the airframe's depreciation continues over its longer useful life.
Components under US GAAP and international standards
For significant components with different useful lives, separate depreciation is generally optional under US GAAP but required under International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). A company using US GAAP may therefore depreciate the asset as a whole, while a company using IFRS must account for those components separately.
Under International Accounting Standard (IAS) 16, paragraph 43, a company depreciates each significant part separately. It may group significant parts with the same useful life and method (paragraph 45). Parts that are not individually significant still receive depreciation; the company may depreciate them together as the rest of the asset (paragraph 46). See the External Reporting Board's IAS 16 equivalent.
Depreciating groups of assets
A company may own many assets whose individual retirement dates are difficult to predict. Tracking depreciation item by item can require substantial work without improving the allocation. Pooling lets the company estimate service across a collection of assets instead.
Group depreciation pools similar assets; composite depreciation pools dissimilar assets. The company develops a rate from the pool's costs and expected useful lives. Individual items may retire earlier or later than expected while the pool as a whole follows its estimated service pattern.
Under traditional pooled accounting, some items last longer or recover more on disposal than expected; others last less time or recover less. The company accounts for those differences across the pool rather than measuring a gain or loss on each item.
For an ordinary retirement within the pool's expected pattern, the company recognizes neither an individual gain nor an individual loss. It removes the item's original cost and adjusts pooled accumulated depreciation for the difference between cost and proceeds. This treatment does not automatically apply to an unusual loss, impairment, or disposal of the entire pool; those require separate analysis.
True Color depreciates its warehouse handling equipment as one composite pool. The equipment became ready on January 1, 2026. The pool contains forklifts and pallet jacks with different useful lives. True Color first calculates straight-line depreciation for each kind.
| Equipment in the pool | Cost | Residual value | Useful life |
|---|---|---|---|
| Forklifts | $100,000 | $10,000 | 6 years |
| Pallet jacks | $25,000 | $0 | 5 years |
First calculate each category's annual depreciation, then add the charges:
Forklift depreciable amount = Forklift cost − Forklift residual value = $100,000 − $10,000 = $90,000.
Annual forklift depreciation = Forklift depreciable amountForklift useful life = $90,0006 years = $15,000.
Annual pallet jack depreciation = Pallet jack cost − Pallet jack residual valuePallet jack useful life = $25,000 − $05 years = $5,000.
Total annual depreciation = Annual forklift depreciation + Annual pallet jack depreciation = $15,000 + $5,000 = $20,000.
A group pool combines similar assets, such as forklifts alone. This composite pool combines different kinds of equipment.
The composite rate expresses the total annual depreciation as a percentage of the pool's original cost. Dividing annual depreciation by total cost produces a rate the company can apply to the cost of equipment remaining in the pool. Residual value has already been deducted in calculating the annual depreciations; the rate's denominator is total cost, not depreciable amount.
Composite rate = Total annual depreciationTotal pool cost = $20,000$125,000 = 0.16 = 16% per year.
The composite life answers a different question: how long would the initial pool's depreciable amount last at that annual depreciation? Divide cost less residual value by annual depreciation. The combined allocation period does not predict that each individual asset will last that long.
Pool depreciable amount = Total pool cost − Total pool residual value = $125,000 − $10,000 = $115,000.
Composite life = Pool depreciable amountTotal annual depreciation = $115,000$20,000 = 5.75 years.
Each year, True Color applies the 16% rate to the cost of the equipment still in the pool. For 2026, depreciation is $125,000 × 16% = $20,000. If no equipment left the pool, that charge would allocate the pool's depreciable amount in 5.75 years.
On January 1, 2028, True Color sells one forklift from the pool for $6,000 cash. The forklift cost $20,000. Assume this is an ordinary retirement under the pool's continuing replacement pattern. True Color records the cash, removes the original cost, and debits accumulated depreciation for the difference:
Accumulated depreciation removed = Asset cost − Proceeds = $20,000 − $6,000 = $14,000.
That debit does not mean True Color had separately recorded $14,000 of depreciation on this forklift. It adjusts the pooled accumulated depreciation account. Individual retirement differences remain part of the pool's allocation instead of producing a separate disposal gain or loss.
True Color then applies the composite rate to the cost left in the pool:
Remaining pool cost = Pool cost before sale − Cost of asset sold = $125,000 − $20,000 = $105,000.
2028 depreciation = Remaining pool cost × Composite rate = $105,000 × 16% = $16,800.
On January 1, 2029, True Color sells a pallet jack from the same pool for $1,000 cash. The pallet jack cost $5,000. Prepare the entry. Does True Color report a gain or loss?
Compare your answer.
Accumulated depreciation removed = Asset cost − Proceeds = $5,000 − $1,000 = $4,000.
True Color reports no gain or loss for this ordinary retirement. The debit adjusts pooled accumulated depreciation.
Revising depreciation estimates
An asset may wear out sooner, remain useful longer, or have a different expected residual value than the company first estimated. Revising those estimates because of new information is a change in accounting estimate. The company allocates the remaining depreciable cost over the service it now expects from the asset, following its depreciation method. Remaining service may be measured in years, operating hours, or units of output.
The company does not redo earlier depreciation: those charges reflected the information available then. Instead, it uses the revised estimates from the change date forward. This is prospective treatment (ASC 250-10-45-17). Correcting a mistake in the earlier accounting is different; we address errors later in this section.
For straight-line depreciation, start with carrying amount at the change date, subtract the revised residual value, and divide by the revised remaining useful life. Carrying amount represents the cost still on the books; the revised estimates determine how much of that cost to allocate and over how many years.
Double Feature originally expected its $84,000 projector to provide service for 6 years, with residual value of $12,000. It became ready on April 1, 2026, and the company uses straight-line depreciation.
On January 1, 2028, an engineering inspection and revised screening plans provide new information. Double Feature now expects to use the projector for four years from January 1, 2028, through December 31, 2031, and estimates residual value of $7,000 at the end of that period. The projector has already provided service for 1 year and 9 months. The original estimate would have left 4 years and 3 months. The revision both shortens remaining life and lowers residual value.
Calculating revised depreciation
For straight-line depreciation, the revised calculation is:
Remaining depreciable amount = Carrying amount at change date − Revised residual value.
Revised annual depreciation = Remaining depreciable amountRevised remaining useful life.
First establish carrying amount on January 1, 2028. In the earlier partial-year example, we calculated the projector's annual straight-line depreciation and its 2026 partial-year depreciation. Those original estimates also apply throughout 2027:
Annual depreciation = Depreciable amountOriginal useful life = $72,0006 years = $12,000.
| Period | Depreciation calculation |
|---|---|
| April–December 2026 | Annual depreciation × Fraction of year in service $12,000 × 912 = $9,000 |
| 2027 | Full year at the original annual depreciation: $12,000 |
| Accumulated depreciation (A/D), January 1, 2028 | $9,000 + $12,000 = $21,000 |
Next, subtract accumulated depreciation from original cost to find carrying amount at the revision date.
Carrying amount = Recorded cost − Accumulated depreciation = $84,000 − $21,000 = $63,000.
Double Feature has already allocated $21,000 to earlier periods. It leaves those charges unchanged. The cost remaining to allocate is carrying amount less revised residual value.
Remaining depreciable amount = Carrying amount at change date − Revised residual value = $63,000 − $7,000 = $56,000.
Revised annual depreciation = Remaining depreciable amountRevised remaining useful life = $56,0004 years = $14,000 per year.
$21,000Carrying amount, January 1, 2028
$63,000
The lower residual value leaves more cost to allocate, and the shorter remaining life spreads it over fewer years. Both changes increase annual depreciation from $12,000 to $14,000. The revised estimates apply from January 1, 2028, forward. Earlier depreciation remains valid because the original estimates were reasonable based on the information available at the time.
Because the revision affects future periods, Double Feature discloses its effect on current-period income from continuing operations, net income, and any related per-share amounts (ASC 250-10-50-4). The entry itself changes only current depreciation expense and accumulated depreciation:
A bakery's oven cost $60,000, has an estimated residual value of $6,000, and has a 6-year useful life. It became ready on January 1, 2026, and the bakery uses straight-line depreciation. On January 1, 2028, new information leads the bakery to expect a remaining useful life of 3 years and residual value of $3,000. Calculate the carrying amount at the date of change and the revised annual depreciation.
Compare your answer.
Original depreciable amount = $60,000 − $6,000 = $54,000.
Original annual depreciation = $54,0006 years = $9,000.
Accumulated depreciation after 2 full years = $9,000 × 2 = $18,000.
Carrying amount on January 1, 2028 = $60,000 − $18,000 = $42,000.
Remaining depreciable amount = $42,000 − $3,000 = $39,000.
Revised annual depreciation = $39,0003 years = $13,000.
The bakery leaves the $18,000 already recorded unchanged. It allocates the remaining depreciable amount over the revised remaining life, not the original 6-year life.
Distinguishing estimate changes from errors
A change in accounting estimate results from new information. An error involves a mistake in earlier accounting, such as an incorrect calculation, an omitted transaction, or a misapplied accounting requirement. An unreasonable estimate based on information already available can also be an error. Useful lives and residual values are estimates; revising them because of new information differs from correcting a mistake (ASC 250-10-20).
For example, discovering an omitted projector installation cost does not change expected service. It identifies a mistake in recorded acquisition cost. Similarly, recording less depreciation than the company correctly calculated is an error rather than a revised estimate.
Actual results can differ from a reasonable estimate without creating an error. But when earlier accounting was incorrect using information available then, the company evaluates and corrects the error under ASC 250. Calling it an estimate change does not permit the company to leave the mistake uncorrected.
A clinic's documented estimate for an imaging machine was a 6-year useful life. Its accountant calculated 2027 depreciation using 8 years. In 2028, the clinic finds the difference. Is correcting it a change in accounting estimate?
Compare your answer.
No. The 6-year estimate existed when the clinic prepared its 2027 statements. The accountant misapplied information available then, so the difference is an error. The clinic evaluates and corrects it under the ASC 250 error guidance. It does not spread the difference over future years as an estimate change.
- Mistaken idea: Every estimate change restates prior periods
Correction: A change in a depreciation estimate applies to the current year and later years. The company keeps the depreciation it recorded under the earlier estimate. It allocates the carrying amount at the date of change, less the revised residual value, over the remaining useful life.
Read the full explanation
Changing depreciation methods
New information may indicate that another method better represents service consumed. For example, changed operating conditions might make hours of use a better measure than elapsed time.
Under ASC 250-10-45-18, a change in depreciation method is a change in accounting estimate effected by a change in accounting principle. The company may make the change only if the new method is preferable (ASC 250-10-45-19). It then applies the change prospectively, as it would any change in accounting estimate. Management cannot justify a method as preferable because it increases reported income.
The company applies the new method to remaining service without recalculating earlier depreciation. For a switch to straight-line, it deducts residual value from carrying amount at the change date and divides by remaining useful life. The calculation uses the remaining depreciable amount, as with an estimate revision:
Annual depreciation after a switch to straight-line = Carrying amount at change date − Residual valueRemaining useful life.
A switch to an activity method would instead use estimated remaining activity as the denominator. The new allocation must follow the method the company has justified, not merely preserve a desired annual depreciation.
On January 1, 2028, True Color changes the mixer from double-declining balance to straight-line because new information leads True Color to expect even service. Its carrying amount is $75,600, residual value remains $10,000, and 3 years of use remain. Calculate 2028 depreciation. Does True Color recalculate 2026 and 2027?
Compare your answer.
Remaining depreciable amount = $75,600 − $10,000 = $65,600.
Revised annual depreciation = $65,6003 years = $21,866.67.
No. The change is a change in accounting estimate effected by a change in accounting principle, so True Color applies it prospectively from carrying amount (ASC 250-10-45-18 and 45-19).
- Mistaken idea: A depreciation-method change is always retrospective
Correction: A change in depreciation method is a change in accounting estimate effected by a change in accounting principle. The company makes the change only if the new method is preferable. It applies the new method to the carrying amount at the date of change and does not recalculate earlier depreciation. ASC 250-10-45-18 treats the change as an estimate change. ASC 250-10-45-19 requires management to justify the new method as preferable. A different expense amount alone is not that justification.
Read the full explanation
Disposing of tangible assets
A company may sell an asset, permanently retire it, or lose it through destruction. Disposal requires accounting for any remaining carrying amount and removing the asset's recorded balances.
Removing an asset from the accounts
For a separately tracked asset, the company removes both original cost and accumulated depreciation. It also records any proceeds and the gain or loss. Unlike ordinary retirements from a pool, these individual disposals produce a gain or loss when proceeds differ from carrying amount.
First bring depreciation up to date. If the asset remained in use until sale, include depreciation through the disposal date. If it qualified as held for sale before disposal, update depreciation only through that classification date. Chapter 21 explains when an asset qualifies as held for sale. Use the resulting carrying amount to calculate the disposal gain or loss.
For the basic gain-or-loss calculation and the debits and credits used to remove an asset, see the separate asset disposal refresher. Here, we continue the projector's history through its estimate revision and sale.
Selling an asset
Double Feature sells the projector for $48,000 on July 1, 2029. The buyer pays cash and takes control that day. There are no selling costs, and the projector remains in service through June. No earlier held-for-sale classification or impairment applies to this example.
Step 1: Record depreciation through disposal. Use the revised annual depreciation for the final partial year. Recording depreciation before the sale keeps the cost of using the projector separate from the disposal gain or loss.
January–June depreciation
Annual depreciation × Months in service before disposal12
= $14,000 × 612 = $7,000.
Step 2: Determine accumulated depreciation and carrying amount. Double Feature now totals every depreciation charge recorded through the sale. The estimate revision affects the later charges but leaves the 2026 and 2027 charges in the total at their original amounts.
| Period | Depreciation |
|---|---|
| April through December 2026 | $9,000 |
| 2027 | $12,000 |
| 2028 | $14,000 |
| January through June 2029 | $7,000 |
| Total accumulated depreciation at sale | $42,000 |
Carrying amount at sale = Recorded cost − Accumulated depreciation at sale = $84,000 − $42,000 = $42,000.
Step 3: Calculate the gain or loss. Double Feature compares the cash proceeds with the updated carrying amount.
Gain = Net disposal proceeds − Carrying amount = $48,000 − $42,000 = $6,000.
Step 4: Record the sale and remove the asset. Double Feature records cash, removes both asset balances, and recognizes the gain in one entry.
Suppose Double Feature sells the projector on July 1, 2029, for $40,000 cash instead of $48,000. Depreciation is current through June, as above. Prepare the sale entry. Which account replaces the gain, and on which side of the entry does it appear?
Compare your answer.
Carrying amount is still $42,000, so the sale produces a loss of $42,000 − $40,000 = $2,000.
Debit Cash for $40,000, Accumulated depreciation for $42,000, and Loss on disposal for $2,000. Credit Equipment for $84,000. The loss replaces the gain and is a debit, so the debits equal the Equipment credit.
How disposal affects the financial statements
Double Feature reports $7,000 of depreciation expense for the projector's final service in 2029 and a $6,000 gain on disposal. Depreciation allocates cost during use. The gain is the excess of proceeds over the remaining recorded amount.
Under ASC 360-10-45-5, the gain belongs in income from continuing operations before income taxes unless discontinued operations treatment applies. If the company presents an operating income subtotal, it includes the gain in that subtotal. Selling one projector does not by itself create a discontinued operation.
On the statement of cash flows, Double Feature reports the $48,000 sale proceeds as an investing inflow (ASC 230-10-45-12). Under the indirect method, it subtracts the $6,000 gain from net income when calculating operating cash flow. This removes the sale's gain from operating activities; the $48,000 cash receipt remains in investing activities. Chapter 11 reviews these cash-flow classifications and the treatment of disposal gains.
- Mistaken idea: Asset-sale proceeds equal the disposal gain
Correction: A gain on an asset sale equals the sale proceeds less the asset's carrying amount. It does not equal the cash received. Report the cash received from an equipment sale in investing activities.
Read the full explanation
Retiring an asset without selling it
Permanently discarding a separately tracked asset without proceeds requires removing cost and accumulated depreciation. Any remaining carrying amount becomes a loss. A temporary shutdown is not a retirement; the asset stays in the accounts (ASC 360-10-35-49).
On June 30, 2028, Double Feature permanently discards its old ticket kiosks without receiving any proceeds. The kiosks cost $22,000, and accumulated depreciation through the retirement date is $18,000.
Loss on retirement = Recorded cost − Accumulated depreciation − Proceeds = $22,000 − $18,000 − $0 = $4,000.
If carrying amount is zero, removing equal cost and accumulated depreciation produces no gain or loss. A plan to abandon equipment at a future date is different from discarding it now. The company revises depreciation over the shortened remaining useful life and continues recording it while the asset remains in use (ASC 360-10-35-47). It removes the asset when use ceases.
Involuntary conversions
When equipment is destroyed, the company may receive an insurance payment for the loss. This is an involuntary conversion: the company loses the asset and receives money in its place. Compare the insurance recovery with the asset's carrying amount to calculate the gain or loss. Account for any replacement purchase separately.
Double Feature's exterior sign is destroyed on December 31, 2027. Its cost is $26,000, and its accumulated depreciation, current through that date, is $16,000. The insurer agrees to an unconditional settlement and immediately pays $13,500.
Sign carrying amount = Recorded cost − Accumulated depreciation = $26,000 − $16,000 = $10,000.
Gain/(loss) on conversion = Insurance recovery − Carrying amount = $13,500 − $10,000 = $3,500 gain.
The gain arises because compensation exceeds the sign's remaining recorded cost. It does not measure the cost of buying a replacement sign. Double Feature reports the $13,500 insurance payment as an investing cash inflow for 2027. ASC 230-10-45-12 treats insurance proceeds for destroyed equipment as receipts from disposing of that equipment.
On January 15, 2028, Double Feature buys a replacement sign for $31,000 in a separate purchase. It records that amount as the new sign's cost (ASC 610-30-30-1).
This example uses an agreed insurance settlement paid immediately. Uncertain recoveries require additional contingency guidance (ASC 610-30-25-4), which is outside this course's scope.
The completed example has two separate results: a gain on the destroyed sign and a new asset recorded at its purchase cost. Buying the replacement does not erase the gain or reduce the new asset's recorded cost (ASC 610-30-25-2 and 25-3).