In this chapter
- Recognizing liabilities
- Present obligations
- Unrecorded obligations at year-end
- Accounts payable and accrued expenses
- Inventory received before the invoice
- Unbilled utilities
- Payroll and employee benefits
- Wages and payroll taxes
- Employee bonuses
- Paid leave
- Accrued vacation example
- Taxes payable
- Taxes collected and taxes incurred
- Customer advances
- Dividends payable
- Notes payable and accrued interest
- Current and noncurrent debt
- Scheduled principal payments
- Long-term refinancing of short-term debt
- Refinancing before or after repayment
- Covenant violations and waivers
- Debt classification under IFRS
- Working capital and the current ratio
- Loss contingencies
- Estimating a loss within a range
- Gain contingencies
- Warranties
- Assurance warranties
- Service warranties
- Payment allocated to warranty services
- Revenue as warranty coverage is provided
A company can owe something before cash changes hands. Employees may have completed work that remains unpaid, or a customer may have paid for goods the company has not delivered. A cash balance alone cannot describe either situation. The company needs to report what it has received or used and what it still owes.
The balance sheet reports resources and obligations at a date. The income statement reports revenue earned and expenses incurred during a period. Waiting for payment to record work already used can omit both an expense and an unpaid obligation. Recording a customer's advance as revenue can imply that the company has performed work it still owes. The accounting depends on what has happened between the parties, not just on whether cash has moved.
Recognizing liabilities
Present obligations
A liability is a present obligation to transfer an economic benefit, such as money, goods, or services, to another party. Present means the company owes something now, even if it will settle the obligation later. An event has already occurred that leaves the company with a duty to pay or provide something to another party.
Employees provide work in return for pay. Once they perform that work, the employer has received their service and owes the agreed compensation. The employer still owes them if payday falls in the next month. Payday settles the obligation; it does not determine when employees earn their wages.
A budget for next month's wages describes work the company expects employees to perform. The budget alone creates no obligation for that future work. The difference is whether employees have already provided the service for which the company owes payment.
Other events create different duties. A company that collects sales tax for a government holds money it must pass to the taxing authority. A company that receives a customer's advance payment still owes the promised goods or services. The recipient and the form of settlement differ, but each company has an obligation left to fulfill.
To recognize a liability is to record it in the accounts. Recording unpaid wages includes the employer's unsettled obligation in its reported financial position. Omitting that liability would make the employer appear to owe less than it does.
An employer has unpaid wages for work completed in December and a budget for work employees will perform in January. Which amount represents an obligation at December 31? Explain what has happened to create that obligation.
Compare your present-obligation reasoning.
The December work has already been performed, so the employer owes those wages. The January budget describes an expected future cost. The plan to employ people in January does not by itself create a payable for their future work.
Unrecorded obligations at year-end
An obligation may exist before the company records it. At year-end, the company records unpaid costs and obligations that are missing from its accounts. The adjustment belongs to the period in which the company received the goods or services, even when payment will occur later.
If you need to review why unpaid work creates both an expense and a payable, revisit accrued expenses in Chapter 2.
Accounts payable and accrued expenses
Accounts Payable commonly records amounts owed to suppliers for purchases on credit. Companies may use separate accounts, such as Utilities Payable, to track particular unpaid costs. The account name identifies what is owed; the transaction determines when the obligation exists.
Inventory received before the invoice
A purchase on credit leaves the company with an obligation to pay, but the other side of the entry depends on what it received. Unsold goods remain inventory because the company still holds something it expects to sell. A service already consumed creates an expense because the company has used what it received. If the company has not paid for the goods or services, it also records a payable for the amount it owes.
When a company buys goods or services on credit, it agrees to pay for what the supplier provides. Once it receives the goods or uses the services, it owes payment even if the bill has not arrived. Waiting for the bill before recording the payable would leave an existing obligation out of the accounts.
On December 29, 2026, Millbrook Equipment, Inc., received and accepted $6,000 of inventory on credit. At December 31, it owned the goods and owed the supplier, but had recorded neither the inventory nor the payable.
The supplier's invoice arrived on January 5, 2027, while Millbrook was preparing its year-end statements. Millbrook included the purchase in its December accounts because it had received the inventory and incurred the obligation in December. Waiting until January to record the purchase would leave both an asset and a liability out of the December 31 balance sheet.
Unbilled utilities
A company uses electricity and other utilities throughout a billing period. If the final bill arrives after year-end, the company must still include the service used by year-end in its expense and payable. Until the bill arrives, the company may need to estimate the charge using service records and applicable rates.
Millbrook has recorded $5,000 of unpaid utility bills for December in Utilities Expense and Utilities Payable. Those bills cover only part of December's service. The bill for the remaining service will arrive in January, so Millbrook does not yet have the utility company's final charge. Using December meter readings and the rate schedule, it estimates that unbilled charge at $3,000.
The T-account shows Utilities Payable after adding the unrecorded December service cost.
The $3,000 estimate is the additional December cost that Millbrook had not previously recorded. It adds that amount to Utilities Expense and Utilities Payable. The ending payable is $8,000: $5,000 of recorded unpaid bills plus $3,000 of estimated unbilled service.
Millbrook knows it owes payment for the December service; it is estimating the amount. Uncertainty about the final bill does not make the service a future expense.
Suppose the additional $3,000 of utility service is provided in January 2027 instead of December. Should Millbrook include it in the December adjustment? Would changing only the bill's arrival date have the same effect?
Compare your service-date reasoning.
If the utility service occurs in January 2027, Millbrook does not record a December expense or payable for that service. Moving only the invoice date leaves the December obligation unchanged. Moving the service period changes whether the company has received the service by year-end.
Payroll and employee benefits
Wages and payroll taxes
Gross wages are the employee's earnings before taxes and other deductions. The employer owes those wages in exchange for the employee's work. Employee income taxes are the employee's responsibility, but the employer withholds part of the wages and remits that money to the tax authority on the employee's behalf.
Withholding changes where the employer sends the wages. The employer pays part to the employee and part to the tax authority. Both amounts come from the employee's gross earnings, so both are included in Wages Expense. The withheld tax is not an additional expense of the employer because it comes out of wages the employer already owes.
Employer payroll taxes are separate taxes for which the employer is responsible. The employer pays them in addition to gross wages, so they create an additional payroll expense. Employee withholding reduces the employee's take-home pay; employer payroll taxes add to the employer's cost.
Millbrook's employees earned $20,000 of unpaid gross wages in December. It must withhold $2,000 of employee taxes and owes another $4,000 of employer payroll taxes. Both tax amounts are payable to payroll authorities. None of these wages or taxes has been recorded.
| Payroll amount | Calculation | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Owed to employees | $20,000 gross wages − $2,000 withheld | $18,000 |
| Owed to payroll authorities | $2,000 withheld + $4,000 employer taxes | $6,000 |
| Total payroll expense | $20,000 gross wages + $4,000 employer taxes | $24,000 |
Millbrook uses Employer Payroll Cost for its own payroll taxes and Payroll Liabilities for the combined amount owed to the authorities. Combining employee withholding and employer taxes in one liability account does not combine their expenses. The employee portion remains part of Wages Expense; the employer portion is an additional cost.
When Millbrook pays employees on January 4, it debits Wages Payable and credits Cash for $18,000. Payment removes the obligation. It does not create another wage expense. The separate remittance to payroll authorities removes the $6,000 payroll liability when paid.
- Mistaken idea: The pay date controls payroll expense
Correction: The employer records wage expense when employees perform the work. If those wages remain unpaid, the employer also records a payable.
Read the full explanation
Employee bonuses
A bonus can be part of the compensation employees earn through their work. When employees satisfy the terms of a bonus agreement, the employer owes that compensation even if payment comes later. The expense belongs to the period of service to which the bonus relates. For benefits attributed to a year's service, ASC 710-10-25-9 requires the employer to recognize the cost in that year. If the award also requires future service, only the portion attributable to service already provided is accrued under ASC 710-10-25-10.
For example, a company promised employees a bonus for meeting its 2026 sales target. By December 31, they had met the target and earned $6,000 under the agreement. No further service or approval is required, and the company will pay on March 5, 2027. It has recorded no bonus expense or payable. This example leaves out employee withholding and employer payroll taxes to focus on when the bonus is earned and paid.
The employees have earned the $6,000, and none has been paid or recorded. The employer records the full bonus expense and payable at year-end.
On March 5, the employer pays the bonus. It settles the recorded obligation without receiving new work from the employees, so it does not record another expense.
Paid leave
Paid leave can be part of the compensation employees earn through their work. The employer receives their service now and promises pay for time off later. For benefits earned through that work, the compensation cost belongs with the work that earned them. Waiting until employees take leave would shift that cost to a later period, when they are using the benefit rather than earning it.
Whether unused leave creates a year-end obligation depends on the employee's rights under the plan. Two separate questions matter: what happens when an employee leaves the company, and what happens when the benefit period ends?
Rights vest when the employee keeps the right to payment after leaving the employer. For example, a plan may require the company to pay for earned, unused vacation when an employee resigns. Rights are nonvesting when leaving the employer ends that payment right.
Rights accumulate when an employee can carry unused leave into a later period. Rights do not accumulate when unused leave expires at the end of the benefit period. Under a use-it-or-lose-it plan with no payout, the employee loses unused days instead of receiving payment or carrying them forward.
Vesting and accumulation describe different features, so a plan can have either feature or both. Employees might forfeit a cash payout when they leave but still carry unused vacation forward while employed. Those rights are nonvesting but accumulating: the employer still owes paid time off to employees who remain and use the benefit.
An employer accrues earned paid leave when all 4 conditions in ASC 710-10-25-1 are met:
- Employees have already performed the work that earns the benefit. Future work does not create a present compensation cost.
- The rights vest or accumulate, or both. Either feature can leave the employer owing a benefit after the current period.
- Payment is probable, meaning likely to occur. The employer expects to pay through time off or a cash payout.
- The employer can reasonably estimate the amount. It needs a supportable measure of the earned benefit to record the expense and liability.
Does earned leave require accrual?
- Past service
Have employees earned the benefits?
YesNoDo not accrue future service.Employees must first earn the rights. - Continuing rights
Do rights vest, accumulate, or both?
YesNoThe general rights condition is unmet.Unused hours alone do not establish qualifying rights. - Expected payment
Is payment probable?
YesNoThe payment condition is unmet.Do not accrue under this general model. - Measurement
Can the amount be reasonably estimated?
YesNoThe estimation condition is unmet.Do not invent an amount.
Sick leave can protect employees against lost pay if they become ill, without giving them a cash benefit for every unused day. ASC 710-10-25-7 permits employers not to accrue nonvesting, accumulating sick pay, even when the general conditions hold. Unused days may expire without payment if the employee never becomes ill. The exception is specific to sick pay; it does not extend to accumulating vacation.
But if a company routinely pays sick benefits without actual illness or pays the benefits out at termination, those benefits do not meet this exception. The employer must apply the general accrual conditions above. Actual payment practices matter, even when the written policy calls the benefit sick leave.
Source note. ASC 710-10-25-2 addresses earned benefits and expected forfeitures. Paragraphs 25-6 through 25-8 address actual sick-pay practices and the exception for nonvesting, accumulating sick pay.
Suppose employees lose payment rights when they leave, but unused vacation carries forward while they remain employed. Past service has earned the vacation, payment is probable, and the amount is reasonably estimable. Does the lack of vesting prevent accrual?
Compare your paid-leave decision.
Lack of vesting does not by itself prevent accrual. Accumulating rights satisfy that condition; past service, probable payment, and reasonable estimation still matter. If unused rights neither vest nor accumulate, unused hours do not qualify under this general model.
- Mistaken idea: All future paid leave is accrued
Correction: A plan for future paid leave does not by itself establish a liability. The employer examines benefits earned through past work and the employee's continuing rights.
Read the full explanation
Accrued vacation example
Once earned vacation meets the accrual conditions, the employer measures the unpaid benefit at year-end. Payroll records provide earned hours, leave already used, and the applicable pay rates. For an hourly plan, the employer multiplies unused hours expected to be paid by the applicable rate.
Some employees may lose unused benefits when they leave. The employer estimates these forfeitures using the plan's terms, employee turnover, and past use of leave. It updates the estimate when those expectations change. Rights paid out at departure are not forfeited merely because an employee leaves.
The estimate covers all earned vacation still owed, including benefits carried forward from earlier years. Vacation Payable may already include much of that obligation. The employer records only the amount needed to bring the account to the estimated unpaid benefit.
Need to distinguish what remains owed from what still needs recording? Review required and recorded balances in Chapter 2.
Millbrook allows employees to carry unused vacation into later years and pays them for unused earned vacation when they leave. Its employees have earned 700 unused hours through work already performed. All 700 hours remain payable, whether employees take the leave or leave the company. No forfeitures are expected, and the pay rate is $20 per hour. Payment during 2027 is probable.
The rights accumulate because employees can carry them forward. They also vest because employees retain payment rights when they leave. Past service has earned the benefit, payment is probable, and the hours and pay rate permit a reasonable estimate. All 4 accrual conditions are met, so Millbrook must accrue the unpaid vacation. The 700 hours measure the full year-end obligation, including unused hours earned in earlier periods.
Millbrook has a $9,000 credit balance in Vacation Payable from vacation accruals already posted. At December 31, it compares that balance with the obligation for all earned, unused hours.
| Vacation liability calculation | Amount |
|---|---|
| Required ending balance: 700 × $20 = $14,000 | $14,000 |
| Credit balance already recorded | 9,000 |
| Additional expense and liability | $5,000 |
The $9,000 already recorded is part of the $14,000 obligation. Recording another $14,000 would count that portion twice.
Taxes payable
Taxes collected and taxes incurred
A company may collect sales tax from customers and pass it to a tax authority. The tax is not part of the amount the company earns from the sale. Until it remits the collection, the company owes that money to the authority and reports a payable.
Millbrook collected $12,000 of sales tax that it has not yet remitted. It reports $12,000 as Sales Tax Payable. The collection creates a liability rather than sales revenue because Millbrook collected the money for another party.
Income taxes payable. A company may also owe tax on its own taxable income. ASC 740-10-25-2(a) requires a current tax liability for estimated taxes payable on tax returns for the current and prior years. Unlike taxes collected for others, the company's own income tax is its cost. Payment may occur after the year in which the tax obligation arises.
Suppose a company's current-year income tax is $12,000. It has already paid $9,000 and recorded those payments as Income Tax Expense. It has no recorded Income Taxes Payable balance. The unpaid amount is $12,000 − $9,000 = $3,000, so it records the following year-end adjustment.
After the adjustment, Income Tax Expense is $12,000 and Income Taxes Payable is $3,000. The expense reports the year's tax cost in this example; the payable reports the portion still unpaid. The example assumes no other income-tax effects. ACC 301 explains why tax expense can also differ from the tax calculated for the current year, even before considering payments.
Customer advances
A customer who pays in advance has provided cash, but the seller may still owe everything it promised. Cash increases the seller's assets. Recording revenue at that point would also increase income even though the seller has not yet provided the goods or services. The offsetting liability reports the performance still owed to the customer.
ASC 606-10-45-2 identifies a contract liability when customer payment is received or due before the seller transfers the promised goods or services. Under the ASC 606 revenue recognition model, the seller recognizes revenue as it transfers the promised goods or services. That performance fulfills the obligation created by the advance, so the liability declines as revenue is earned.
Millbrook received $30,000 in December for equipment it will deliver in February 2027. Control has not transferred to the customer at year-end. Millbrook records the December receipt as follows.
Customer Advances is the account Millbrook uses for this contract liability. The name identifies cash received while equipment delivery is still owed.
The $30,000 is the full price of the equipment in this example. When control transfers in February, Millbrook debits Customer Advances and credits Equipment Revenue for $30,000. It also records the equipment's cost separately. The advance amount does not establish that cost.
Review contract accounting under ASC 606 in Chapter 8 if you need to distinguish receipt of cash from satisfaction of a performance obligation.
Suppose Millbrook receives the equipment customer's cash in January instead of December, with delivery still due in February. Has Millbrook earned revenue when it receives the cash? What does it owe the customer then?
Compare your customer-advance reasoning.
Millbrook still owes the equipment because it has not transferred control. It records the January cash receipt as a customer advance. Changing the receipt date does not satisfy the delivery promise or create revenue.
Dividends payable
A cash dividend distributes earnings to shareholders. When the board declares the dividend, the company commits to distribute cash to shareholders and records a payable. The declaration creates the obligation before the payment date.
Review the statement of changes in equity if you need to distinguish distributions to owners from expenses.
A dividend distributes earnings to owners; it is not a cost of earning revenue. The company therefore debits Retained Earnings to reduce the earnings retained for its owners. For example, a board declares a $10,000 cash dividend on December 20, 2026, payable January 15, 2027. The company has not yet recorded the declaration.
The January payment reduces Dividends Payable and Cash without reducing income. A declared stock dividend, on the other hand, does not create a liability: the company will issue its own shares rather than transfer cash or other assets.
Notes payable and accrued interest
A note payable is a written promise to repay borrowed money. The principal is the amount borrowed. On an interest-bearing note, the borrower also pays interest for the time the borrowing remains outstanding. Interest accrues even if the borrower leaves the cash unspent. Receipt of the loan creates the principal obligation; the passage of time creates the interest cost.
Suppose a company borrows $60,000 on October 1, 2026, under a 6% annual interest-bearing note. Principal and interest are due April 1, 2027. The note uses simple interest measured in months and has no fees or discount. The company records Cash and Notes Payable for $60,000 when it borrows. It has recorded no interest by December 31.
By year-end, the borrowing has been outstanding for 3 months. The 6% rate applies to a full year, so 3 months earns the lender 3/12 of the annual interest. Interest for that period is $60,000 × 6% × 3 ÷ 12 = $900. The company owes that $900 at year-end and has recorded no interest, so it accrues the full amount.
The company reports both the $60,000 principal and $900 accrued interest as current liabilities. It owes the principal because it borrowed the money and the interest because the borrowing has remained outstanding. Waiting until April to record all the interest would leave the cost of borrowing during 2026 out of that year's income statement.
If the company had already recorded $600 of this unpaid interest, what year-end adjustment would remain?
Compare your interest adjustment.
The required balance remains $900. The company debits Interest Expense and credits Interest Payable for only $300, the difference between the required and recorded balances. Recording another $900 would count the previously recorded $600 twice.
Notes issued at a discount require present-value concepts developed in Unit 4. The example here uses only an interest-bearing note issued for its principal amount.
Current and noncurrent debt
A debt total tells readers how much the company owes, but not how soon it must find the resources to repay. Two companies can owe the same amount and face different demands if one must pay soon and the other can wait several years. Current and noncurrent classification separates those repayment demands on the balance sheet.
The current portion generally includes principal due within one year of the reporting date, or the normal operating cycle if longer. The operating cycle runs from acquiring goods or services for operations through collecting cash from customers. The time boundary is a reporting convention that helps readers compare near-term obligations with resources available during that period. Principal due later is generally noncurrent, unless the lender can require earlier repayment.
Source note. ASC 210-10-45-8 and 45-9 establish the current-liability classification guidance, including scheduled maturities of long-term debt.
Reclassification changes the reported timing of repayment, not the amount borrowed. It therefore changes neither total debt nor the expense of borrowing. For example, a covenant violation can make an existing loan payable on demand even though its scheduled due date is years away.
Scheduled principal payments
A loan described as long-term may still require an installment soon. The borrower cannot postpone that installment merely because the final payment is several years away. Separating scheduled principal payments identifies the amount that requires near-term repayment before considering refinancing or changes in the lender's rights.
Millbrook has a four-month operating cycle, so the one-year period governs this debt analysis.
Millbrook owes $280,000 of principal at December 31, 2026. Its carrying amount equals principal; interest is paid, and there are no loan fees. It must pay $40,000 each December 31 from 2027 through 2033.
| Principal due | Amount | December 31, 2026, classification |
|---|---|---|
| December 31, 2027 | $40,000 | Current |
| December 31, 2028–2033 | $240,000 | Noncurrent |
| Total | $280,000 | Total debt remains unchanged. |
The scheduled split reports $40,000 as current debt and $240,000 as noncurrent debt. Classification does not create an expense or change cash.
Review current debt maturities in Chapter 9 before applying the exceptions below.
A company borrowed under a 5-year agreement, and its next principal installment is due within 12 months. Does the original 5-year term make that installment noncurrent? Assume there is no refinancing or covenant violation.
Compare your scheduled-payment classification.
The installment is current because the company must repay that portion within the next year. The original term does not postpone its due date. Principal due after the current period remains noncurrent.
Long-term refinancing of short-term debt
Refinancing replaces a borrowing with financing that extends settlement. If qualifying long-term financing replaces a short-term borrowing, the company can repay the old lender without using its existing current resources. That changes the demand on those resources, even though the old debt still exists at the reporting date.
A plan to borrow later does not establish that replacement funds will be available. US generally accepted accounting principles, or US GAAP, therefore require both intent to refinance and demonstrated ability before excluding a short-term obligation from current liabilities. Intent connects the financing to repayment of that debt; demonstrated ability supports the company's access to the funds. ASC 470-10-45-14 sets the intent-and-ability requirements. Customary operating payables remain current under ASC 470-10-45-13.
The company can demonstrate ability by completing a long-term borrowing or equity issuance specifically for the refinancing, or by entering a qualifying financing agreement. US GAAP permits either to occur after year-end, provided it occurs before the statements are issued or available to be issued, as applicable.
The agreement must establish financing terms that are readily determinable. The company needs to know what financing the lender has committed to provide; an agreement to negotiate those terms later does not demonstrate refinancing ability.
ASC 470-10-45-14(b) also requires the agreement and the lender to meet the following conditions:
- The agreement must let the company obtain financing beyond one year after the balance-sheet date, or beyond the operating cycle if it is longer.
- During that period, the lender cannot cancel the agreement or demand repayment except for objectively measurable violations. A cancellation clause based on the lender's judgment that operations are unsatisfactory does not qualify.
- No violation may exist at year-end or arise before the statements are issued or available to be issued, unless the company obtains a waiver.
- The lender must be expected to have the financial ability to provide the funds.
These conditions establish whether the company can depend on replacement funds beyond the current period. A lender's unrestricted cancellation right would leave the borrower without that assurance. An agreement also offers little repayment protection if the lender cannot supply the money.
ASC 470-10-45-16 and 45-17 limit the exclusion to financing proceeds or the amount available under a qualifying agreement. Also examine how the old debt was repaid. Under ASC 470-10-45-15, repayment from current assets followed by later borrowing does not qualify merely because the later borrowing replenishes cash. Current resources have already settled the old obligation.
Refinancing before or after repayment
Millbrook is privately held. Its completed statements receive all required approvals on March 15, 2027, making them available to be issued on that date. That is the cutoff for demonstrating refinancing ability in this example.
Suppose Millbrook arranges refinancing for part of its scheduled payment. Management intends to refinance $30,000 of the $40,000 current maturity. On February 15, 2027, Millbrook completes a $30,000 borrowing due in 2030 specifically to refinance that principal. It has not already paid the old principal from current assets. The borrowing is completed before March 15, when Millbrook's statements are available to be issued.
Millbrook can exclude $30,000 from current liabilities at December 31. It reports $10,000 of current debt and $270,000 of noncurrent debt. The December balance sheet still reports the old debt. The February borrowing demonstrates that Millbrook can replace $30,000 of it with long-term financing, which supports the classification exception. Millbrook records the new borrowing and its cash receipt in February, when that transaction occurs.
Instead assume that Millbrook pays the $30,000 principal from cash on January 31, then borrows $30,000 on February 15. The December current portion remains $40,000. The later borrowing replaces cash already used; it does not support the same exclusion under ASC 470-10-45-15.
- Mistaken idea: Any post-year-end loan proves long-term refinancing
Correction: A new loan after year-end does not automatically make an earlier debt noncurrent. The company must intend to refinance that debt and demonstrate its ability to obtain qualifying long-term financing.
Read the full explanation
Covenant violations and waivers
A covenant is a condition in a borrowing agreement, such as a required financial ratio. If the borrower violates that condition, the agreement may give the lender the right to demand early repayment. Debt is callable when the lender has that right, even if it has not demanded payment. A violation can therefore make principal scheduled for later years payable on demand. Current classification reflects that changed repayment right; it is not an accounting penalty for breaking the agreement.
ASC 470-10-45-11 generally requires current classification when a year-end violation makes debt callable. The company may expect the lender to be patient, but that expectation does not remove the lender's enforceable right.
A waiver is the lender's agreement to give up its right to demand early repayment for a specified violation. To support noncurrent classification, the relief must protect the borrower for more than one year from the balance-sheet date, or the longer operating cycle. Under US GAAP, qualifying relief can be obtained before statements are issued or available to be issued.
A grace period gives the borrower time under the loan agreement to correct a violation. Correcting it is called curing the violation. This relief can support noncurrent classification when correction within the allowed period is probable and will prevent the debt from becoming callable. A borrower's hope that the lender will wait does not provide the same contractual protection.
Read the duration and scope of the relief. A short waiver may leave the lender able to demand payment within the current period. A waiver of one violation does not remove scheduled principal payments. When future covenant tests apply, consider whether another violation within the next year is probable and cannot be cured within an applicable grace period. Such a violation can require current classification despite the present waiver.
Source note. ASC 470-10-45-11 addresses waivers and probable correction within a grace period. ASC 470-10-45-1 also addresses probable violations at future compliance dates.
Classify a scheduled payment and refinancing
Apply this path to principal due within the next year. A later borrowing matters only when it qualifies as refinancing.
- Scheduled maturity
Is this principal due within one year, or the operating cycle if longer?
YesNoReport the principal as noncurrent.The scheduled maturity places this amount outside current liabilities. - Qualifying refinancing
Did the company intend and demonstrate ability to refinance on a long-term basis before statements are issued or available to be issued?
YesNoReport the principal as current.A current maturity remains current without both intent and demonstrated ability. - Supported amount
Does the completed financing or qualifying agreement support this amount without prior repayment from current assets?
YesNoReport the unsupported balance as current.Later borrowing cannot replace cash already used to settle the old debt.
Check the lender's right to demand repayment
Use these questions when a year-end violation makes debt callable, or will make it callable unless cured within a contractual grace period.
- Waiver of the lender's repayment right. Has the lender waived or lost that right for more than one year after the reporting date? Use the operating cycle if longer. Relief obtained before statements are issued or available to be issued can permit noncurrent classification.
- Correction within a grace period. Without a waiver, does the contract allow time to correct the violation? If correction is probable within that period and prevents the debt from becoming callable, noncurrent classification can be appropriate.
- No qualifying relief. If neither exception applies, report the callable debt as current.
After a waiver, examine retained covenant tests within the next 12 months. If another default is probable and cannot be cured as required, classify the callable amount as current.
When qualifying relief permits noncurrent classification, retain scheduled current maturities. Test any proposed refinancing of those maturities separately. See ASC 470-10-45-1 and 45-11.
Millbrook owes $280,000, with $40,000 due in 2027 and $240,000 due later. Its loan requires a current ratio of at least 1.10, measured before any reclassification for a violation. Millbrook's ratio is 1.20, above the required minimum, so it has not violated the covenant. For a separate comparison, suppose the agreement instead requires a ratio of 1.25. Millbrook now fails the test, and the lender can call all $280,000. Without relief, all the debt is current.
For the same violation, suppose the lender grants a waiver on February 10, 2027, before the statements are available to be issued. The lender gives up its right to call the debt for this violation through March 31, 2028. Scheduled payments remain due. The next annual covenant test is December 31, 2027, and compliance is probable. The waiver removes the demand for early repayment but leaves the scheduled installment due. US GAAP therefore permits $40,000 of current debt and $240,000 of noncurrent debt.
Replace Millbrook's waiver with one that ends June 30, 2027. The lender can demand repayment after that date, and no other relief applies. How should Millbrook classify the callable debt at December 31, 2026?
Compare your waiver-period analysis.
That waiver alone does not protect Millbrook beyond one year from December 31, 2026. Without other qualifying relief, the callable debt remains current. Do not use the date the lender signed the waiver as a substitute for the period it covers.
- Mistaken idea: Every covenant breach makes debt current
Correction: A covenant violation requires examination of the lender's repayment rights. Qualifying relief can prevent current classification of amounts otherwise due after the current period.
Read the full explanation
Debt classification under IFRS
For debt to be noncurrent under International Financial Reporting Standards, or IFRS, the company must have a right at year-end to defer settlement for at least 12 months. A waiver obtained after year-end does not restore that right at year-end. In Millbrook's earlier example, the February 10 waiver permits $240,000 to remain noncurrent under US GAAP. Under IFRS, all $280,000 remains current because Millbrook lacked that protection on December 31. Later refinancing likewise cannot create a reporting-date right that did not exist. See IAS 1.69(d) and 72A–76. Access to the standard may require an IFRS Foundation account.
| Same violated loan and February waiver | Current debt | Noncurrent debt |
|---|---|---|
| US GAAP | $40,000 | $240,000 |
| IFRS | $280,000 | $0 |
Working capital and the current ratio
Working capital is current assets minus current liabilities. It measures the excess of those assets over those obligations in dollars. The current ratio is current assets divided by current liabilities. It expresses the current assets available for each dollar of current liabilities; it does not imply that all those assets are cash.
Moving debt into current liabilities lowers both measures when current assets remain unchanged. Moving debt out of current liabilities raises them. Neither change creates cash, although the classification communicates a different repayment requirement.
Review working capital and the current ratio in Chapter 9 for the meaning and limits of each measure.
Millbrook's completed base accounts contain $480,000 of current assets and $400,000 of current liabilities, including the scheduled $40,000 debt payment.
| Separate case | Current assets | Current liabilities | Working capital | Current ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scheduled payments, no violation | $480,000 | $400,000 | $80,000 | 1.20 |
| Qualifying $30,000 refinancing | $480,000 | $370,000 | $110,000 | 1.30 |
| Violation without relief | $480,000 | $640,000 | −$160,000 | 0.75 |
Ratios are rounded to two decimals. In the violation case, $240,000 moves from noncurrent to current liabilities. Cash, total debt, and total liabilities remain unchanged. The lower current ratio reflects an earlier enforceable demand for repayment, not a new borrowing or cash payment.
Loss contingencies
A company facing a disputed damage claim may not yet know whether it owes damages or how much it will pay. A loss contingency is an existing condition whose loss outcome depends on future events. The uncertainty differs from an unbilled utility service: the company may dispute the obligation itself, not just its amount.
Waiting for a final settlement could hide a loss that the company has probably already incurred. Recording every threatened claim could instead report losses and obligations that do not exist. The company needs information about whether a loss has occurred and a reasonable estimate of its amount. Under ASC 450-20-25-2, it records a loss and liability when both requirements are met: the incurred loss is probable and reasonably estimable.
The assessment uses information available before the statements are issued or available to be issued about conditions at the balance-sheet date. An expected cost of a possible future business problem does not represent a loss already incurred. Under this guidance, probable means likely, reasonably possible means more than remote but less than likely, and remote means the chance is slight. US GAAP does not assign numerical percentages to these terms. The examples supply a professional assessment because a claim's size alone cannot establish its likelihood.
Recognition puts a loss and liability in the accounts; measurement establishes the amount recorded. A financial statement note can explain uncertainty that a single recorded amount cannot convey. Disclosure is therefore a separate decision, including when no liability can be recorded. For example, a probable loss with no reasonable estimate leaves readers needing information even though the company cannot supply an accrual amount.
If an existing loss is at least reasonably possible, disclosure may be required even when no amount is recorded. ASC 450-20-50-4 requires the company to describe the contingency and estimate the possible loss or range, or state that an estimate cannot be made. ASC 450-20-50-3 also requires disclosure when loss above a recorded amount is reasonably possible. Recording an estimate does not eliminate the possibility that the company will ultimately pay more.
| Assessment of an existing loss | Record a liability? | Consider disclosure? |
|---|---|---|
| Probable and reasonably estimable | Yes. | Yes, including reasonably possible additional loss. |
| Probable but not reasonably estimable | No amount can be accrued under this test. | Yes; explain the inability to estimate. |
| Reasonably possible | No. | Yes. |
| Remote | Generally no. | Generally no; specialized exceptions require separate guidance. |
- Mistaken idea: No accrual means no disclosure
Correction: Recording a loss and disclosing it are separate decisions. A loss that does not qualify for an entry may still require explanation in the financial statement notes.
Read the full explanation
Unasserted claims. A company may know of an event that could lead to a claim before anyone makes that claim. It faces separate uncertainties: whether someone will bring the claim and whether the company will suffer a loss if they do. A possible loss alone does not establish that a claim is likely to be made.
Suppose there is no indication that the person who could bring a claim knows of the possible claim. For this situation, ASC 450-20-50-6 requires disclosure only if assertion is probable and an unfavorable outcome is at least reasonably possible. For example, counsel might conclude that a customer will probably discover damage and bring a claim, while judging a loss only reasonably possible. Both disclosure conditions would be met, but the loss would not qualify for accrual. If assertion were not probable, this unasserted-claim disclosure requirement would not apply.
Estimating a loss within a range
A reasonable range can support accrual even when no single outcome is certain. ASC 450-20-30-1 requires the best estimate within the range when one amount is better supported. If no amount is better supported than any other amount, US GAAP requires the minimum amount of the estimated range. Every outcome in that supported range includes at least this amount of loss. The midpoint is not the default under US GAAP; the IFRS comparison below addresses when that standard uses it.
An item is material when omitting or misstating it could affect a financial statement user's decision. Millbrook faces a material customer damage claim from a 2026 event outside its warranty coverage. Counsel assesses a probable loss between $18,000 and $40,000 and supports $24,000 as the best estimate. Settlement is expected in 2027. Millbrook has not recorded any amount for this claim. It records $24,000 and discloses the claim, recorded amount, and total loss range. Counsel also assesses loss above the recorded amount as reasonably possible. The maximum additional exposure is $40,000 − $24,000 = $16,000. Because that additional loss is reasonably possible, the disclosure must also communicate the possible loss beyond the amount recorded. No insurance recovery is included in these facts.
Consider 2 alternatives to counsel's $24,000 best estimate before Millbrook records the claim. In one, counsel cannot identify a best estimate. In the other, counsel supports $32,000. Each row below is a separate assessment of the same $18,000–$40,000 range, not another loss to add.
| Counsel's assessment | Required accrual | Remaining possible loss above accrual |
|---|---|---|
| Counsel supports $24,000 as the best estimate | $24,000 | $16,000 |
| No amount is a better estimate | $18,000 | $22,000 |
| Counsel supports $32,000 as the best estimate | $32,000 | $8,000 |
The last column measures how much more Millbrook could lose above its accrual. Disclosure depends on whether that additional loss is at least reasonably possible. The difference between the range's upper end and the accrual does not establish its likelihood.
- Mistaken idea: The minimum of a range is always the conservative accrual
Correction: When a loss must be accrued, the company records the best estimate within a reasonable range. Under US generally accepted accounting principles (US GAAP), it uses the minimum only when no amount is a better estimate.
Read the full explanation
Under IFRS, a provision is a liability with uncertain timing or amount. IFRS uses a best-estimate measurement approach under IAS 37.36–40. For a continuous range in which every point is equally likely, IAS 37.39 uses the midpoint. That specific assumption differs from merely knowing two endpoints. Do not transfer the US GAAP minimum rule to an IFRS provision. See IAS 37; publisher access may require an account.
Suppose counsel concludes that Millbrook's material loss is probable but cannot reasonably estimate an amount or range. Should Millbrook record a liability, disclose the claim, or do both?
Compare your recognition and disclosure decision.
Probability alone does not satisfy both accrual conditions. Millbrook discloses the nature of the contingency and states that an estimate cannot be made. It does not invent a liability amount or omit the matter merely because measurement is difficult.
Gain contingencies
A company seeking damages from another party faces a possible gain instead of a possible loss. Even a strong expectation of winning does not settle its right to receive the money. Recording the expected award could increase income and assets while the company is still disputing whether it will receive anything.
Under ASC 450-30-25-1, companies usually do not recognize a contingent gain before realization. In a disputed lawsuit, the company may expect to win but still have no settled right to the award. Estimating the amount it hopes to receive does not resolve whether the other party must pay. If the parties settle the dispute and the company receives the agreed payment with no remaining conditions, the gain is no longer contingent. An expected win and a completed settlement describe different events. The probable-loss accrual test does not provide permission to record a probable gain. Under ASC 450-30-50-1, the company discloses the contingency without overstating the likelihood of receiving the gain.
A company expects to win a disputed lawsuit and can estimate the award. Does that make the expected gain eligible for recognition under the probable-and-estimable loss test?
Compare your gain-contingency reasoning.
No. The loss test concerns recognition of an incurred loss. Applying it to the expected award would record a gain while the company's right to that award remains unresolved. Disclosure must describe the uncertainty without implying that receipt is assured.
- Mistaken idea: Gain contingencies mirror loss accruals
Correction: The probable-loss test does not authorize a company to record a probable gain. An expected favorable outcome can remain uncertain even when the company can estimate the amount.
Read the full explanation
Warranties
A seller may promise to correct defects in a product or provide an additional service after the sale. Both promises can involve later repairs, but the accounting depends on what the seller has promised the customer. Correcting a defective product fulfills assurance given with the sale. Providing an additional service earns the part of the price allocated to that service.
Assurance warranties
An assurance warranty promises that a product meets agreed specifications. When the seller makes a covered sale, it accepts responsibility for qualifying defects. Customers may request repairs later, but the seller made the promise when it sold the product. Waiting for claims before recognizing any cost could report the sale's revenue while omitting the expected cost of fulfilling that promise.
The liability represents estimated costs still required to fulfill promises on products already sold. ASC 460-10-25-5 applies the loss-accrual conditions to assurance warranties. The seller records Warranty Expense and Warranty Liability when claims are probable and their cost can be reasonably estimated. Experience with similar products can support that estimate even before the seller knows which customers will make claims. The amount concerns expected repair costs, rather than the product's selling price.
Source note. ASC 460-10-25-6 and 25-7 address estimates from claim experience and groups of similar sales, even when individual claimants are unknown.
An accrual records an obligation; it does not place cash in a separate account. A later repair payment settles part of the recorded obligation and reduces the liability. Recording that same cost as expense again would count it twice. New covered sales create new obligations, while information about earlier sales can increase or decrease the estimated costs still remaining.
| Change during the period | Effect on the warranty liability |
|---|---|
| Expected costs on new covered sales | Increase the liability. |
| Revised estimate for earlier sales | Increase or decrease the liability as the estimate changes. |
| Claims settled | Decrease the liability. |
Millbrook provides its own assurance warranty on reconditioned equipment. It begins 2026 with a $12,000 warranty liability for expected repairs on earlier sales.
During 2026, Millbrook sells $900,000 of covered equipment. Its experience supports estimated repair costs of 2% of covered sales. As it records those sales, it also records their expected warranty costs. The entries for the year total $900,000 × 2% = $18,000:
Millbrook pays $14,000 for covered repairs during the year. Those payments fulfill warranty promises already included in the liability, so they reduce the liability without recording the cost again.
At December 31, Millbrook reassesses repair costs still expected on sales made before 2026. It now expects those remaining costs to be $4,000 higher than previously estimated. The new information increases both the remaining obligation and warranty expense:
Warranty expense for 2026 is $18,000 + $4,000 = $22,000. The chart traces the liability from its opening balance through the year's accruals and payments. Millbrook expects to settle the remaining claims during 2027.
A separate dealer begins the year with a $10,000 assurance-warranty liability. It records $8,000 of estimated costs on current-year sales and pays $12,000 of claims. There is no other estimate revision. What are its warranty expense and ending liability? Does paying more than the current-year estimate require another $4,000 expense?
Compare your warranty reconciliation.
Warranty expense is $8,000. The ending liability is $10,000 + $8,000 − $12,000 = $6,000. Payments settle obligations included in the liability from earlier and current sales. The excess of payments over the current-year expense does not by itself establish an additional expense. A further expense would require a revised estimate of the remaining obligation.
- Mistaken idea: Warranty claims equal current warranty expense
Correction: Warranty payments settle recorded obligations. Current warranty expense reflects estimated costs for new covered sales and changes in estimates for earlier sales.
Read the full explanation
Service warranties
A service warranty provides service beyond assurance that a product meets agreed specifications. The customer is buying something in addition to a product that works as promised. Reporting the entire payment as product revenue would treat that additional service as already delivered, even when the seller still owes it.
A performance obligation is a promise to transfer a distinct good or service. Distinct means the customer can benefit from it and the promise is separately identifiable within the contract. Under ASC 606-10-55-31, a customer option to buy the warranty separately establishes a distinct service. The seller accounts for that service under the revenue model because providing it earns part of the contract price.
Some sellers include coverage in the equipment price instead of offering it as a separate purchase. Included coverage still requires examination. A customer option to buy coverage separately identifies an additional service. Without that option, the seller still examines the promise: coverage included in the price may provide more than defect correction. ASC 606-10-55-33 identifies factors to consider: whether law requires the coverage, its length, and the tasks promised. Required defect correction generally supports assurance; additional maintenance can be a service. When assurance and service cannot reasonably be separated, ASC 606-10-55-34 requires the seller to account for them together as one performance obligation.
Connect the warranty promise to the liability
| Promise | Accounting treatment |
|---|---|
| Assurance that the product meets agreed specifications | Record qualifying estimated repair costs as expense and a warranty liability. |
| A distinct additional service, whether separately sold or included in the package | Allocate consideration to the service and recognize revenue as it is provided. Advance payment creates a contract liability. |
| Both assurance and service | Separate the components when reasonable and apply the corresponding treatment to each. If they cannot reasonably be separated, account for them together as one performance obligation. |
- Mistaken idea: Every warranty is a contingency accrual
Correction: A seller distinguishes assurance that a product meets specifications from an additional service. A service warranty creates a revenue obligation rather than an accrual for its entire selling price.
Read the full explanation
Payment allocated to warranty services
Review relative stand-alone selling prices in Chapter 8 if you need to divide one price among separate promises.
When a contract includes equipment and a distinct service, part of the price belongs to each promise. ASC 606-10-32-28 and 32-29 require allocation based on relative stand-alone selling prices, subject to the model's specified exceptions. A stand-alone selling price is the price the seller would charge for that good or service separately. Cash collected for service not yet provided creates a contract liability. That liability represents customer consideration for performance still owed, rather than estimated repair costs.
Millbrook uses Service Contract Liability to track payments for coverage it has not yet provided. Like Customer Advances, this account reports a contract liability. The separate name identifies the service still owed.
Revenue as warranty coverage is provided
For coverage that promises access to repairs throughout a period, the seller provides a service by remaining available. The customer receives that protection during the coverage period even if no repair is needed. Revenue can therefore be earned without a claim, and the liability declines as the seller fulfills its promise. Treating claims as the only service would ignore the availability the customer purchased.
The seller recognizes revenue according to progress in providing the promised service. Equal monthly amounts are appropriate when equal periods represent equal progress, as with the evenly provided availability in the next example. For example, a promise to perform a single inspection is fulfilled when the seller performs that inspection. Simply waiting for months to pass does not provide that service.
Source note. ASC 606-10-25-27(a) addresses services whose benefits the customer receives and consumes as the seller performs. Paragraph 25-31 requires a measure of progress for performance obligations satisfied over time.
On July 1, 2026, Millbrook collects $24,000 in advance for separately sold wear-and-breakdown coverage. The contract covers July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2027. Millbrook must provide coverage throughout the year, whether or not a customer needs a repair. In this example, it provides that availability evenly, so it recognizes revenue in equal monthly amounts.
Millbrook has recorded the cash receipt but has not yet recorded any revenue for this contract. By December 31, 6 of 12 months have elapsed. Millbrook recognizes $24,000 × 6 ÷ 12 = $12,000 of service revenue and retains a $12,000 contract liability.
Costs of providing service are accounted for separately; they do not determine the amount of revenue earned from standing ready.
A seller includes preventive maintenance beyond defect correction in the equipment price. The customer can benefit from the maintenance separately from the equipment, and the promise is separately identifiable. The customer cannot purchase it separately under this contract. Does the absence of a separate price make the coverage an assurance warranty?
Compare your included-service decision.
The maintenance is a distinct service: the customer can benefit from it separately, and the promise is separately identifiable. Allocate part of the equipment contract price to that service and recognize revenue as the seller provides it. Coverage limited to correcting defects would instead be assurance coverage.