In this chapter
- Which measurement model applies
- Events that call for an impairment test
- Which assets should the company test together?
- Inventory in an asset group
- Testing an asset held and used
- The mixer's carrying amount on December 31, 2027
- Step 1: the recoverability test
- Step 2: measuring the loss
- When the mixer passes the recoverability test
- Accounting after an impairment loss
- Where the loss appears in the financial statements
- Allocating a group loss to long-lived assets
- Impairment under US GAAP and international standards
- Assets held for sale
- Measuring an asset held for sale
- A later increase before the sale
- Comparing the two models
- Impairment and return on assets
- Reading the change
Review and resources
True Color Paint makes paint for independent paint stores. It uses a mixer to make paint to customers' specifications. On December 31, 2027, the largest customer for that paint cancels its contract. The mixer still works, but management expects fewer orders.
True Color recorded depreciation to allocate part of the mixer's cost to the year it used the machine. The lost contract raises a different question. With fewer orders, can True Color still recover the amount it reports for the mixer?
Which measurement model applies
The test depends on how the company expects to recover the amount it still reports for the equipment.
- Held and used. The company expects to recover that amount mainly through use. If there are signs of impairment, it first compares the amount on its books with the cash it expects from use and eventual disposal.
- Held for sale. The equipment meets the sale criteria, including being available for immediate sale. The company compares the amount on its books with what it could receive from a sale after selling costs. It also stops depreciating the equipment.
In Session 7 on discontinued operations, we applied the held-for-sale criteria to part of a business. The criteria also apply when a company plans to sell a piece of equipment. Review held-for-sale measurement in Chapter 7.
Events that call for an impairment test
True Color plans to keep the mixer in service, so it uses the held-and-used model. The lost contract gives True Color a reason to test for recoverability.
True Color has already paid for the mixer. Depreciation requires no further cash payment. An asset's carrying amount is its recorded cost less accumulated depreciation and any recorded impairment. The company estimates how much cash it will collect and spend during the asset's remaining use and disposal. The carrying amount is recoverable if the net cash covers it.
Under US GAAP, events or changes in circumstances can indicate that the carrying amount may not be recoverable. Accountants call such changes impairment indicators. For assets held and used, a company must test for recoverability when it identifies an impairment indicator (ASC 360-10-35-21). The company tests before deciding whether to measure a loss.
Look for signs like these.
- A significant drop in market price. Used machines like the company's now sell for far less than before. The company may receive less when it eventually sells its machine.
- A major change that limits use, or serious damage. A fire damages a kiln. The company can still fire some batches, but its lower output may bring in less cash. A drop in demand that leaves the kiln idle most days can have the same effect.
- A harmful change in laws or business conditions. A new rule limits the hours a plant can run. The plant may fill fewer orders and earn less cash over its remaining life.
- Acquisition or construction costs well above expectations. Building a warehouse costs far more than planned. The company must recover more cost from the same expected rental payments.
- An operating or cash flow loss that may continue. A laundromat has a cash flow loss this year and expects more losses after several nearby customers move away. A history of losses can also give the company reason to test when it has a loss in the current period.
- Expected disposal well before the end of useful life. Management expects to scrap a production line well before the end of its planned useful life. If early disposal is more likely than not, the company tests the line while it still uses it. The line may have fewer years left to bring in cash.
Other events can also call for a test. True Color lost its largest customer for custom paint. Management expects enough of a drop in orders to doubt whether the mixer can earn back its carrying amount. True Color tests recoverability even though the mixer works as before.
A bakery takes its oven out of service for scheduled maintenance. It expects to fill the same orders when the oven returns to service, and there are no other changes. Months later, a fire damages the oven and cuts the bakery's expected output for the rest of the oven's life. At which event should the bakery test for recoverability? Explain.
Compare your answer.
The bakery tests after the fire. The damage limits what the bakery expects to make and sell over the oven's remaining life. The planned maintenance leaves expected orders and cash flows unchanged. Its test results will determine whether it needs to measure a loss.
Which assets should the company test together?
The test compares the carrying amount of the assets with the cash flows those assets generate. When several assets work together to make a product, customers pay for the product. The company may have no way to tell how much of that cash each machine brought in. In that case, it tests the assets together.
The company uses the lowest level at which it can identify cash flows that are largely independent of those from other assets and liabilities. The assets and related liabilities at that level form the asset group (ASC 360-10-35-23). Including an unrelated operation could hide a shortfall in the assets the company needs to test.
True Color uses the mixer to make custom paint. Customers pay for the finished paint. True Color can estimate the cash it will collect and spend on custom-paint orders separately from the rest of its business. It therefore tests the custom-paint operation as one asset group.
In this example, the group's carrying amount is the mixer's carrying amount. True Color compares it with the cash the company expects to collect from custom-paint orders and from disposing of the mixer, after subtracting the cash it expects to spend on both. If the test shows a loss, True Color writes down the mixer.
- Mistaken idea: Depreciation automatically captures every impairment
Correction: A company records depreciation to allocate cost less residual value over an asset's useful life. For equipment held and used, the company also tests for recoverability when an event suggests its carrying amount may not be recoverable (ASC 360-10-35-21).
Read the full explanation
A laundry chain owns two shops. Each serves its own customers and pays its own operating costs. At one shop, customers pay a single price for the wash and dry service. Should the chain test the washers at that shop alone, test the whole shop, or test both shops together?
Compare your answer.
Test the shop. Its washers and dryers earn the service charge together. The shop has its own customers and operating costs, so the chain can estimate its cash flows apart from those of the other shop.
Inventory in an asset group
An asset group can include inventory. For example, a factory may use raw materials it already owns to make goods for sale. The factory includes the expected cash from making and selling those goods in the test. It includes the carrying amount of those materials in the group as well.
Before testing the asset group, the factory determines whether it needs to record an inventory write-down. It records any required write-down and uses the resulting inventory balance in the group's carrying amount (ASC 360-10-35-27).
Chapter 17 explains how the inventory cost flow method affects the write-down decision.
Testing an asset held and used
The first question is whether the company expects to get back the amount it still reports for the asset or asset group. Start with the cash the company expects to collect from using those assets. Subtract the cash it expects to spend to generate those receipts. Leave out depreciation because it uses no cash. Also exclude interest payments that the company will record as an expense (ASC 360-10-35-29). The result is net cash flow from use. Add the cash the company expects to receive from disposal, less the cash costs of disposal.
For equipment held and used, a company adds those amounts without adjusting for when the cash arrives. These are undiscounted cash flows. Management uses its plans and forecasts to estimate them (ASC 360-10-35-17, 35-30, and 35-31).
-
Step 1. Recoverability test
Do total undiscounted cash flows equal or exceed the carrying amount at the test date?
YesRecord no impairment loss. Continue depreciation.
NoGo to Step 2.
-
Step 2. Measure fair value at the test date
Is fair value at least the carrying amount?
YesRecord no impairment loss. Continue depreciation.
NoRecord an impairment loss equal to carrying amount minus fair value.
The mixer's carrying amount on December 31, 2027
Straight-line depreciation, carrying amount, and a revision of useful life or residual value are assumed in this chapter. To review them, read allocating the cost of service and revising depreciation estimates in Chapter 20.
In Chapter 20, True Color depreciated a mixer that cost $210,000 and became ready on January 1, 2026. The company expects to use it for 5 years and to recover $10,000 at disposal. It uses the straight-line method. True Color has a December year-end, and its amounts are in US dollars.
True Color records depreciation through December 31, 2027. The test uses the carrying amount on that date (ASC 360-10-35-17).
The $130,000 is cost that True Color has not yet allocated to expense. The company can recover it through cash from the paint orders it fills over the remaining 3 years and from selling the mixer at the end.
Step 1: the recoverability test
On December 31, 2027, management estimated net cash flow from filling those paint orders for each of 2028 through 2030, the mixer's remaining useful life (ASC 360-10-35-31). True Color also expects $10,000 of cash from disposal when it sells the mixer at the end of 2030, equal to the residual value. Add the cash flows from use and disposal, then compare the total with the carrying amount. If the total falls short, subtract it from the carrying amount to find the shortfall.
| Expected cash flow | Amount |
|---|---|
| Net cash flow from use, 2028 | $30,000 |
| Net cash flow from use, 2029 | $35,000 |
| Net cash flow from use, 2030 | $25,000 |
| Cash from disposal, end of 2030 | $10,000 |
| Undiscounted cash flows | $100,000 |
The expected cash flows fall $30,000 short of the carrying amount. True Color has to proceed to the second step.
Step 2: measuring the loss
The cash-flow comparison answers whether True Color can recover the reported amount through its own use and eventual sale of the equipment. To measure a loss, US GAAP calls for a market amount. Fair value is the price the company would receive to sell the asset in an orderly transaction with market participants on the measurement date (ASC 820-10-35-2). If fair value is below carrying amount, the company writes the asset down to fair value. The reduction is the impairment loss (ASC 360-10-35-17).
A dealer in used industrial equipment quoted prices for similar used mixers. From those prices, management measured the mixer's fair value at $82,000 on December 31, 2027.
The $30,000 shortfall establishes that the mixer fails the screen. True Color measures the loss against fair value, giving the larger $48,000 loss.
- Mistaken idea: The recoverability shortfall equals the impairment loss
Correction: For an asset held and used, the company first compares carrying amount with undiscounted cash flows. If the cash flows fall short, the company compares carrying amount with fair value. It records a loss only when fair value is lower than carrying amount (ASC 360-10-35-17).
Read the full explanation
True Color records the loss as a reduction of the mixer's carrying amount.
The credit increases accumulated depreciation by the amount of the loss. True Color subtracts that updated balance from the mixer's original cost to find the carrying amount after impairment.
Under ASC 360-10-35-20, the carrying amount after the write-down becomes the asset's new cost basis. True Color credits Accumulated depreciation. A company can also credit Equipment directly or use a separate contra account, such as Accumulated impairment losses. Each approach leaves the mixer at $82,000 and records the same $48,000 loss.
When the mixer passes the recoverability test
Suppose True Color expects $135,000 in net cash flows from using the mixer through 2030. That is $45,000 more than the original estimate of $90,000. In Step 1, True Color adds the same $10,000 from disposal. The total undiscounted cash flows of $145,000 exceed the $130,000 carrying amount by $15,000. The mixer passes the recoverability test.
Passing Step 1 ends the test. True Color records no impairment loss even though the mixer's fair value is still $82,000. The mixer remains at $130,000 on December 31, 2027, and True Color continues to depreciate it.
A commercial laundry tests its pressing line, an asset group, on December 31, 2027. Carrying amount is $400,000, undiscounted cash flows are $360,000, and fair value is $290,000. Should the laundry move on to measure a loss? If so, calculate the loss.
Compare your answer.
Yes. The $360,000 of expected cash flows falls $40,000 short of the $400,000 carrying amount. The laundry then compares carrying amount with fair value.
Accounting after an impairment loss
After the write-down, True Color has $82,000 left on the books for the mixer. The company will allocate the remaining cost, after subtracting residual value, over the years it still expects to use the mixer. The carrying amount immediately after the loss is the new cost basis (ASC 360-10-35-20).
When a company tests an asset, it may also need to review the asset's depreciation estimates (ASC 360-10-35-22). If management revises the remaining useful life, it uses that revised life to estimate cash flows in the recoverability test. As in Chapter 20, the company applies revised estimates prospectively. It calculates future depreciation using the carrying amount after any impairment loss.
True Color still expects 3 more years of use and a residual value of $10,000, equal to the cash from disposal used in the test. To find the carrying amount at the end of 2028, it subtracts that year's depreciation from the new cost basis.
Annual depreciation falls because less cost remains to allocate. To find the total reduction, subtract the new annual depreciation from the old annual amount and multiply that difference by the remaining years.
True Color recognized that cost as an impairment loss in 2027. It therefore records less depreciation over the mixer's remaining useful life.
If the mixer later becomes more valuable, True Color continues to depreciate it using the new basis. US GAAP prohibits reversing the loss while the mixer is held and used (ASC 360-10-35-20).
Where the loss appears in the financial statements
The loss belongs in income from continuing operations before income taxes. If the company presents an operating-income subtotal, the loss is included in it (ASC 360-10-45-4). The mixer was used in operations, so the loss is an operating cost: cost of the mixer that depreciation did not allocate. In the notes, the company describes the impaired asset and the facts that led to the loss, and it states how it measured fair value (ASC 360-10-50-2).
The loss reduces net income but uses no cash; True Color paid for the mixer in 2026. Under the indirect method, True Color therefore adds the $48,000 back to net income in operating activities, as it does with depreciation (ASC 230-10-45-28).
After recording an impairment loss, a laundry reports its pressing line at $290,000. The line's two machines each have 4 years of remaining use. Their combined residual value is $10,000. Calculate depreciation for the next year using straight-line depreciation. If a new contract then raises expected cash flows, how does US GAAP treat the loss?
Compare your answer.
The new basis is $290,000, the pressing line's carrying amount after the loss.
The laundry keeps the loss on its books and continues to depreciate the asset on the new basis (ASC 360-10-35-20).
Allocating a group loss to long-lived assets
If the asset group has an impairment loss, the company allocates the loss only to the group's long-lived assets. For example, it allocates none of that loss to inventory. The company first finds each long-lived asset's share of the total carrying amount of the long-lived assets. It multiplies that share by the group's impairment loss (ASC 360-10-35-28).
If the company can determine an individual asset's fair value without undue cost and effort, it limits the loss on that asset to keep its carrying amount at or above fair value. The company reallocates the excess loss to the other long-lived assets in proportion to their adjusted carrying amounts, subject to the same limit (ASC 360-10-35-28 and 55-22).
The laundry's pressing line has two long-lived assets, a press and a folder. The press has a carrying amount of $240,000, and the folder has a carrying amount of $160,000. Their total carrying amount is $400,000, and the group impairment loss is $110,000.
The laundry can determine the press's $200,000 fair value without undue cost and effort. Allocating the full $66,000 to the press would push its carrying amount below fair value. The laundry limits the loss on the press and assigns the remaining loss to the folder. The folder is the group's only other long-lived asset, and the laundry cannot determine the folder's fair value without undue cost and effort.
The press now has a carrying amount of $200,000. The press and folder together account for the group's $290,000 new cost basis.
Impairment under US GAAP and international standards
Both US and international rules ask whether the company can recover the amount on its books. Under US GAAP, expected cash flows without discounting determine whether the company needs to compare carrying amount with fair value.
Under International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), management assesses at each reporting date whether there are signs of impairment. If there are, it estimates what the asset can recover from use or from sale. Value in use is the present value of the cash flows the company expects from the asset. For sale, it uses fair value less disposal costs. The higher of these amounts is the recoverable amount because the company can recover more by choosing the better of the two options. If either amount covers carrying amount, the company records no loss. Otherwise, the loss is carrying amount less recoverable amount (International Accounting Standard (IAS) 36, paragraphs 6, 9, 18, 19, and 59).
If changed estimates raise recoverable amount above carrying amount, the company reverses the loss on the equipment. A new customer contract, for example, may raise the value in use enough to require a reversal. The company caps the new carrying amount at what it would have reported after depreciation had it never recorded the loss (IAS 36, paragraphs 114 and 117). See the External Reporting Board's IAS 36 equivalent.
Assets held for sale
In Chapter 7, we used the held-for-sale criteria when a company planned to sell part of its business. The same criteria apply to a piece of equipment.
A company classifies equipment as held for sale when it meets all six criteria (ASC 360-10-45-9).
- Management with authority commits to a sale plan.
- A buyer can take the asset immediately in its current condition on the usual sale terms.
- The company has started looking for a buyer and taking the other steps needed to complete the sale.
- A completed sale within one year is probable, subject to the exceptions in ASC 360-10-45-11.
- The company actively markets the asset at a price in line with current fair value.
- The steps the company has taken make a major change or withdrawal of the plan unlikely.
True Color owns a filling line that puts paint into cans. On December 31, 2027, authorized management commits to selling it. A buyer can take the line as it stands. True Color starts looking for a buyer, offers the line at a price in line with fair value, and begins the other work needed to complete the sale. A sale within one year is likely, and the steps True Color has taken make a major change or withdrawal unlikely.
True Color meets all six criteria on December 31. It classifies the filling line as held for sale, stops depreciating it, and presents it separately on the balance sheet.
Suppose True Color will release the filling line only after a replacement is installed next year. That delay exceeds customary sale terms. Does an approved sale plan make the line held for sale today?
Compare your answer.
The line remains held and used because it is unavailable for immediate sale. Management must meet all 6 criteria; approving a plan alone is insufficient.
- Mistaken idea: Management intent alone makes an asset held for sale
Correction: A company classifies equipment as held for sale on the date it meets all six sale criteria (ASC 360-10-45-9).
Read the full explanation
Measuring an asset held for sale
A company measures an asset held for sale at the lower of its carrying amount and fair value less cost to sell. It stops depreciating the asset while it is held for sale, even if it continues using it (ASC 360-10-35-43). Cost to sell means the incremental direct costs of the sale, such as broker commissions and legal and title transfer fees (ASC 360-10-35-38).
At classification, the company records a loss if expected net proceeds fall below carrying amount. If expected net proceeds exceed carrying amount at classification, the company keeps the carrying amount and records no gain.
True Color starts with the filling line's cost less accumulated depreciation. It subtracts selling costs from the line's fair value. If the result is lower than the carrying amount, the difference is the loss.
The filling line cost $150,000, and accumulated depreciation, current through December 31, 2027, is $60,000. Its fair value is $80,000, and selling costs are expected to be $6,000.
True Color presents the filling line separately on the balance sheet (ASC 360-10-45-14). It moves the line out of Equipment when it records the loss.
A later increase before the sale
At later reporting dates, the company updates fair value less cost to sell. If the new amount falls below carrying amount, the company records a loss. If the estimate rises after a write-down, the company records a gain. The gain can recover only the write-downs that remain on the books (ASC 360-10-35-40).
To measure the increase, subtract the previous fair value less cost to sell from the updated estimate. Compare that increase with the loss still on the books. The lower amount is the gain, which the company adds to the asset's carrying amount.
On March 31, 2028, the line is still held for sale. Its fair value is $100,000, and selling costs are expected to be $5,000.
The line is back at its carrying amount before classification. True Color still owns the line on March 31. At sale, it will remove the asset and compare the actual proceeds, net of selling costs, with the carrying amount then on the books. Any difference is the gain or loss on the sale.
Under IFRS 5, a company also measures the asset at the lower amount and stops depreciating it. When the company calculates the cap on a later gain, it includes impairment losses under IAS 36 and write-downs under IFRS 5 (paragraphs 15, 21, and 25).
Selling one filling line does not by itself create a discontinued operation, so the loss and gain belong in income from continuing operations. Review discontinued operations in Chapter 7 for the disposals that qualify.
A city bus operator meets every held-for-sale criterion for a garage lift on June 30, 2028. The lift cost $120,000, and accumulated depreciation through that date is $68,000. Fair value is $60,000, and cost to sell is $3,000. At what amount does the operator report the lift, and what happens to depreciation?
Compare your answer.
The operator reports the lift at the lower amount, its $52,000 carrying amount. It records no loss and stops depreciation.
Comparing the two models
| Decision | Held and used | Held for sale |
|---|---|---|
| How to measure | Test recoverability first. If the test fails and fair value is below carrying amount, write down to fair value. | Use the lower of carrying amount and fair value less cost to sell. |
| Depreciation | Continue depreciation. If there is a loss, use the new cost basis. | Stop depreciation while the asset is held for sale. |
| Later recovery | Keep the previous loss on the books. | Recognize a gain up to the cumulative loss on the held-for-sale write-down. |
If True Color changes its plans and keeps the line in use, it returns the line to equipment (ASC 360-10-45-10). It subtracts the depreciation it would have recorded during the sale period from the carrying amount before classification. It then compares that adjusted amount with fair value on the date it decides to keep the line. True Color uses the lower amount and resumes depreciation (ASC 360-10-35-44).
Impairment and return on assets
The mixer loss changes both True Color's income and the amount of assets it reports. An analyst comparing two years may ask how much income the company earned for each dollar of assets it used. Income covers the full year, while the balance sheet gives the amount of assets on one date. Use last year's ending total assets as this year's beginning balance. The average of that balance and this year's ending balance estimates the assets in use over the year. A large purchase or write-down close to year-end can make the average less representative of the assets available for most of the year.
Return on assets divides net income by that average. To explain a change in return, recall net profit margin from Chapter 6. It tells us how much income the company keeps from each dollar of sales. A second measure, asset turnover, tells us how many dollars of sales the company generates per dollar of average assets. Net sales are sales after returns, allowances, and discounts.
Net sales cancels in the product. Multiplying margin by turnover gives income per dollar of average assets. A company can raise its return by keeping more of each sales dollar or by producing more sales from its assets.
First, compare 2027 before and after the mixer loss. Both columns use the same sales and include every other transaction and adjustment, including the filling-line write-down. The before-loss column shows what 2027 would have looked like without the mixer loss. The $48,000 loss reduces both net income and ending total assets. The example ignores income taxes on that adjustment.
| True Color | 2026 | 2027 before the mixer loss | 2027 after the mixer loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net sales | $2,400,000 | $3,000,000 | $3,000,000 |
| Net income | $180,000 | $240,000 | $192,000 |
| Beginning total assets | $1,700,000 | $1,900,000 | $1,900,000 |
| Ending total assets | $1,900,000 | $2,100,000 | $2,052,000 |
| Average total assets | $1,800,000 | $2,000,000 | $1,976,000 |
| Net profit margin | 7.50% | 8.00% | 6.40% |
| Asset turnover | 1.33 | 1.50 | 1.52 |
| Return on assets | 10.00% | 12.00% | 9.72% |
Show the table calculations
2026
2027 before the mixer loss
2027 after the mixer loss
Each ratio above is computed from the amounts, not from rounded ratios. Multiplying the rounded 2026 ratios, for example, would not give exactly 10.00%.
Reading the change
The loss moves margin and turnover in opposite directions. It lowers 2027 net income, so margin falls by 1.60 percentage points, to 6.40%. It also lowers ending total assets, so turnover rises from 1.50 to 1.52 with no additional sales. The margin effect is larger, and return on assets falls to 9.72%.
The reported year-to-year comparison answers a different question. True Color earned more net income in 2027 than in 2026, but sales grew faster than income. The company kept 6.40% of each sales dollar, down from 7.50%. Higher turnover partly offset the lower margin. Reported return fell from 10.00% to 9.72%. The comparison within 2027 shows how much the mixer entry by itself changed those ratios.
Now compare two versions of 2028. Hold sales and all other operating assumptions fixed, and change only whether True Color recorded the mixer loss at the end of 2027. Net sales are $3,200,000 in both columns, and income taxes are ignored. Without the write-down, net income would be $256,000 and average total assets $2,080,000.
With the write-down, 2028 depreciation is $16,000 lower, so net income is higher. Total assets are $48,000 lower at the beginning of 2028. Lower depreciation narrows the difference in assets by year-end. To find the effect on average total assets, average the beginning and ending differences. Subtract that average difference from the average assets True Color would have reported without the write-down.
| True Color, 2028 | Without the write-down | With the write-down |
|---|---|---|
| Net income | $256,000 | $272,000 |
| Average total assets | $2,080,000 | $2,040,000 |
| Net profit margin | 8.00% | 8.50% |
| Asset turnover | 1.54 | 1.57 |
| Return on assets | 12.31% | 13.33% |
Both the lower depreciation and the smaller asset base raise the 2028 return, and neither reflects more sales or better operations. Over 2027 through 2030, total income is the same with or without the write-down. The 3 years of $16,000 lower depreciation total the $48,000 loss, which only moved expense into 2027. Before calling a higher ratio an improvement, check which amount changed.
- Mistaken idea: Higher operating turnover is always better
Correction: Check the two amounts in the ratio before drawing a conclusion about operations. For example, asset turnover can rise when a write-down reduces average total assets and net sales stay the same.
Read the full explanation
The same reasoning applies to depreciation from Chapter 20. An old asset base with large accumulated depreciation has a small carrying amount, and so does one reduced by impairments. A smaller asset denominator raises turnover and, when net income is positive, return on assets without better operations. Compare companies with the age of their assets and their write-downs in view.
A bicycle retailer reports net sales of $1,200,000 and net income of $90,000. Total assets were $700,000 at the beginning of the year and $800,000 at the end. Calculate net profit margin, asset turnover, and return on assets. Suppose next year the retailer earns the same net income on the same sales, but average assets are lower. Which part of return on assets changes?
Compare your answer.
Return on assets is 12.00%, the product of a 7.50% margin and turnover of 1.60.
Net profit margin stays the same because net income and net sales are unchanged. Asset turnover rises because the same sales are divided by fewer dollars of assets. That increase in turnover raises return on assets.